Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: What article of clothing do you refuse to wear? Previous entry: California readers

Can we start forgetting about him yet?

The good news about Bush’s planned presidential library is that it’s going to be polluting Dallas and not Austin.  For awhile there, I was positively obsessed with the idea that Bush was going to going to set up here as a form of counter-programming to the Most Awesome Presidential Library* in the world, the LBJ Library at UT Austin. Luckily, he didn’t, and we can still hold our heads high.  No, he’s setting his library down at SMU, where it will be nestled in a wealthy, Republican neighborhood and safe from eggs and people flinging burned-out joints at it.  There’s also going to be a think tank, because if you’re going to name a library after Bush, why not pile on with the equally comical idea of thinking? 

But what’s so great is that Bush is having a hard time raising the money.

Yet, given the president’s current unpopularity, some Bush critics wonder whether the facility will turn out to be a historical white elephant. Fundraising for the project so far has been “very modest”, according to Dan Bartlett, a former Bush counsellor who is acting as a library spokesman.

Langdale said the president is intentionally waiting until he leaves office to start actively seeking out donors.

“The sceptics could be right: It might be a white elephant,” said Benjamin Hufbauer, an art history professor at the University of Louisville in Kentucky and an expert on presidential libraries. “But presidents don’t see it that way. ... Presidents see these as a foundation from which to build a new reputation. It’s just the right kind of elephant.”


I’m sure he’ll make up the money when he gets out of office and starts calling in favors, so unfortunately this setback is nothing more than a setback.  I’m sure the library will be finished on time.  But it got me to thinking—-is it really necessary for Bush to have a presidential library?  After asking about it on Twitter and getting some replies, I discovered that only 12 Presidents have libraries.  Herbert Hoover got one and then everyone thought they had to have one.  Richard Nixon has two.  (The display at the Clinton library right now is, I shit you now, “The Art Of The Chopper”.)  But there’s no reason that a library should have to follow every President who leaves office.  And if any President should be the one to skip the tradition, it should be Bush. 

Sarah Vowell once wrote an essay about how the measure of a presidential library is how well it handles the mistakes a President made.  She singles out the LBJ Library for praise in this department, pointing out that LBJ himself insisted that the library should deal with Vietnam in an honest way and not gloss over it out of some fear that it would hurt his feelings.**  That bit of honesty makes it easier for visitors to open up and absorb all the great things LBJ did.  Bush’s problem is that he’s not an honest man like LBJ was, and he’s surrounded by a bunch of fools. On top of that, he didn’t do anything good to offset the disaster that is Iraq.  So I suspect his library will just gloss over his soul-sucking badness and may very well be the worst presidential library in the country.

True, it’s fitting for the worst President quite possibly in history to have the stupidest presidential library, but its presence will be a blight on SMU’s campus.  So why not just break with recent tradition and not have a library at all?  No one’s going to miss it, I’m sure.  Unless of course they had an exhibit called “EPIC FAIL”, which would be fitting and awesome. 

Here’s to hoping that the Barack Obama Presidential Library is full of win, both in content and design.  Something cool and modern, like he is. 

*That I’ve seen anyway.  It’s also the only one I’ve seen.  But that they have an animatronic LBJ who cracks hoary jokes should put it over the top, don’t you think?
**See?  Best Presidential Library Ever.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Amanda Marcotte on 09:35 PM • (51) Comments

The ALA’s opinion of Bush ought to make staffing it a fun prospect…

Comment #1: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  12/16  at  09:41 PM

I grew up not too far from the Reagan Presidential Library.  Sigh. This is just another “library” I’m going to avoid in the future when I visit family in Dallas.

Comment #2: history_mom  on  12/16  at  09:42 PM

I’m sure he’ll make up the money when he gets out of office and starts calling in favors, so unfortunately this setback is nothing more than a setback.

I’ll be curious to find out.  A lot of the moneycons have lost a crapload of money in the past few months, and they’re not any happier about it than the rest of us.  W may have committed the ultimate sin:  losing money.

Comment #3: Mnemosyne  on  12/16  at  09:52 PM

I still laugh at the fact he can’t get his autobiography published, while Bill Clinton made millions off of his and had publishers falling over to sign him.

