Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: I’d Like The Salmon, Please - Minus The Fish Previous entry: The un-holiday

Brent Bozell retaliates for the mythical war on Christmas with a war on humor

The annual tradition has begun—-right wing pundits are stirring up shit with their gullible readers by declaring that there’s a “war on Christmas”.  You’d be hard pressed to find a better example than the mythical war on Christmas to demonstrate that culture warriors are a cynical, disingenuous bunch who make up issues to get excited about to distract people from the real Republican war on people who aren’t rich.  That said, I do think that Brent Bozell really is as upset as he comes across in this temper tantrum of a column.  Because the Colbert Report expertly dismantled the scare tactics of the right in the video above—-they actually managed to get Toby Keith to sing a song about fighting for the right in the war on Christmas, and it’s hysterical.  It’s so funny, in fact, that it caused Bozell’s anus to constrict violently around the giant stick that’s crammed up there, and I suspect he got splinters.

The lyrics (written by “Daily Show” executive producer David Javerbaum) are not what you would call subtle (or intelligent) about those bullying Christians. The song jokes that idiotic Colbert-clone conservatives think Santa Claus and Uncle Sam are one and the same, “so boys, take aim.” Perhaps this joking about slaying the unbelievers might warm the hearts of those who equate Christians with bloodthirsty Muslim radicals. I’m sure Rosie O’Donnell gives it two thumbs up.


He also goes into a fully frothing freak-out over the use of Willie Nelson in another skit as a pot-smoking wise man in a nativity scene.  Seems like Bozell’s going to have to declare a War On Country Musicians along with a War On Humor and the War On Ass Splinters.  It’s no surprise that Bozell is in a huff over this show, because the more that the disingenuous war on Christmas panic is satirized, the more it loses its punch, which means that culture warriors may have to find a replacement panic to get the intensely gullible all worked up.  Of course, the ostensible reason is that the show is disrespectful to Christianity (and that Colbert must be a closet atheist), because it pokes fun at the silly things that people believe in, like the power of prayer.  And this is Not Suitable For Children, because they day your kids realize it’s cracked for grown adults to believe in angels is the day they quit believing their parents know everything.

This bit of hypocrisy is amusing.

But as usual with satirists, he is cynical and hypocritical.

Satirists have nothing on right wing pundits in the cynical-and-hypocritical department, I’d say.  I can’t think of anything more cynical than pushing the War On Christmas as if it’s a real phenomenon, and nothing more hypocritical than carrying on about morality when you can’t even be bothered to be an honest person.  Really, I’m just in love with that statement, because—-and I’m sure that Bozell doesn’t realize this, because he’s that sloppy—-he’s implicitly denouncing all satire as inherently distasteful and probably immoral.  Which, to be fair, is probably what any of us would think if we felt that stick up our asses grating uncomfortably against rectal tissue every time we giggled.

Colbert proclaimed a while back on “60 Minutes” that he never lets his children watch his shows, because they don’t get his irony. He just makes them so that everyone else’s children are instructed to laugh along.

And by “children”, Bozell means grown adults.  Because children can be told to turn off the TV and go to bed.  In fact, the rule of thumb when some wingnut is going on about “the children” is that they mean “adults that we can’t control though we think we should have that right”.  They don’t want the world child-proofed so much as asshole-proofed, where they can walk around being giant assholes without ever running the risk that someone will call them out for it. 

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Amanda Marcotte on 06:26 PM • (83) Comments

Bwa!!

Bozell’s column is confirmation of everything Colbert satirizes. He’s so pwned he doesn’t even realize it.

Comment #1: Quaker in a Basement  on  11/29  at  06:49 PM

He got Toby Keith to do this? Is there something about him politically that I’m not aware of?

Comment #2: Ben D.  on  11/29  at  06:57 PM

Thing is, they had a War on Christmas at Walmart the other day and as usual, nobody won but somebody died.

Bozell should change his name to Buzzkill, not that he’d get it.

Comment #3: Caveat  on  11/29  at  07:06 PM

Toby Keith is in no way a favorite of mine, but I’ll give him credit for how much he’s enjoying mocking his own image in this segment.

Comment #4: FlipYrWhig  on  11/29  at  07:12 PM

I was torn about buying this album off iTunes (as much as I love Colbert the last thing I want to do is give money to Toby Keith!) but now that I know it’s pissing off conservatives, I think I’m gonna.

Ben D.- If I recall correctly, TK is actually a conservative Democrat (or a DINO, or what have you) who happens to be gung-ho about Bush.

