Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Who to blame for the Plan B debacle? Previous entry: That’s not your purse; it belongs to the TSA

Classic literature, interpreted by wingnuts

Batsh*t CrazyBooksChoadsEconomy

Via Whiskey Fire comes this illuminating piece from Jeff Carter at Townhall explaining why the sole blame for high unemployment is that people are too stupid and lazy to get jobs, coupled with "advice" on how to get one. Carter appears to believe that since a talentless moron like him can get work, so can you, though he's reluctant to offer wingnut welfare as an option, fearing the competition that arises when literally any moron could do your evil job. But what makes this piece special in the growing pile of hateful nonsense wingnuts are churning out to rationalize our terrible economy? Carter's amazing talents at literary interpretation:

If you are an unskilled laborer, it may seem like there are no opportunities. But, there are if you move to where the jobs are. In the 1930's and 1940's, there were several great migrations in the United States. The migration from the Great Plains to California was captured in the John Steinbeck novel about the Joad family. Many families moved from the rural south to the industrialized north for work. Just because you have lived your whole life in one area of the country doesn’t mean you are stuck there.

I'm surprised he didn't take it to the next level, and argue that you should avoid going on food stamps by pressing women with newborns into sharing their breast milk with you in lieu of purchased food. Maybe mow their lawn or something in exchange. My guess is that he didn't think of it, because he probably hasn't read the book, because even someone as dumb as Carter would grasp, upon reading The Grapes of Wrath, that Steinbeck has a fairly low opinion of people like the entire staff of Townhall. 

Which made me think about other classic works of literature and how they could be interpreted by conservatives, with or without actually reading the books in question. So I thought I'd make a list:

Oliver Twist: This story clearly demonstrates that putting bastard children into workhouses puts them on the path to peace and prosperity.

To Kill a Mockingbird: Innocent men can be convicted of rape just on a woman's word, so we should dismiss rape cases unless the crime happened in broad daylight in front of multiple witnesses, and the victim was a virgin on her way to church. Additionally, growing up in racist communities brings out the best in little girls.

Angels in America: The key is getting religion before you let dudes put it in your butt, and then you wouldn't get AIDS.

Moby Dick: The endangered species list is wrong, because it prevents good men from fulfilling their dreams.

A Christmas Carol: The ending demonstrates that we need  no government regulation, because our capitalist leaders are so naturally generous and fair.

The Handmaid's Tale: Women should simply give up on this feminism thing so that men aren't forced to take drastic action.

The Lottery: When your number's up, it's better for everyone if you don't whine about it so much. 

Tess of the d'Urbervilles: Women who don't accept that men prefer to marry virgins are pathetic lost causes.

The House of Mirth: Women should spend their youth trying to get married as quickly as possible to the first man that will have them. 

Slaughterhouse-Five: WWII truly produced the greatest generation.

Come up with your own!

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Amanda Marcotte on 10:43 AM • (114) Comments

Its a Wonderful Life: Bankers will be Bankers, but family is always special.

Comment #1: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  11:38 AM

Frankenstein - Scientists with will to power and the ability to ignore potential moral/ethical violations of their work and its consequences are the greatest innovators….especially in the name of “true love.”  Also, there’s nothing wrong with abandoning newly created life to the dangerous prejudicial outside world if he proves to be too “freaky”. 

Comment #2: exholt  on  12/07  at  11:52 AM

The Great Gatsby: Money can buy you happiness, as we can see by how emotionally healthy and well adjusted rich people are.

Elmer Gantry: Religious leaders are paragons of virtue and should not be questioned.

It Can’t Happen Here: Fascism is only something that happens in Europe.

Comment #3: MissCherryPi  on  12/07  at  11:53 AM

Make Room! Make Room!: [Novel Solyent Green was based on.] Poor people should listen to their betters and stop using contraception.

Comment #4: MissCherryPi  on  12/07  at  11:55 AM

Catch-22: War and capitalism are hilarious and awesome!

Comment #5: Scott  on  12/07  at  11:55 AM

The Jungle -  cause as bad as working conditions (and people falling in the sausage rendering vats) communism is way worse.

1984:  is pro-communist* by showing how bad communism is.