Comment #4: Ben D.  on  12/16  at  09:54 PM

How much space do you need for three comic books?

Comment #5: James  on  12/16  at  09:56 PM

Poor Mr. President Bush, I fear that he will be pelted with shoes wherever he goes now, by traitors who don’t see the good in war…G*dspeed, George Willard Bush!

Comment #6: Rugged in Montana  on  12/16  at  09:57 PM

There’s also going to be a think tank, because if you’re going to name a library after Bush, why not pile on with the equally comical idea of thinking? 

Well, it is a religious university, so installing a Republican think tank probably makes sense.

Comment #7: Incertus, Nacho Daddy  on  12/16  at  10:00 PM

The ALA’s opinion of Bush ought to make staffing it a fun prospect…

What, credentialed experts who are competent at their job? That’s for the “reality-based community.”

No, the staff should match his glorious legacy. That means they’ll just hire mailroom staff from the Heritage Foundation and graduates of the “Liberry Science” departments of schools like the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (which hires such “distinguished professors” as Mary Kassian).

I’m so pleased to hear they’re having such a hard time raising funds for this travesty. Between that, the mass refusal of world leaders to shake his hand at the economic summit, and the shoe-throwing incident, I hope Prince Bush will see his unique place in American history: the only modern ex-President to be more reviled than Nixon.

Comment #8: Gracchus  on  12/16  at  10:01 PM

Can we start forgetting about him yet?

Not while there is even the slightest chance of making him or anyone in his administration pay for his crimes, no. I don’t think we should.

Comment #9: atheist  on  12/16  at  10:05 PM

The good news about Bush’s planned presidential library is that it’s going to be polluting Dallas and not Austin.

I remember about 2004, on a flight to Mexico, I had a stop-over in the Dallas-Fort Worth airport. I walked past a life-sized statue of George W. Bush in the hall. I thought that was wierd and even a bit frightening. I’ve never seen life-sized statues of other presidents in airports, and I wondered if this was the beginning of some kind of cult.

Comment #10: atheist  on  12/16  at  10:09 PM

’ve never seen life-sized statues of other presidents in airports

I saw one of Jefferson, but he’s been dead for over 250+ years so it’s not as creepy.

Comment #11: Ben D.  on  12/16  at  10:12 PM

Er, 150+ years.

Comment #12: Ben D.  on  12/16  at  10:13 PM

safe from eggs and people flinging burned-out joints at it

Ah, but do they have shoes at SMU?

Comment #13: rea  on  12/16  at  10:16 PM

I would encourage people to donate a pair of shoes to charity…do it in the name of George Bush…and send the Bush Library the receipt.

Comment #14: gwangung  on  12/16  at  10:29 PM

Given that amount of paper work an administration generates and the amount of data for future historians, the idea of presidential libraries make sense.  Having them run by basically sycophantic foundations whose funds are raised directed by the President makes no sense.  They’ve turned into monuments.

Also keep in mind that one of Bush’s first acts was to reclassify a whole bunch of stuff about his father’s administration to keep it from getting out, so yeah this will be about as honest as the Creation Museum.

Comment #15: Rob  on  12/16  at  10:44 PM

yeah, Ben D., it was the fact that he was still president and they were building statues. Seemed a bit Baathist to me.

Comment #16: atheist  on  12/16  at  10:45 PM

Apparently there’s an old Bob Hope gag about Spiro Agnew that could be repurposed here:

Disaster struck recently when a fire broke out in <strike>Spiro Agnew</strike> George W. Bush’s library. Fire Department sources inform us that both books were badly damaged by the fire and the water used to suppress it. Sadly, Mr. <strike>Agnew</strike> Bush had not yet finished coloring one of them in.

Comment #17: Warren Terra  on  12/16  at  10:46 PM

The ALA’s opinion of Bush ought to make staffing it a fun prospect…

Presidential libraries, alas, do not usually employ professional librarians.  They tend to stick with museum curators, usually ones who are loyalists to the President.  Which is why LBJ had to step in and demand that the curator not tip toe around Vietnam.