Regardless of his political beliefs, the fact remains that I can’t stand his music. Except for this one song of course…

Comment #5: kaje  on  11/29  at  07:17 PM

He got Toby Keith to do this? Is there something about him politically that I’m not aware of?

Toby Keith, while being kind of dim and somewhat bloodthirsty and hawkish, is not a fan of the SuperChristian Right Wing. More than a couple of times he’s made comments that suggest he finds them all a bunch of hypocritical, sanctimonious blowhards. (Always to my mild astonishment.)

Comment #6: Well, what?  on  11/29  at  07:20 PM

I’m pretty sure Colbert is a practicing Catholic.

Comment #7: chingona  on  11/29  at  07:23 PM

Then again, he filmed it in front of a greenscreen.

Who knows to what level he understood he was participating in satire? There are certainly plenty of his fans who would take the lyrics entirely seriously, if not TK himself.

Comment #8: Auguste  on  11/29  at  07:25 PM

I kind of got the feeling that Toby Keith may not be totally clued in to the satire, but you never know.

And any person that was not reduced to tears of laughter at Willie Nelson as the wise man who brought pot to the baby Jesus simply isn’t human.

Comment #9: mothworm  on  11/29  at  07:27 PM

(I have to ask - what is “DINO”?)

I love the annual War on Christmas. We’re pagans, so we get a big evergreen tree to represent fertility and set it up in our living room. We like to decorate the tree with “witch glass” - colored glass balls and baubles that sparkle brightly and ward away frowns. When we celebrate the rebirth of the sun god, we give out presents to one another to comemorate the sun god’s birth day. We certainly never go to any mass for Christ.

I wonder if I could get Bill O’Reilly to film our pagan observations? We also have a bitchin one at Easter that involves fertility symbols like eggs and bunnies, decorated with chocolate…

Comment #10: Ellen  on  11/29  at  07:31 PM

My sons, who have been been forced to sing every goddamn jingoistic country craptacular written since 9/11 at school, were in hysterics when they saw that bit (although they also found it more than a bit disturbing).

They were chatting about it the other day, wondering if this was Toby Keith’s way of dissing the fans that he really doesn’t like.

Comment #11: Ms Kate  on  11/29  at  07:35 PM

Actually, Toby Keith is most certainly a registered Democrat (my jaw dropped when i heard it too), and he said publicly (in April) that he was excited about BOTH Obama and Clinton, so unless something changed, he’s likely on our side right now.  And, based on prior appearances on Colbert, it seems he’s got a sense of humor about himself.

Comment #12: Thurst  on  11/29  at  07:36 PM

I prefer to think of it as a war for XMas. Best to portray our efforts to take the Christ out of Christmas with positive language.

Comment #13: chuckling  on  11/29  at  07:38 PM

I had to revise my opinion of Toby Keith several months ago when I caught a segment of him on some conservative blowhard’s talk show defending same-sex marriage rights.  Said blowhard’s shocked spluttering was a marvel to behold.

Comment #14: Lee  on  11/29  at  07:38 PM

DINO = Democrat in Name Only. Although from what I’m reading in these comments that may have been unfair on my part.

Music still blows though.

I have no doubt in my mind that some country stations will play this song in complete sincerity. Which would make Bozwell’s “this song portrays conservatives as bloodthirsty monsters” whining all the more delicious.

Comment #15: kaje  on  11/29  at  07:49 PM

Who knows to what level he understood he was participating in satire?

C’mon, Auguste. Toby’s music is offensive in all kinds of ways, but he’s no dummy.

Also, per Chingona, I’d lay odds that Stephen Colbert goes to church more often than Brent Bozell.

Comment #16: DJA  on  11/29  at  07:56 PM

seriously? wtf kid is allowed to watch the colbert report?  *I* don’t stay up late enough and I’m 25.

Comment #17: bethany  on  11/29  at  07:56 PM

I especially loved this bit in Bozell’s whine:

Colbert is so busy manufacturing his O’Reilly-esque right-wing jerk

He doesn’t even realize he just called O’Reilly a right wing jerk.
Clueless honesty. About the best that can be hoped for by a wingnut pundit.

Comment #18: flory  on  11/29  at  08:02 PM

But as usual with satirists, he is cynical and hypocritical.

Damn those satirists! Always saying one thing and meaning another. Irony is so unpatriotic. Real Americans stick to the denotative function of language.

Comment #19: inkybrain  on  11/29  at  08:06 PM

Also, check out the video for Toby’s latest single, “God Love Her.” Earfuckingly awful song, of course, but the take-home message is that the fornicating runaway daughter is happier and has a healthier relationship with Christ than her conservative preacher daddy, who never converted a soul.