*http://ericjennings.wordpress.com/2007/10/03/banned-book-1984/

Comment #6: gardenom  on  12/07  at  12:00 PM

The left hand of darkness: Suppression of the female sex drive leads to harmony.

Shooting an elephant: The white man knows how to make the ‘hard decisions.’

Everything that rises must converge: uppity black women are a mortal danger.

Comment #7: rb1  on  12/07  at  12:02 PM

Jurassic Park: A successful dinosaur rebellion against government regulations. After overthrowing the restrictive human government, Isla Nubla becomes a paradise of mesozoic prosperity symbolized by the jubilous roar of the Tyrannosaur.

Comment #8: Baruk  on  12/07  at  12:02 PM

@1 - word!  Watching IaWL on Christmas Eve is our family tradition and in the last several years it’s themes been incredibly salient.

Comment #9: gardenom  on  12/07  at  12:02 PM

Gone with the Wind: Northerners wrecked all the fun by destroying the slave state.

Comment #10: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  12:04 PM

Sorry. Can’t come up with anything better than what I have (literally) laughed out loud at here.

However, I do want to say that “The Grapes of Wrath” describes perfectly how my mother-in-law’s family came to California from Texas. So when assholes like this say “See, that’s what people need to be doing. Picking cotton and cooking what the MIGHT be able to find to eat on the side of the road while living in their cars”, I just want to beat the shit out of them.

Now back to the jokes…

Comment #11: Mark  on  12/07  at  12:05 PM

Seriously, guys…if you are not the proprietor of a large oil company, it may seem like there are no opportunities. But, there are if you move to where the jobs are. Around the turn of the century, there were several great oil strikes in the United States. The dawn of this great oil boom was captured in the Paul Thomas Anderson film about Daniel Plainview. Many wildcatters struck it rich with perseverance and a dedication to the free market. Just because you have lived your whole life without owning a large energy concern doesn’t mean you are stuck there.

Comment #12: dopus dei  on  12/07  at  12:06 PM

Lord of the flies: Free market!

Sonny’s blues: Jazz leads to drug abuse.

Comment #13: rb1  on  12/07  at  12:07 PM

Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom: See, if you’re really talented and hard-working, you’ll be able to find employment. It’s only when you start questioning the decisions of people richer (and thus, obviously, wiser) than you, or blaming your lack of success on some imagined “racism” by the white people with all the money (I mean, come on—Sturdyvant was willing to pay a few dollars for Levee’s songs: what more did he want?) that you end up getting into trouble. Also, watch out for poor black people, they will stab you for no reason at all.

Comment #14: latinist  on  12/07  at  12:18 PM

Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All to You:  An accurate recounting of Catholic theology, punctuated with bouts of vaudeville and a twist ending.

Comment #15: Dark Avenger Guardian Chow Mein  on  12/07  at  12:26 PM

Lolita: All females, no matter how young, are manipulative sluts who enjoy entrapping the poor, innocent men who are powerless to resist their mind-controlling vaginas.

Comment #16: Tobasco da Gama  on  12/07  at  12:29 PM

A Clockwork Orange - Can we get our for-profit prison industry to implement the plan detailed in this book?

Comment #17: maurinsky  on  12/07  at  12:33 PM

Othello: Their honour killings are way more monstrous, and yet so much pettier, than our honour killings.

Comment #18: Ranylt  on  12/07  at  12:35 PM

Dante’s Inferno: most people in Hell are Catholic

Comment #19: ganews_  on  12/07  at  12:35 PM

Wuthering Heights: It’s better off for women to marry a man who has a crushing obsession with her and calls first dibs, even if that happens when they’re both six years old, because marrying someone else will naturally cause him to kidnap and marry her daughter against her will in an effort to take vengeance on her entire family for letting her think she had a right to marry who she liked. That, my friends, is romance!

Comment #20: Mighty Ponygirl  on  12/07  at  12:36 PM

The Odyssey: it is cool for a guy away from home to screw around, but his wife must remain eternally faithful

Comment #21: ganews_  on  12/07  at  12:37 PM

A Confederacy of Dunces - Searching for a job is a reward in itself and Lesbians will try to kill you.