Comment #18: Amanda Marcotte  on  12/16  at  10:52 PM

Or maybe they do use librarians for the papers.  I know the LBJ Library has a mind-bogglingly huge vault of papers and now tapes from his administration.  Organizing that and making it available to historians must be insanely hard.

Comment #19: Amanda Marcotte  on  12/16  at  10:55 PM

Eh, Agnew was an evil motherfucker but wasn’t a complete imbecile like Bush.

Comment #20: Ben D.  on  12/16  at  10:59 PM

I’d argue that the best presidential library is the only one residing in a public library—Coolidge, at Forbes Library in Northampton, MA.  http://www.forbeslibrary.org/coolidge/coolidge.shtml

Comment #21: rowmyboat  on  12/16  at  11:02 PM

Thank you for reminding me that I’ll need to make a contribution to the George Bush Presidential Library!  smile

However, whether you happen to like a particular president or not, these things contain presidential papers that researchers will use; they serve a real purpose beyond sycophancy.

Amanda wrote:

Here’s to hoping that the Barack Obama Presidential Library is full of win, both in content and design.  Something cool and modern, like he is.

The man hasn’t even been inaugurated yet; he might turn out to be a colossal bust.

Comment #22: Dana  on  12/16  at  11:06 PM

Given that amount of paper work an administration generates and the amount of data for future historians, the idea of presidential libraries make sense.

But W classified the shit out of everything and has made it nearly impossible to get documents.  He’s ordered his underlings to obstruct and slow down every FOIA request. 

What papers do you think will be there? 

-
Dana, there’s no way Obama can come close to matching the colossal bust that has been the Administration of the Worst President Ever.  He’s already making a dramatic difference by putting qualified people in his cabinet and in charge of federal departments.  Our international reputation is already being repaired.

I feel pretty confident in proclaiming that no US cities will be written off under Barry.

Comment #23: Caren  on  12/16  at  11:22 PM

For Bush’s Presidential Library, one of those carnival haunted houses would be appropriate.

Comment #24: Luke  on  12/16  at  11:23 PM

Obama will look good just by virtue of who preceded him. Hell I’ll take “below average” over what we have now. I’d take fucking Nixon over what we have now!

Comment #25: Ben D.  on  12/16  at  11:25 PM

Caren, you beat me to it.  I’m not sure that library science teaches how to file shredded documents and deleted emails.  “The Pet Goat” likely doesn’t take up much shelf space.

Comment #26: PWI  on  12/16  at  11:27 PM

The sad thing is that I know you’re hoping so, Dana, even though a bad President at this crisis juncture could completely ruin this country.  Thank god your guys lost in 1932, so we still have an America to love.

Comment #27: Amanda Marcotte  on  12/16  at  11:27 PM

But W classified the shit out of everything and has made it nearly impossible to get documents.  He’s ordered his underlings to obstruct and slow down every FOIA request.

So what you’re saying is that the library will be built by Halliburton and contain row after row of empty shelving that would collapse if you actually put anything on it?

Comment #28: paul  on  12/16  at  11:30 PM

I do have to defend SMU.  It’s got a reputation for being a country club Republican school, but when Laura Bush went there, she was a bleeding heart liberal who campaigned for Democrats.  I love universities in general.  I even allow that Texas A&M;contributes to society in the form of actually providing good ag info, even if they visit many horrors on the world including their fight song, school culture, and the Corps.

Comment #29: Amanda Marcotte  on  12/16  at  11:31 PM

To be more lifelike, shouldn’t the animatronic LBJ pressure you to support him on a key bill while he’s taking a dump?

BTW, I love the Bush fashion dolls.  There’s a whole series of presidential ones—I have the Nixon one at the bottom of a box somewhere.  Mrs. Pesto and I even considered using the dolls to identify tables at our wedding (“Oh, we’re sitting at the Eisenhower table!” where the guests would find a little, paper Ike and Mimi in their undies, with paper clothes for them to wear!).  I don’t remember why we didn’t follow through on that plan…

Comment #30: Pesto  on  12/16  at  11:44 PM

“So what you’re saying is that the library will be built by Halliburton and contain row after row of empty shelving that would collapse if you actually put anything on it?”