Comment #20: DJA  on  11/29  at  08:06 PM

“wtf kid is allowed to watch the colbert report?”

The “for the children” argument is obvious bullshit, but the show reruns in earlier timeslots, so it’s not impossible for reasonably-bedtimed children to be amongst the viewing audience.

Comment #21: preying mantis  on  11/29  at  08:08 PM

I’m not a big Toby Keith fan, but from what I’ve heard in recent years he’s basically a moderate Democrat who got all wrapped up in the post-9/11 jingoistic hysteria and supported Bush’s invasion of Iraq.  In other words, Dixie Chicks feud notwithstanding (and that feud probably had as much to do with country music celebrity competitiveness, a la rap feuds, as it did with genuine ideological disagreement), he was basically in the same rotten place that a lot of the country was in from 2003-2006, a place that even a lot of otherwise progressive folks were in, to be honest. 

Again, I’m not a fan, but he probably was never the right-wing caricature a lot of people (myself included) thought he was.  Plus, Willie Nelson hangs out with him, and that should say something positive about the guy.

Comment #22: mistermark  on  11/29  at  08:16 PM

Oh, and yeah, Brent Bozell is a total tool.  Forgot to mention that.

Comment #23: mistermark  on  11/29  at  08:16 PM

Damn those satirists! Always saying one thing and meaning another. Irony is so unpatriotic. Real Americans stick to the denotative function of language.

Exactly!  Mean one thing, or another!  We’re at war, pick a side!

Re Toby Keith:  I’m pretty sure Colbert rubs his hands in glee anytime TK comes on his show, since he can make *everyone’s* head explode.

Comment #24: NY Expat  on  11/29  at  08:23 PM

Thanks a lot Amanda, I had finally gotten this song (along with Stuart’s Hanukah song) dislodged from my head after having it stuck there all morning and you go and put right back in.

I’m going to agree with some other posters that Keith seems to be one of those guys like Dennis Miller who was a nominal liberal who was driven a little insane by 9/11.  However unlike Miller he appears to have come to his senses, and has shown quite a bit of self awareness poking fun at his previous self.

“We’ve got candles.”
“What are they?”
“THEY ARE CANDLES!”

Comment #25: Nied  on  11/29  at  08:32 PM

In fact, the rule of thumb when some wingnut is going on about “the children” is that they mean “adults that we can’t control though we think we should have that right”.

Perfect.  Exactly accurate.

Comment #26: seeker6079  on  11/29  at  08:39 PM

so it’s not impossible for reasonably-bedtimed children to be amongst the viewing audience.

Whether it’s appropriate or not for said children to be watching is a decision I’ll leave in the hands of their parents, seeing as I’m a family values kind of gal.

Comment #27: chingona  on  11/29  at  08:41 PM

Oh look! We’re under the mistletoe.

Well this is awkward…

Comment #28: kaje  on  11/29  at  08:42 PM

I thought Dennis Miller was kidnapped by aliens who transversed his brain. tongue wink

Comment #29: RacyT  on  11/29  at  08:52 PM

The hilarious thing about the “War on Christmas” is that what’s actually going on is pretty easy to figure out.  Secular/retail/business world uses “Happy Holidays” until after Hanukkah, at which point they switch to “Merry Christmas.”  So the wingnuts get to complain about Happy Holidays and then feel all vindicated when they begin hearing Merry Christmas.  Despite the fact that this pattern held years before the Republican Death Star thought up the War on Christmas.

Comment #30: Mo  on  11/29  at  08:53 PM

Well, according to my religion, kaje, that means we need to [20 minute pornographic narration deleted—for the children!]

Comment #31: Erl  on  11/29  at  09:34 PM

Yeah, Toby Keith tneds to be a true good ole boy and all that entails.  Meaning he though he was writing his “Sweet Home Alabama” to the Dixie Chick’s “Southern Man” more than some sort of deep political statement.

Comment #32: Rob  on  11/29  at  10:06 PM

Well, according to my religion, kaje, that means we need to [20 minute pornographic narration deleted—for the children!]

Oh, I’m familiar with that religion - The Aristocrats, isn’t it?

Comment #33: Auguste  on  11/29  at  10:12 PM

What I find kind of weird is that in Britain, most Christians (who are less right-wing and less politically active than Christians here) complain that Christmas has been coopted by unbelievers into commercial cheesiness, and would PREFER that the rest of us stick to “Season’s Greetings”.