Comment #22: RonO  on  12/07  at  12:48 PM

Dreams from my father: I am the culmination of a decades-long international communimuslim conspiracy to infiltrate the office of the POTUS.


Comment #23: rb1  on  12/07  at  12:49 PM

I have a real one, from a conservative in my office.  One person asked, “What is 1984 about?”  Conservative response: “Communism.”

I felt my eyes get really big in my face, but I know better than to try to talk her out of things.

Comment #24: Blitzgal  on  12/07  at  12:51 PM

ganews_, you would love Margaret Atwood’s The Penelopiad.

Comment #25: catfood  on  12/07  at  12:59 PM

The Ghost of Christmas Future was the original Supply Side Jesus.

Comment #26: Big_Southern  on  12/07  at  01:03 PM

“Bartleby” - Lazy, unemployed people deserve no charity and should starve to death.

Comment #27: Ben  on  12/07  at  01:07 PM

The Heart of Darkness:  Those savage Negroes are so much happier when there are benevolent white Europeans around to guide them toward civilized behavior.  It also points up how important it is to treat all people fairly and without prejudice.  “I don’t even see color!” 

At a pivotal point in the story, when Kurtz wrote in his journal “Exterminate all the brutes!”, he was making an important and necessary statement about the dangers of Socialism. 

Ultimately it’s a lot like Jungle Book, mixed with Song of the South and set in the Belgian Congo, which was a great vacation spot at the time.

I heard that Francis Ford Coppola later made a light-hearted movie version of the story, which emphasized how important it was for America to be fighting Communism in the jungles of Vietnam…

Comment #28: MikeEss  on  12/07  at  01:08 PM

Thanks catfood, I’ve never heard of it but it’s going on my list right now.  That part of the Odyssey was always (often the only) a part we studied in school.
Oh, another from Dante, the Paradiso: a woman who is raped (specifically a nun) is less holy for it.  I guess this isn’t really a wingnut interpretation, though, but the original intent.

Comment #29: ganews_  on  12/07  at  01:17 PM

“One person asked, “What is 1984 about?”  Conservative response: “Communism.””

...and the natural followup question would be, “What is Communism?”, to which many modern Conservatives would reply, “I don’t really know, but I know it’s bad.  And liberal.  And just like Fascism…”

Comment #30: MikeEss  on  12/07  at  01:17 PM

Old Man and the Sea- who needs a safety net?  We’ve got boats!

Comment #31: Satanicpanic  on  12/07  at  01:25 PM

The Yellow Wallpaper: Bitches be crazy.

Comment #32: CologneCerrone  on  12/07  at  01:27 PM

The Godfather: What happens when a man with a dream and the will to work manages to avoid being help up by restrictive government regulations.

The Lord of the Rings: You see, Ahmadineyad is just like Sauron. All of us men of good will should unite and wage a just war against his muslim orcs.

Satyricon: Ehh…nope, sorry. This one is absolutely not interpretable through a conservative lens.

Comment #33: Baruk  on  12/07  at  01:28 PM

Brave New World: Just Say No! to drugs - unless they are prescribed by the state.  Also, women can’t be trusted with childbearing.

Comment #34: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  01:28 PM

Gone with the Wind: Northerners wrecked all the fun by destroying the slave state.

To be fair, I feel like this is what Mitchell *intended* for us to take from that book. Bleh.

Comment #35: Well, what?  on  12/07  at  01:37 PM

Animal Farm: Some animals are more equal than others.

Comment #36: jeevmon  on  12/07  at  01:38 PM

Lazarillo de Tormes: Yay child labor.

Comment #37: Baruk  on  12/07  at  01:42 PM

Lem’s The Cyberiad: Instapundit was right about the future robot bodies!

Comment #38: ganews_  on  12/07  at  01:47 PM

Ben at #27:

Nuh-uh. Bartleby is about how people choose to be unemployed, and trying to help them won’t work. They will only persist in their self-destructive ways.

Billy Budd: Forcing your kids to work their way up the ladder to management will only lead to heartbreak.

