Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Sarah Palin Is Keyser Soze Previous entry: Straight from the wingnut’s mouth

John McCain Is Pregnant

See, what tends to get lost in the mix when prominent social conservatives have teenage mothers and gays and lesbians as a part of their families is that it’s not about them, their families and their privacy.  It’s about the millions of other families around the country who have to deal with the same things, and don’t get the benefit of saying “it’s a private matter” and being largely ignored by the conservative movement when their family members have to go out into the world and be told that they’re heathens precipitating the fall of Western Civilization.

Bristol Palin is a girl who did something that millions of teenagers have done - have sex.  And she is now facing the most obvious consequence of that choice - pregnancy.  She is not an evil person, she is not a blight on society, she is not deserving of public shaming.  She was deserving of proper information about sexual health and pregnancy prevention, something that her mother repeatedly and vocally fought against.

Perhaps most importantly, she’s deserving of not being thrust into the national spotlight as a part of a political movement that endangers the health of millions and turns a pregnancy into a statement of convenient moral superiority.  There are thousands and thousands of young women who have found themselves pregnant, and who have found themselves pressured to keep the child because it was the burden they deserved for the shameful thing they did, because to do otherwise risked shame and dishonor for their family.  They don’t, however, get the benefit of being (at worst) lauded and used as a political prop or (at best) ignored or allowed to live their lives - they become a part of an ever-growing testimonial to society’s failure, and yet more evidence that the particular evil of the day, whether they be Communists or hippies or the blacks or the liberals, are creeping insidiously into our homes and schools and tender crotches.

I begrudge Bristol Palin and her family nothing, and hope that she has a healthy and vibrant child who grows up to change the world for the better.  I just wish that we all had the benefit of being a prominent Republican’s child when it came time for judgment to be passed on us for our sex lives. 

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Jesse Taylor on 08:24 PM • (21) Comments

Well said, Jesse.  And wow… Robert Stacy McCain is pretty much king dick of shitbag mountain, isn’t he?

Comment #1: Bradley  on  09/01  at  08:30 PM

Thank you.  That was perfect.  You put it better than I could have.

Comment #2: Amanda Marcotte  on  09/01  at  08:31 PM

Well said.

Comment #3: MAJeff, the God of Biscuits  on  09/01  at  08:32 PM

Yep. Right on.

Comment #4: Kevin T. Keith  on  09/01  at  08:36 PM

Excellent, Jesse, and a splendid last paragraph.  I join the sentiment.

Comment #5: Hugo Schwyzer  on  09/01  at  08:45 PM

*applause*

Comment #6: Doug H. (Fausto no more)  on  09/01  at  08:46 PM

You mean people don’t get to say “it’s a private matter” when their entire election platform is based on using the government to control people’s private matters?

Shock!

Comment #7: dan  on  09/01  at  08:56 PM

Did anyone else notice the woman in the Snorg Tees ad that often appears on this site looks a lot like Sarah Palin?

Comment #8: Bacopa  on  09/01  at  08:59 PM

The bottom line is that McCain has committed campaign suicide in exchange for winning a weekend news cycle.

Comment #9: Ben D.  on  09/01  at  09:00 PM

Also, right on.

Comment #10: Ben D.  on  09/01  at  09:01 PM

I just wish that we all had the benefit of being a prominent Republican’s child when it came time for judgment to be passed on us for our sex lives.

Awe.  Some.

Comment #11: FlipYrWhig  on  09/01  at  09:02 PM

I’m… really sorry, but I just *have* to indulge in a piece of shameless self-advertising. Because you know, I just made a video about this. *And* I’m starved for attention:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQ1Ag9b0niw

Comment #12: Sebastian  on  09/01  at  09:56 PM

As we sometimes say in Texas:  A - fucking - men!

Comment #13: KL  on  09/01  at  09:57 PM

Church! Well said.

Comment #14: DanF  on  09/01  at  09:58 PM

ABC News just confirmed that Palin was a member of the secessionist Alaska Independence Party. That is borderline treasonous.

What’s next on the Sarah Palin Show?

Comment #15: Ben D.  on  09/01  at  09:58 PM

Aw, it’s not treason when Republicans do it, Ben D. When they do it, it’s just ornery independence.

Comment #16: annejumps  on  09/01  at  10:11 PM

Can we let this particular thread stay focused narrowly on the original point?  Jesse really nailed how I at least feel about her daughter’s (totally nothing-to-be-ashamed-of) pregnancy.

I’m sure much more dirt on Sarah Palin will emerge which we can discuss at that time.

Comment #17: KL  on  09/01  at  10:12 PM

I’m sure much more dirt on Sarah Palin will emerge which we can discuss at that time

See the thread above.

Comment #18: MAJeff, the God of Biscuits  on  09/01  at  10:15 PM

They don’t, however, get the benefit of being (at worst) lauded and used as a political prop

I’m not sure that’s really a benefit.

Comment #19: chingona  on  09/01  at  11:22 PM

Bravo sir.

Comment #20: ice weasel  on  09/02  at  07:33 AM

Thank you for articulating this so well, Jesse. That Spectator link is just awful. Imagine growing up as Bristol Palin’s child and stumbling upon the fact that you were a “national embarrassment” once upon a time. The Right sure does “love” babies. Oh, no, wait, they only love babies when it is convenient to do so. God, why don’t these people just admit it already?

Renee Martin wrote about the race and class aspects of this situation in my magazine (yes, yes, I want you guys to read my magazine - I think Renee’s point is very important). And you know what? It’s true. If Bristol Palin were a poor Latina mother, no one in the GOP would be “celebrating her choice” or, for that matter, arguing that she deserves the right to privacy or dignity or anything of the sort.

And here’s the other thing - it’s a funny word to use: “choice.” We all know that many, many people in the GOP would gladly be rid of choice altogether. There is a tremendous sense of disconnect between Bristol Palin’s choice (and her being lauded for it elsewhere) and the fact that these people would rather leave her with no choice at all.

Do they ever stop and think that celebrating a choice is contingent upon HAVING a choice? I doubt it.

Comment #21: Natalia  on  09/02  at  07:54 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.