Comment #34: Dolbia  on  11/29  at  10:14 PM

Lee, if you could find a link to that, I’d pay you in theoretical dollars.

Comment #35: Lauren O  on  11/29  at  10:30 PM

I’m pretty sure Colbert is a practicing Catholic.

A very devout one, who teaches Sunday School and everything!

Comment #36: hamletta  on  11/29  at  10:42 PM

Lee, if you could find a link to that, I’d pay you in theoretical dollars.

I’m pretty sure it was Glenn Beck on CNN Headline News.  I can’t find it on YouTube, and neither cnn.com nor Beck’s website have any of the videos or transcripts (assumably because the show’s been cancelled).

And there’s only so much slogging through Glenn Beck’s back catalogue I can stomach.  smile

Comment #37: Lee  on  11/29  at  11:06 PM

“I thought Dennis Miller was kidnapped by aliens who transversed his brain.”

So was he Doleized or Gephardtized?  I can never keep them straight.

Comment #38: Andy  on  11/29  at  11:22 PM

“Secular/retail/business world uses “Happy Holidays” until after Hanukkah, at which point they switch to “Merry Christmas.”

You’re not wrong, but the thing that torques me is that, as a religious holiday, Christmas is a twelve day holiday that STARTS on the 25th of December and ends with Epiphany on the 6th of January. Christmas Eve gets counted in because of the tradition that feasts start at sundown the night before.

The morons who claim that there is a war on the Christian celebration of Christmas because people are being inclusive of other holidays in November and December are actually on the wrong side of both the secular AND the religious traditions. All they are on the side of is the RETAIL observance of Christmas - which has now, at least in our area, finally overrun Halloween in places. Everything Halloween was 90% off the last week of October, and by the 29th, we had Christmas carols playing in Walgreens and Christmas decorations hanging from all the streetlights. At least they waited until November 1st to light them.

If Christmas is at risk, it is because there will be a popular uprising because people are so damn tired of it by the end of December that it dies of exhaustion.

</rant>

My current plan is to wish everyone a Happy Holidays in the fervent hope that someone gets on my case about it, so I can look them square in the eye and tell them to be ashamed of themselves.

Comment #39: Lymis  on  11/29  at  11:28 PM

Speaking of “the children,” my kid (3) just watched the clip over my shoulder when I showed it to my husband. His reaction:

“What? What’s funny? What’s that man doing? Mommy, what’s funny? What? What’s he doing? What’s funny? What? What?”

I’m sure he’ll grow up to be a serial killer. Thanks a lot, Colbert!

Comment #40: chingona  on  11/29  at  11:30 PM

I had lunch with a Muslim friend today. Her office has a “voluntary” Christmas cookie trade. She has to (because it really isn’t voluntary—I did suggest she say she wasn’t going to participate and when they got all sad and concerned and asked why to just honestly say, I’m Muslim. But these people aren’t celebrating a religious holiday. They’re celebrating a cultural holiday—but still not HER culture. It’s a puzzlement.) make 22 dozen cookies to trade for other people’s cookies. Then she and her husband and son will have 22 dozen cookies, and no holiday. I’d be furious. She’s merely bemused.

Comment #41: Bo  on  11/29  at  11:43 PM

So was he Doleized or Gephardtized?  I can never keep them straight.

While I liked Dennis Miller once upon a time, I have to say that he was never as funny as he thought he was, so his descent from moderately funny grump to tool of tools is more like a wheelchair ramp off a curb than an Acapulco cliff dive.

Comment #42: Incertus, Nacho Daddy  on  11/30  at  12:03 AM

SPOILER!

My favorite part was when the bear ate Elvis Costello.

Comment #43: Mnemosyne  on  11/30  at  12:11 AM

Toby Keith is one of those people that lost their damn minds after 9/11, and it took them a few years to sober up and realize what they let Bush do while they were hiding under their beds.  Hey, Al Franken did the same thing (read his account of it in Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them).  I’m guessing that Keith is a big Obama fan now.

One of the reasons Stephen Colbert is so brilliant is that he so rarely breaks character.  Actually, I think he was forced to start breaking character a little bit more because a lot of people—like Tom DeLay—really thought he was a conservative and started quoting him.  Which was mega-funny in itself.

Comment #44: Mnemosyne  on  11/30  at  12:17 AM

You’d be “furious”?  You are a tool.

Comment #45: Eric, Rejector of Memez  on  11/30  at  12:17 AM

To Andy (11/29 at 09:22 PM),

Gephardtization is when they take your eyebrows.

(I hope we’re alluding to the same thing….)