Comment #39: paul  on  12/07  at  01:54 PM

Othello:  Interracial relationships are bad

Farenheit 451:  Books make people kill themselves

Comment #40: Pandagoner  on  12/07  at  02:02 PM

“Antigone”.  Righteous ruler orders that the enemy doesn’t get proper burial.  Just like we shoulda done to Osama. Crazy bitch gets a bunch of people to protest and they all get what’s coming to them.

Comment #41: SK  on  12/07  at  02:02 PM

The Odyssey - Greek wastes tax-payer money by taking ten year cruise.

I, Claudius - Screwed up. mentally deficient sons of rulers make the bestest rulers themselves.

Sophie’s Choice - Pro-choice policies only make women miserable.

Comment #42: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  12/07  at  02:08 PM

John Steinbeck’s The Pearl: If you are poor, all you need is hard work to make it.

Comment #43: benjaminsa  on  12/07  at  02:12 PM

Billy Budd: Forcing your kids to work their way up the ladder to management will only lead to heartbreak.

oh for chrissakes he was not vere’s kid what is with you people

Comment #44: Dan  on  12/07  at  02:14 PM

Les Miserables:  So many.
Why are those uppity people rebelling against their betters? Sexual harassment, lack of birth control, poverty and starvation are totes awesome!  The Thernardiers: paragons of Christian values who take in orphaned children and teach them the value of hard work.  Javert: Fearless lawman who loses his life to a vile breadthiever.

Comment #45: Shakti  on  12/07  at  02:17 PM

Of Mice & Men: A hard working, industrious young man discovers he need not be shamed into allowing his parasitic, mentally ill friend to put a damper on his entrepreneurial spirit.

Comment #46: casimir  on  12/07  at  02:21 PM

Fahrenheit 451: Restricting access to literature is good since it forces people to innovate in the field of memory and create new markets in book memorization.

Comment #47: casimir  on  12/07  at  02:25 PM

A Tale of Two Cities: get some other sucker to take the fall.  Also, the French suck.

Comment #48: ganews_  on  12/07  at  02:26 PM

The Three Musketeers:  I think it’s about a candy bar…

The Phantom of the Opera:  There are good reasons to be afraid of people with deformities…

Comment #49: MikeEss  on  12/07  at  02:55 PM

Jane Eyre Bitches be crazy. Your ex wife will burn the house down to stop you from getting with that hot poor chick you hired to teach your bastard child.

Comment #50: Shakti  on  12/07  at  02:57 PM

benjamista: It should be “success is too powerful a thing to be given to poor people who wouldn’t know how to handle it if they got it.”

Comment #51: Mighty Ponygirl  on  12/07  at  03:02 PM

Silent Spring: Free Market Job Creators could solve bird noise problem, if the EPA would just get off their backs!

Dune: The feudal system is a great from of government.

Comment #52: p8712  on  12/07  at  03:04 PM

I, Claudius - Screwed up. mentally deficient sons of rulers make the bestest rulers themselves.

To be fair, Phoe, Claudius was quite bright; his family just treated him as a fool because he twitched, stammered and dribbled sometimes.

Which leads us to another interpretation of I, Claudius; feel free to smack your handicapped kids around, it’ll make them turn out great!

Comment #53: Blue Jean  on  12/07  at  03:10 PM

MacBeth: Women are mainpulative bitches who nag their husbands into doing bad things.
Romeo and Juliet: This is what happens when teenagers have sex!
The Taming of the Shrew: Men, learn to control your women. Actually, that’s really what it is about. Blech.

Comment #54: Jimmy  on  12/07  at  03:11 PM

Medea: All right, catfight!

Comment #55: Jimmy  on  12/07  at  03:14 PM

@Mighty Ponygirl misinterpretation is hard to get wrong, but I like yours better.

Comment #56: benjaminsa  on  12/07  at  03:25 PM

Pride and Prejudice—men with money make the best husbands!

Comment #57: Jodi  on  12/07  at  03:39 PM

The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas- it is important to have an underclass, or else your city will fail.  And those who walk away from this truth are liberal pussies.

Comment #58: JoanofArc  on  12/07  at  03:48 PM

Araby: Austerity builds character.

The handsomest drowned man in the world: Indigenous peoples are fucked up and their traditions impenetrable.

