Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Forget fetus personhood; group in FL wants to outlaw birth control Previous entry: Health care reform and domestic violence

Alabama Supremes uphold criminalization of sex toy sales; store owner will continue to sell them

No local dildo-buying for you, Alabamians—you have to point and click to order online (guess the courts haven’t quite figured how to stop that bit of business).

The Alabama Supreme Court on Friday upheld the state’s ban on the sale of sex toys, but Love Stuff, the Hoover store that filed the challenge, has no plans to stop selling the devices.

While people have the right to use the devices in private, the Legislature has the right to ban public distribution of those products, the court majority ruled in a 7-2 decision.

...“Public morality can still serve as a legitimate rational basis for regulating commercial activity, which is not a private activity,” Associate Justice Michael F. Bolin wrote in the majority opinion.

...“As the 11th Circuit pithily and somewhat coarsely stated: `There is nothing `private’ or `consensual’ about the advertising and sale of a dildo,’” the majority opinion said.

Every time I go to Birmingham, when we go to the airport we pass Love Stuff, the sex toy adult novelty store in this case and I wonder how this store managed to skirt by the ridiculous legislation in Alabama that bans the sale of sex toys. Clearly it’s been doing business while its case has been winding through the courts. Sherri Williams said this in an earlier interview about the situation:

My motto has been they are going to have to pry this vibrator from my cold, dead hand. I refuse to give up,” she said.

Alabama’s anti-obscenity law, enacted in 1998, bans the distribution of “any device designed or marketed as useful primarily for the stimulation of human genital organs for anything of pecuniary value.”

The law does not ban the possession of sex toys, and it does not regulate other items, including condoms or virility drugs. Residents may legally buy sex toys out of state for use in Alabama, or they may buy sexual devices in Alabama that have a “bona fide medical” purpose.

So are people going to need to go to court to find out which sexual devices are legal to sell as medical devices? After all, a good Reverend down in Montgomery, Reverend Gary Aldridge (who was a colleague of Jerry Falwell), sadly managed to reach the hereafter engaging in kink that didn’t involve “sex toys” as the court sees them:

An Alabama minister who died in June of “accidental mechanical asphyxia” was found hogtied and wearing two complete wet suits, including a face mask, diving gloves and slippers, rubberized underwear, and a head mask, according to an autopsy report.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Pam Spaulding on 03:52 PM • (26) Comments

Residents may legally buy sex toys out of state for use in Alabama, or they may buy sexual devices in Alabama that have a “bona fide medical” purpose.

Stress relief?

Comment #1: Alex, FCD  on  09/12  at  03:56 PM

Here in Texas, a lot of sex toys have stickers on the packaging such as “party decoration” and “cake topper”.

And then there’s the problem of all the “normal” things in the world that can be used as sex toys…like, pretty much anything.

Comment #2: Dorothy  on  09/12  at  03:58 PM

But remember, we’ve all got to be really, really concerned about BIG NANNY GOVERNMENT intervening in our lives!

Comment #3: annejumps  on  09/12  at  04:31 PM

Heaven forbids that any of them wimmins should learn to expect sexual pleasure (they sure as hell ain’t gonna get it from the hubby).

Comment #4: DrDick  on  09/12  at  04:46 PM

  Residents may legally buy sex toys out of state for use in Alabama, or they may buy sexual devices in Alabama that have a “bona fide medical” purpose.

Stress relief?

Kegel exerciser for incontinence.  Nothing to do with sex at all, officer.

The fleshlight?  Okay, I can explain that too.  Give me a minute…

Comment #5: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  09/12  at  04:53 PM

I’m just weeping at the idea that a sale (which generally features someone choosing to purchase what someone else chooses to sell) has nothing consensual about it.

(For a value of weeping that would be laughing, except that this person holds the authority of a judge on a state supreme court.)

Comment #6: Kyra  on  09/12  at  05:09 PM

they may buy sexual devices in Alabama that have a “bona fide medical” purpose.

That would be penis pumps, to help the menz.  Other than that, nada.

Comment #7: Mnemosyne  on  09/12  at  05:41 PM

Usually, a way around this is for the vendor to be extremely clear that they are selling items for educational, novelty, or collectible purposes only.

After all, if the law says you cannot sell items for stimulation, and you sell them for display and education only, then you ain’t breaking the law.

It would be very, very hard to pass a law that says you cannot use an item for sexual purposes that is sold for another purpose. Shut down zucchini sales, for one thing.

Comment #8: Lymis  on  09/12  at  05:57 PM

How could we ever forget this classic.  Warning, do not drink anything while watching - I’m not responsible fro your keyboard.  (And yes,, I know it’s an old video, but a goodie, just like Ms. Molly was).  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaUl6x1YXpg

Comment #9: phylosopher  on  09/12  at  07:04 PM

phylosopher, that is awesome.  “What if they slip?”  I’ll be laughing for hours.