Comment #46: Michael  on  11/30  at  12:25 AM

You’d be “furious”?  You are a tool.

Why? I’d be furious too if it were clear that it wasn’t actually voluntary, and I celebrate Christmas (though as the mercenary capitalist gorge-athon it is, as opposed to a religious holiday). My boss has claim on my time and effort when I’m on the clock, and that’s it. To require me to help celebrate a holiday I might not want to celebrate is bullshit.

Comment #47: Incertus, Nacho Daddy  on  11/30  at  12:25 AM

We are.

Comment #48: Andy  on  11/30  at  12:28 AM

What would be wrong with making it a law that cashiers are required to say “Happy Jesus’ birthday to you”? when you go to buy something?  Are you LIEbrals so anti-G*d that you refuse to penalize those who won’t advance Christiananity in our Christian nation?

Comment #49: Rugged in Montana  on  11/30  at  12:29 AM

I’m sorry, Bo, but 22 dozen cookies?!?  that’s 264 cookies!  are people expected to have industrial size ovens, or are they (very) mini cookies?  it’s not the xmas cookie exchange that makes your friend’s office wack…

Comment #50: olivetti  on  11/30  at  12:53 AM

A very devout one, who teaches Sunday School and everything!

He needs to satire himself in a Colbert Report skit, teaching Sunday School and the Liburul War on Christmas to the *children*! grin

Comment #51: Pseudo-Adrienne  on  11/30  at  12:57 AM

Why are wingnuts so rude that they don’t want to wish everyone a Happy New Year?

Holidays, plural, can refer to Christmas AND NEW YEAR’S for even the most Christian of Americans. So what’s wrong with saying Happy Holidays? It’s shorter than “Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!” But if you choose, you can take it to mean exactly that.

Comment #52: Alara Rogers  on  11/30  at  01:01 AM

seriously? wtf kid is allowed to watch the colbert report?  *I* don’t stay up late enough and I’m 25.

What the fuck time do you you think a 12-year old should go to bed ... before 8:30?  Steward reruns at 8pm and Colbert at 8:30pm.  If you don’t bother to watch the show on the web, that is. 

As for the xmas special, my 10 year old saw it at 3 pm on Friday.  Is that up too late for ya?

Comment #53: Ms Kate  on  11/30  at  01:41 AM

seriously? wtf kid is allowed to watch the colbert report?  *I* don’t stay up late enough and I’m 25.
bethany on 11/29 at 05:56 PM

Bethany,

Here in the heartland, we get our late night teevee at a more civilized hour*. Why do you coastal liberals hate the real America?

 

*I for example watch the Colbert report the following day

Comment #54: Samwise  on  11/30  at  01:55 AM

Here in the heartland we are also always a few minutes behind the times.

Comment #55: Samwise  on  11/30  at  01:56 AM

This whole War on Christmas thing to me is very puzzling to me. Saying “Happy Holidays” or similar includes Christmas. It just also includes Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, etc., etc. Are conservatives really just that mad that people might celebrate other holidays? I can understand a Christian having the opinion that everyone should be a Christian, but getting mad at even the acknowledgment of other religions? In a country well known for its religious freedoms and separation of church and state? My mind would boggle, but at this point I think it is all boggled out.

Comment #56: Lauren O  on  11/30  at  01:59 AM

This whole War on Christmas thing to me is very puzzling to me. Saying “Happy Holidays” or similar includes Christmas. It just also includes Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, etc., etc. Are conservatives really just that mad that people might celebrate other holidays? I can understand a Christian having the opinion that everyone should be a Christian, but getting mad at even the acknowledgment of other religions? In a country well known for its religious freedoms and separation of church and state? My mind would boggle, but at this point I think it is all boggled out.
Lauren O on 11/29 at 11:59 PM

Yes.

This has been another edition of simple answers to simple questions.

Comment #57: Samwise  on  11/30  at  02:01 AM

I wonder how old the Colbert kids are that they don’t get satire yet?

Comment #58: Ms Kate  on  11/30  at  02:54 AM

I think they’re elementary age. I guess I defer to him, as their father, to decide when he’s ready for them to see it.

Comment #59: chingona  on  11/30  at  03:28 AM

Colbert proclaimed a while back on “60 Minutes” that he never lets his children watch his shows, because they don’t get his irony. He just makes them so that everyone else’s children are instructed to laugh along.

because someone wasn’t paying attention to the interview, it seems. It isn’t because his kids don’t get irony. Its because he doesn’t want them to see him being so insincere. Which doesn’t make a difference for anyone other than his kids. If his kids got irony, it wouldn’t be a problem, and they would get he’s being ironic and it wouldn’t do any harm. But without getting irony, he’d be doing the same sort of stuff as Bill Orielly, which is pretty vile and he fears it would hurt his kids, both their understanding of things and how they look to him, to watch him do that without understanding irony.