Comment #59: rb1  on  12/07  at  03:58 PM

casimir:

Of Mice & Men: A hard working, industrious young man discovers he need not be shamed into allowing his parasitic, mentally ill friend to put a damper on his entrepreneurial spirit.

Also, flirty young married tramps better be careful about tempting the menz, lest they be strangled.

Comment #60: Nobody in Particular  on  12/07  at  03:58 PM

The Scarlet Letter: Women who get themselves pregnant need to be marked and ostracized

Comment #61: alysia  on  12/07  at  03:59 PM

Their eyes were watching god: “Those people” can’t spell or keep a marriage together.

Comment #62: rb1  on  12/07  at  04:03 PM

King Lear:  Never let a woman be in charge of anything.

American Gods:  There is only one true religion and following it will lead you to happiness.

Neuromancer (or Johnny Mnemonic, if you’ve never read the book):  Poor dirty luddites and their fifth columnist liberal friends are trying to steal your hard earned wealth.  Kill them all before they kill you first.

Comment #63: Zifnab  on  12/07  at  04:05 PM

The New Testament—Kill the Commie!

Comment #64: James  on  12/07  at  04:05 PM

Voltaire:  We live in the best of all possible worlds!

Comment #65: Zifnab  on  12/07  at  04:06 PM

Waiting for godot: Libruls made going to the DMV totally boring by funding the EPA.

Comment #66: rb1  on  12/07  at  04:08 PM

On liberty: we must waterboard. It’s the only way to be sure.

Comment #67: rb1  on  12/07  at  04:09 PM

The Legend of Zorro: Guys in tights are fruity.  Don’t let them liberate you because that will make you gay, too.

Comment #68: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  04:10 PM

Flowers for Algenon: The free market for pharmaceutical companies will solve all our health ills.

Comment #69: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  04:11 PM

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest: Obey authority or pay the price.

Comment #70: Jayn Newell  on  12/07  at  04:13 PM

The Hunger Games: who needs food clothing and shelter when we have TV!

Comment #71: Ms Kate  on  12/07  at  04:13 PM

@ 61 —speaking of, have you read the new book “when she woke” by hillary jordan?  im surprised it hasnt been picked up by more feminsit blogs.  it’s essentially the scarlet letter, haidmaid’s tale and the personhood movement rolled in to one eerily plausible dystopian near-future.

Comment #72: gardenom  on  12/07  at  04:15 PM

The Stepford Wives - Abandon you identity and submit yourself to your husbands needs. Or else!

Comment #73: MissCherryPi  on  12/07  at  04:41 PM

Gone with the Wind: Northerners wrecked all the fun by destroying the slave state.

But isn’t that actually the message of Gone with the Wind?

Comment #74: keshmeshi  on  12/07  at  04:44 PM

Pride and Prejudice: there’s no need for women to have economic independence or mobility; they can just get married!

Comment #75: Alyson Miers  on  12/07  at  04:48 PM

Childhood’s End: Space aliens are the spawn of Satan.  Also: US out of the UN!

Comment #76: Johnny Pez  on  12/07  at  04:53 PM

gardenom—I have neither read nor heard of that book, but I will have to check it out.

Comment #77: alysia  on  12/07  at  04:55 PM

It’s a Wonderful Life (redux):  An early example of how the spread of sub-prime mortgages, lending money to people who really can’t afford to own a house, can cause financial ruin to an entire community.  Also, private charity (the generosity of your friends) and a guardian angel is all you need to survive personal financial crises.

Comment #78: MiddleageLiberal  on  12/07  at  05:03 PM

rb1—also, black men are rabid.

Comment #79: Mighty Ponygirl  on  12/07  at  05:10 PM

Hamlet: Revenge is awesome!

Comment #80: Johnny Pez  on  12/07  at  05:12 PM

The Bluest Eye: See, white people really *are* better-looking than black people. Internalized racism? What’s that?

Ender’s Game: We need a permanent soldier caste, separated from the general population and trained to kill since childhood. This would be awesome (NOT incompatible with democracy or horribly psychologically damaging to everyone involved), and is totally necessary to protect us from the evil Other.