Comment #10: Ranylt  on  09/12  at  07:36 PM

Advertising definitely isn’t private and consensual, but I do not understand how a purchase isn’t.

Comment #11: Samantha Vimes  on  09/12  at  08:02 PM

They’ll deal with it the same way Texans deal with it.

A dildo by any other name is still a dildo.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaUl6x1YXpg

Comment #12: Lesly  on  09/12  at  08:18 PM

phylosopher beat me to it.

Comment #13: Lesly  on  09/12  at  08:19 PM

Um, help me out - it is still legal to have inflatable sheep, isn’t it?

I mean help A FREIND OF MINE out.  A FRIEND OF MINE.  Really.

Comment #14: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  09/12  at  08:42 PM

The problem with all of our bright ideas is that it’s not anything factual or logical that will decide this. It’s a bunch of sex-obsessed prosecutors and judges. (And from the current decision it’s pretty clear that the Alabama supremes will rule against anyone they don’t like no matter how educational, medical or collectible their stock may be.)

Comment #15: paul  on  09/12  at  08:57 PM

Your Honor, my client has been diagnosed with hysteria, and I can present expert witness testimony that massage to the point of paroxysm is the medically approved and necessary treatment.

Comment #16: Falconer  on  09/12  at  09:04 PM

You are a New Zealander, aren’t you, PIator?  I understand.  Lived in Montana for a while.

Comment #17: phylosopher  on  09/12  at  09:07 PM

Huh. I actually received real medical advice from one of my doctors to use a vibrator. If I went to Alabama, I suppose I’d need a note from her, though.

Comment #18: BeccaTheCyborg  on  09/12  at  09:43 PM

THANK YOU, phylosopher and Lesly, for posting the Dildo Diaries.  This just confirms that I want to be Molly Ivins (or Ann Richards) when I grow up.

Comment #19: NobleExperiments  on  09/12  at  10:26 PM

It also reminds me of her line (paraphrase) that if the Legislature got rid of all the crooks, thieves, and fools, it would no longer be a representative body.

Comment #20: NobleExperiments  on  09/12  at  10:33 PM

Nuh, Uhh, I called dibbs when she first wrote Bushwhacked.

Comment #21: phylosopher  on  09/12  at  10:35 PM

Your Honor, my client has been diagnosed with hysteria, and I can present expert witness testimony that massage to the point of paroxysm is the medically approved and necessary treatment.

I’ve been reading The Technology of Orgasm, and your quote could come directly from there.

Basically, for most of history, doctors got paid to give women orgasms, and they hated, hated, hated doing it. They invented the vibrator (and the speculum) because they just couldn’t stand to be in contact with those awful womanly bits. From my perspective, this would be like complaining about being paid to sleep until noon, or eat gourmet meals, or travel the world, or, you know, give women orgasms, but apparently, YMMV.

(Of course, as the author points out, they didn’t think what was happening was orgasmic. Which means that a doctor who couldn’t recognize an orgasm in a patient had never seen one in real life).

Comment #22: Egnu Cledge  on  09/13  at  12:49 PM

I believe that one of the main complaints of those poor Victorian doctors was the repetitive strain injuries resulting from regular provision of manual relief.  Which makes me wonder how many patients they were relieving or whether they were trying to do it through the 6 layers of petticoats…

Comment #23: Theadosia  on  09/13  at  07:36 PM

To their credit, the Hoover police have decided that they have higher law enforcement priorities than shutting down Love Stuff. Which just heightens the idiocy of the law, since it has no practical effect at all except to show the AL legislature is still the best money can buy.

Comment #24: moioci  on  09/13  at  09:55 PM

Medical-context genital massage of the labia and clitoris to cure mental disorders in women caused by a “wandering uterus” goes back to the Hellenistic era. In the classical era women avoided this problem by either having other women do this for them as part of “women only” religious practices or by being empowered enough to get some of this action from their husbands. As the Greeks expanded into Africa and Asia minor, the old ways were lost and normal female sexual response became medicalized.

Comment #25: Bacopa  on  09/14  at  02:06 AM

Dorothy (2):

And then there’s the problem of all the “normal” things in the world that can be used as sex toys…like, pretty much anything.

I can’t think of another item that can be used as a vibrator; it seems a lot easier to simply call them “personal massagers” as is traditional. Or sell kits, like they did with wine during Prohibition.

PiaToR (5):

The fleshlight?  Okay, I can explain that too.  Give me a minute…

I can’t explain those at all, even where sex toys are legal.

Comment #26: Hershele Ostropoler  on  09/14  at  01:57 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.