It’s the same as Lou Costello not wanting his kids to see him perform with Bud Abbott, because they wouldn’t be able to understand it’s all an act, and he’s being so mean to their godfather, Uncle Bud. They might think it was a real argument. Which simply isn’t a concern for anyone other than Bud and Lou. So, yeah, not that complicated, but I dunno-

THIRD BASE.

Comment #60: karpad  on  11/30  at  04:55 AM

What I find kind of weird is that in Britain, most Christians (who are less right-wing and less politically active than Christians here) complain that Christmas has been coopted by unbelievers into commercial cheesiness, and would PREFER that the rest of us stick to “Season’s Greetings”

This used to be the case in American Christianity as well; in fact, I suspect the “War on Christmas” charade was designed specifically by the hyper-capitalist right and passed on to their celebrity-preacher allies precisely as a distraction to creeping anti-consumerist sentiment in churches.  I’m skeptical how seriously the WoC is taken among rank-and-file churchgoers, but at least it’s reminded them of their Christian duty to purchase expensive gadgets.

Comment #61: mel-anon  on  11/30  at  06:59 AM

Bonus points to RacyT and Andy for the welcome Bloom County references.

Comment #62: seeker6079  on  11/30  at  09:59 AM

My brother was seriously trying to be all sincere about how horrible the War on Christmas was.  He’s a firm believer that the patriarchy doesn’t exist and the rest of us are whiny, lazy people.  When I pointed out to him that saying Happy Holidays or Season’s Greetings doesn’t disallow the Christian holiday and you can take it to mean whatever you want, he got so pissed at me he didn’t talk to me for five days.  Which I took as a grand compliment and wonderful vacation.

Comment #63: speedbudget  on  11/30  at  10:40 AM

Colbert is in fact Catholic (Brent Bozell is, too, and it’s interesting that he avoids the word, because he, like Dennis Prager, knows that his masters are Protestant fundamentalists), which is why Bozell is using the “fake” Christian tactic.

Comment #64: Amanda Marcotte  on  11/30  at  11:51 AM

The Toby Keith song was awesome. I suspect Bed-wetter Bozell wrote this letter because he’s worried that his fellow Xtian fantasists will take it seriously and make fools of themselves—pre-emptive douchebaggery, if you will.

This whole War on Christmas thing to me is very puzzling to me. Saying “Happy Holidays” or similar includes Christmas. It just also includes Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, etc., etc. Are conservatives really just that mad that people might celebrate other holidays?

These are the same Know-Nothings who go on about how “America is a Christian nation” and demand “10 Commandments” monuments in courthouses and morning prayer in public schools. When used, it’s a good indicator not only of the speaker’s ignorance and personal insecurity, but also serves as a useful indicator of his anti-semitism and racism.

Comment #65: Gracchus  on  11/30  at  11:56 AM

The idea that country music is a conservative Republican monolith comes more from the corporate radio “everything in its box” mentality.  A lot of country music fans are white, uptight Christians who desire an America where their worldview is considered superior in every way to everyone else’s (and where Jews and Muslims working retail are forced to say “Merry Christmas” as a small act of submission), but it gets complicated when it comes to the actual musicians.  Musicians are artists, even in country music, and there’s obviously a tension between the artistic sensibility and the conservative worldview. Therefore the oldest story in country music is about the frequent dust-ups between artists and the management/vocally conservative fans.  The Dixie Chicks’ situation is just one of many of these dust-ups.  Some more:

*Tim McGraw wrote a song about a young couple that chooses abortion and drifts apart, as they should because it’s young love.  It’s got whiffs of regret and sadness, but what country song doesn’t, and who is really elated to have that happen?  But it exposed an ugly fact about the common nature of abortion, yes, even in the oh so holy white rural communities, and so got banned from a lot of radio stations.

*Which resembles the fracas over “The Pill” by Loretta Lynn, which she recorded in the 70s.  There’s absolutely no ambiguity in that song, which is an open celebration of the singer’s ability to control her fertility after having 6 children, 4 before she turned 18.  Banned on many radio stations.

*For awhile, it was touch and go whether or not CMT would play “Thunder Rolls” by Garth Brooks, because the video shows an abused woman killing her husband.  But I think they did play it, because the song was a huge hit.  I found that interesting, because spouse-murdering is a common enough theme in country music, but it’s usually because of cheating and other trifling behavior, but when it’s a woman defending herself, oh no!