...if Halliburton does the electrical wiring, it might kill anybody dumb enough to enter…

Comment #31: MikeEss  on  12/16  at  11:45 PM

There needs to be an exhibit featuring one of those deadly Katrina trailers.  That would please me to no end, for a whole host of reasons…

Oh, and every visitor gets a “bug” clipped on them to pick up everything they say and broadcast it all over the place.  Just a little flavor of domestic spying.

Throw in hourly waterboarding on random live subjects…

Once a day, an explosive device will go off randomly, maiming anyone nearby…just to convey the Iraq experience…

Comment #32: MikeEss  on  12/16  at  11:51 PM

...if Halliburton does the electrical wiring, it might kill anybody dumb enough to enter…

Not to mention the sewage raining down from the pipes in the ceiling!

Comment #33: Xecky Gilchrist  on  12/16  at  11:57 PM

MikeEss:

And you will be allowed to fill out comment cards, but only if you walk two miles away to a barbed-wire enclosure so the librarians won’t be disturbed by your presence.

Comment #34: paul  on  12/17  at  12:02 AM

Oh yes, and the librarians will dutifully turn over all records of what the patrons checked out every day to the FBI.

Comment #35: Xecky Gilchrist  on  12/17  at  12:05 AM

<i>To be more lifelike, shouldn’t the animatronic LBJ pressure you to support him on a key bill while he’s taking a dump? <i> 

Stories like that make me like him more.  He, unlike Bush, was a real Texan.  Conducting business on the pot is just one of those things that we fail to understand upsets other people.  In the movie “W”, Stone gets at that by having Bush whine about his legacy from the pot, but I believe that he is not a real Texan, and thus closes the door and refuses to engage in deep thinking while shitting.

Comment #36: Amanda Marcotte  on  12/17  at  12:56 AM

Oh, I’m not holding it against him, Amanda.  The man could definitely be an asshole, but deep down he was a good-hearted asshole (illustrated both by his commitment to civil rights and the war on poverty, and by his despair over Vietnam), as well as a brilliant politician.  And he certainly had his own style.

Comment #37: Pesto  on  12/17  at  01:05 AM

Copier toner bills will be insane, given how many of the records will be blacked out.

And some mysterious vandal will be leaving copies of The Pet Goat all over the place about once a month.

Comment #38: Brian X  on  12/17  at  01:27 AM

Another thing about LBJ is that in his last days in office(so I was told by a grade school teacher shortly afterwards) he was working hard since he knew what a mess Vietnam would be for Nixon, so that there would be few, if any, other messes for Nixon to have to deal with.

Compare that to the current resident of the WH, I’m afraid the latter suffers greatly by a noticeable lack “work” or ‘results’ in his last days in office, unless you count the final WH Barney video.

I had a stop-over in the Dallas-Fort Worth airport. I walked past a life-sized statue of George W. Bush in the hall.

Drag it into the bathroom so people can pee on it in privacy.

Caren, you beat me to it.  I’m not sure that library science teaches how to file shredded documents and deleted emails.  “The Pet Goat” likely doesn’t take up much shelf space.

On the other hand, classification will be easy.  Most libraries using Dewey tend to have really big 300 series, covering the “social sciences”.  Bush will have at least half of his material classified under 165 - “Fallacies & sources of error”.

Comment #40: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  12/17  at  04:20 AM

paul wrote: So what you’re saying is that the library will be built by Halliburton and contain row after row of empty shelving that would collapse if you actually put anything on it?

LOL! As an affirmation of his conviction that the Iraq War was the bestest thing ever, Bush should have his library built by a Kuwaiti firm contracted by KBR using enslaved Bangladeshis that take his donors’ $250 million, but leave a half-finished building with leaking sewage pipes, rickety stairs, no roof and a mold problem. When the Bush Foundation tries to sue to get their money back, the outfit will point to a little-noticed clause in their contract shielding them from any liability or future claims over the work. In fact, another clause in the contract will force Bush to pay them another $50 million in “overage” charges stemming from a failed attempt to add accessibility ramps to the entry lobby. The head of the construction firm will be owed a $15 million bonus for the job, even though Dallas county inspectors will declare it uninhabitable and taxpayers will be stuck with a $24 million bill to have the eyesore removed and the land at SMU restored to a native prairie reserve. 