*There’s a highway being built around Austin, and there was a lot of popular support for naming it after Willie Nelson.  But he’s a pot-smoking hippie who does “emasculated” things like singing “The Rainbow Connection” in concert, so the Texas legislature stopped it.  Which still pisses me off, because Nelson is a state treasure.

The thing is, some of the most revered figures in country music are giant honking liberals—-Dolly Parton and Johnny Cash are up there as the most respected figures, and they’ve got definite liberal tendencies (not Loretta Lynn, alas).  You work in country music, you know this, and it probably means something to you.  The fans, sadly, can be willfully ignorant, though.

Comment #66: Amanda Marcotte  on  11/30  at  12:44 PM

“I wonder how old the Colbert kids are that they don’t get satire yet?”

You can see the actual Colbert kids on the special - they appear in the doorway during “It’s Another Christmas Song,” dressed as rag-tag orphans.  (The satire is that their father’s song is supposed to support them and they are trotted out as objects of pity to entice the viewer to buy the song on iTunes.)  The oldest, a daughter, is about 14 or 15.  The two boys are around 10 and 8 or thereabouts.

Comment #67: Elizabeth  on  11/30  at  01:42 PM

Along with the general idiocy in the comments section over there, I just got a kick out of all the people skeert for the children.  What about the children who are going to watch that!  They get all their education from MTV!!!

Especially the idjit who depends on parental controls and the networks’ rating scale to monitor his children’s viewing habits.  And, durn it, they just don’t work that well, and even on ‘family’ shows those Girls Gone Wild commercials can come through.  He knows his 15 y/o daughter understands her relationship with Christ and will turn off a channel showing bad things, but his 9 y/o son doesn’t always do that.  Boys will be boys, I guess.

Seriously?  B/c absolutely nothing my kids watch ever gets them a GGW commercial.  Nickelodeon, even on demand, will get them ads for toys, but I can’t remember the last time I saw a GGW commercial.  That damn BBC america doesn’t show them! 

What kind of “family” show entices Joe Francis to buy air time?  Cause, that’s…creepy.

It makes sense, though.  These are people who can’t control themselves when faced with freedom and temptation.  That’s why they want sharia type laws to constrict behavior.  It’s just too hard to monitor kids’ TV viewing habits and constrain them to ‘appropriate’ fare or limit the amount of time in front of screens.  Why can’t ya just click a button, or have them there Nerd Herd guys click it for you, and then the Tee Vee could only show unicorns and rainbows?

Comment #68: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  11/30  at  02:11 PM

B/c absolutely nothing my kids watch ever gets them a GGW commercial.  Nickelodeon, even on demand, will get them ads for toys, but I can’t remember the last time I saw a GGW commercial.

If you watch anything past about 10:00 pm on Comedy Central, you’ll get to see more GGW commercials than you knew existed.  Apparently CC has decided that no one watches past that time who’s not a pathetic loser.

Comment #69: Mnemosyne  on  11/30  at  02:56 PM

Off topic, but, Amanda, did you say that Thunder Rolls is about spousal abuse? Because I must’ve listened to that song a thousand times and never “got” that - I thought she was killing the husband because he was cheating on her, all that stuff about a strange new perfume and “she knows” and tonight will be the last time she wonders where he’s been.

Is the abuse something they added to the video? Or was it there all along and I just didn’t hear it? I learn something new every day I guess.

Comment #70: Ellen  on  11/30  at  03:23 PM

Not a big fan of country, but it would be nice if it stopped being so thoroughly sanctimonious and ultra-right-wing (or an unofficial organ of the GOP, like Fox News is), as it seems to be every time I try to access any of that kind of music through a major media outlet. Maybe following Keith’s example other artists will feel more free to express a diversity of views rather than play exclusively to the asshats in their fan base.

Comment #71: wapsie  on  11/30  at  03:44 PM

The “for the children” argument is obvious bullshit, but the show reruns in earlier timeslots, so it’s not impossible for reasonably-bedtimed children to be amongst the viewing audience.

Not to mention that every episode of The Report is available in its entirety at http://ColbertNation.com

My 12 year old son is even a bigger Colbert fan than I am.

Comment #72: Zog  on  11/30  at  04:30 PM

It’s interesting that some right-wingers have grown just enough of a sense of irony to be able to tell when they’re being mocked. I especially liked this part from Bozell’s column:

Once again, Comedy Central merges together Christianity and Islam like they were two different brands of poison.