It will be a fitting tribute indeed.

Comment #41: jonas  on  12/17  at  04:47 AM

Off topic:  can we ban (or otherwise filter) all smileys in comments?  Though it’s nice to have an easy way to identify Dana, the passive-aggressiveness is wearing thin.

Comment #42: KL  on  12/17  at  11:51 AM

I have nothing to contribute to the discussion of the Bush library that hasn’t already been said, but I’d like to point out the sheer tonnage of win that comprises the LBJ animatronic thing in the video Amanda posted.

Comment #43: Matty  on  12/17  at  01:19 PM

Oh my god, I HAVE those Bush family fashion cut-outs.

Comment #44: Nicole  on  12/17  at  01:24 PM

I can’t wait to visit the Barack Obama Presidential Library at the University of Chicago… because duh, of course that’s where it’s going.

Comment #45: DTG in STL  on  12/17  at  03:31 PM

The good news about Bush’s planned presidential library is that it’s going to be polluting Dallas and not Austin.

Le Sigh.  Which is why the SMU alumni association will not get a fucking dime from me ever.  (Okay, there are lots of reasons why they won’t, but this is a big damn cherry on top of my Sundae of Resentment.)

Comment #46: kaninchen  on  12/17  at  06:14 PM

However, whether you happen to like a particular president or not, these things contain presidential papers that researchers will use; they serve a real purpose beyond sycophancy.

That’s why we have a Library of Congress, which is supposed to be able to preserve records of our government for our use. It may happen at a presidential library if they’re allowed access to them rather than impeded by sycophantic legacy-polishers the president and his family get to choose to be in charge. The record of the Bush family in this regard is not good. Bush Sr. undermined the Presidential Records Act by making an agreement with the Archivist to give him complete control over his own administration’s records, in return for which the Archivist was put in charge of his presidential library. This was later overturned by a federal judge. Then one of Bush Junior’s first acts upon taking office was to give presidents and their heirs complete veto power over access to their papers, with no restrictions.

So yeah, I’m sure his presidential library will do a fine job of making sure researchers have access to anything embarrassing or potentially incriminating. Just like they have the entire time he’s been in office…

Comment #47: Redshift  on  12/17  at  06:17 PM

Regarding Southern Methodist University: Hell yes they have shoes at SMU.  They’re way too expensive to be throwing around, though.  And while it is a nominally religious school (and has a school of theology, with the nicest library on campus), SMU’s administration and student body tends to be a good bit more conservative than the actual Methodist church.  Marion Wright Edelman once spoke at graduation; there was much grumbling about having someone speak that nobody ever heard of and couldn’t they get G.H.W. Bush to come back?

You can tell which parking lots are for students and which are for faculty: the student parking lots have way nicer cars in them.  Faculty types have shitty cars.

Comment #48: kaninchen  on  12/17  at  06:22 PM

“So what you’re saying is that the library will be built by Halliburton and contain row after row of empty shelving that would collapse if you actually put anything on it?”

...if Halliburton does the electrical wiring, it might kill anybody dumb enough to enter…

That just made me think of a Monty Python skit where they were interviewing architects for a retirement community, and one of the interviewees goes on to describe his creation - “Here they enter in the front, and then proceed by conveyor belt to rotating knives” or something like that - and when the guy is informed that this is for a retirement community, the guy goes, “Oh?  It’s not a slaughterhouse?”

Because that just sums up the total incompetence and horror of the Bush years.

Comment #49: DUHMonster  on  12/17  at  11:05 PM

They have to find someplace to put Ann Coulter’s books and other Reich wing garbage no one actually wants to read.

Comment #50: Samantha Vimes  on  12/18  at  12:05 AM

I can’t wait for his library to be built.  I love Dallas, I love SMU and I love Republicans.  Ya’ll won’t have much to write about when President Bush is gone….will this website fold??

Comment #51: Gail  on  12/20  at  09:15 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.