Funny, I would have said that that was exactly accurate. It’s right-wingers like Bozell who invite the comparison by consistently advocating policies that are different only in degree from those of Saudi Arabia or the Taliban.

Comment #73: Ebonmuse  on  11/30  at  04:50 PM

The song “Thunder Rolls” is a typical shoot-him-for-cheating song.  The video, however, implied that cheating was not his only sin, because the wife is beat up.

Comment #74: Amanda Marcotte  on  11/30  at  08:51 PM

Wapsie, I blame the radio more than artists, really.  If you are different, or interesting, or liberal, you’re smart to be “alt” country because mainstream stations won’t play you.

Comment #75: Amanda Marcotte  on  11/30  at  08:53 PM

“Thunder Rolls” is surprising enough, but “Independence Day” (Martina McBride, Gretchen Peters) sends chills right up my spine… it’s definitely about an abused spouse killing her abuser (and herself, and burning the house down). Uses Christian imagery really strongly.

Judging from its citations on the ‘net, a lot of people haven’t noticed that it’s about the weak taking revenge on a bully.

Comment #76: clew  on  11/30  at  09:34 PM

Country music is fascinating for its politics…Martina McBride has some startlingly strong songs about women (Independence Day, When God Fearing Women Get the Blues) and she sings several other songs about domestic violence; and yet she is a die-hard Republican.  Toby Keith sings those totally assinine patriotic songs, but is nominally a conservative democrat.  Garth Brooks is pro-gay marriage, very publicly.  Tim McGraw sang about abortion, got a ton of guff about it, and refused to even comment about the controversy publicly except to say that telling stories is what country music is about, and he wouldn’t back down from telling a true story for better or worse.  Loretta Lynn is very conservative despite having bucked country music radio for singing about birth control positively in a popular song - for which her fans stood up and made sure her song was heard.  I recently saw one of the series of concerts where Sugarland played alongside one of the Indigo Girls (secret there is that Sugarland is basically an indie band that makes better press on country radio) - Emily Saliers was up there making jokes about being gay alongside one of country’s hottest bands.  It’s true that country radio is rather conservative, but it’s really, really not that simple at all.

Comment #77: skylanda  on  12/01  at  12:01 AM

Which still pisses me off, because Nelson is a state treasure.
~ ~ Amanda Marcotte

More like a national treasure.

Comment #78: fastiller  on  12/01  at  12:53 PM

While I enjoy country music titles (“You’re the Reason Our Kids are Ugly,” “She got the Gold Mine, and I Got the Shaft” are two that come to mind), the genre itself I can pretty much skip.

Except for the Dixie Chicks’ song, “Goodbye, Earl,” which really IS about a woman and her best girlfriend whacking the abusive spouse, who is such an asshole that nobody cares he’s gone!!

*Loved* that song!! 

‘Course, now the husband won’t eat black-eyed peas ... heehee! smile

Comment #79: Mhorag  on  12/01  at  02:17 PM

I bet Colbert is thinking more about Harvey Birdman Attorney at Law than anything else when it comes to limiting what his kids watch.  In the commentary he mentions that he’s told his family not to mention it to him, even if they like it. wink

I wouldn’t want my kids watching Booty Noir either. Haha.

Comment #80: Shoe  on  12/02  at  02:37 AM

Oh and song aside, Toby Keith was a frigging log in the show. It’s like he was in a neck cast or something. What is up with that? Must have been the green screen.

Comment #81: Shoe  on  12/02  at  02:37 AM

I thought the show was sweet, especially the singalong to Costello’s song “Peace, Love & Understanding.”

Bozell’s review was funnier than the show.

I totally support Colbert’s decision about not letting his kids watch. Kids need to be sure that their parents are sincere.

I think kids from 9 and up could watch it safely, maybe for the 9 year olds it might be a good idea to be on hand to explain that it’s satire. 10 year olds and up would get it better than we do.

Comment #82: Rev. Bob  on  12/02  at  12:57 PM

Lymis, you wrote:

“You’re not wrong, but the thing that torques me is that, as a religious holiday, Christmas is a twelve day holiday that STARTS on the 25th of December and ends with Epiphany on the 6th of January. Christmas Eve gets counted in because of the tradition that feasts start at sundown the night before.”

To which I say:

WORD!

Chances are if you went around correcting the most frothing-at-the-mouth of these Warriors for Christmas and wished them a “joyous Advent” (which is a *penitential* season, yo), you’d make their heads explode.

Comment #83: Sarah  on  12/05  at  04:04 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.