Also, population control is terrible and leads to potential Saviors of Humanity not being born.

Comment #81: Thalestris  on  12/07  at  05:12 PM

(that last might have been original intent, though, blargh)

Comment #82: Thalestris  on  12/07  at  05:13 PM

Invisible Man: There are all kinds of great opportunities for colored folk in the city!

Comment #83: jonas  on  12/07  at  05:16 PM

I personally think the wingnut interpretation of the New Testament is my favorite. Total lulz!

Comment #84: lightfoils  on  12/07  at  05:27 PM

I, Robot: Servants need to know their place: they’ll be happier.
Stranger in a Strange Land: Every older libertarian white man deserves three hot secretaries.
2001: A Space Odyssey: Father knows best.

Comment #85: felagund  on  12/07  at  06:00 PM

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn: if servants aren’t kept under the tight control of their <s>owners</s> employers, they run off and kidnap impressionable young boys who should be at home with their rightful fathers.

Comment #86: Alyson Miers  on  12/07  at  06:01 PM

Doctor Zhivago: We must go to war against the evil world-destroying Communist menace! (It’s not a pro-Soviet book, but it’s not McCarthyism either.)

The Great Gatsby: Rich people are the best and most important.

Fight Club: We should respond violently to the feminization of society!

Harry Potter: We must go to war against the evil world-destroying Muslim menace! (I didn’t even make this one up—it was a real right-wing interpretation.)

Contact: Science is useless; all we need is Jesus.

Comment #87: snowmentality  on  12/07  at  06:04 PM

Robinson Crusoe: Your own island away from any other authority is a libertarian paradise.

Comment #88: ganews_  on  12/07  at  06:11 PM

Really, any riches-to-rags story where the main character evolves after being pushed into hardship (A Little Princess, Gone With The Wind, The Wolves of Willoughby Chase, The Prince And The Pauper) could be interpreted as saying that hardship is a good thing. It builds character. So the 1% is doing the middle class a favor when they force them into penury. Living at a base level of survival simplifies life, makes you appreciate the little things.

Comment #89: Proboscidea  on  12/07  at  06:20 PM

kBlack Like Me A white man goes undercover as a black man to get them to STFU about how bad they really have it.

Comment #90: pitbullgirl65  on  12/07  at  06:21 PM

I’m trying to think up something for a pun on “Bros before hoes” - would “the Grapes of Wrath” count?

Spelling of “hoes” is intentional…

Comment #91: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  12/07  at  06:29 PM

The Autobiography of Malcolm X (yes, I know it’s not fiction, exactly): see what happens to uppity Negroes?

Tom Sawyer:  Obviously, there is a reason to keep Indians on reservations.

Comment #92: Iam138  on  12/07  at  06:39 PM

Invisible Man: Incandescent lights are da bomb!

Comment #93: Kyartist  on  12/07  at  07:09 PM

  Gone with the Wind: Northerners wrecked all the fun by destroying the slave state.

But isn’t that actually the message of Gone with the Wind?

I’ve read the book a few times, and didn’t get that message.  (It seemed more like, “don’t waste your life pining for what is gone.”)  But I’ve never seen the movie.

Was the movie different from the book?

 

Comment #94: AMM  on  12/07  at  07:22 PM

Stranger in a Strange Land: Every older libertarian white man deserves three hot secretaries

No, that’s the original interpretation.  And one of the reasons I don’t reread Heinlein.

Comment #95: woodland sunflower  on  12/07  at  07:30 PM

Speaking of Heinlein…

Farnham’s (?) Freehold: Black and muslim people are waiting for the chance to take over and make white people their slaves. Also, they’re cannibals.

Of course, Heinlein is so bigoted it’s hard to say just how much of that needs to be read into the text.

Comment #96: Jayn Newell  on  12/07  at  08:16 PM

I’ve read the book a few times, and didn’t get that message.  (It seemed more like, “don’t waste your life pining for what is gone.”)  But I’ve never seen the movie.

Was the movie different from the book?

I’ve read the book and seen the movie, and the two are very different, not least because you can’t pack that much story into one movie, even one that’s three hours long.  Admittedly, it’s been a long time since I read or watched either, but I still remember some explicitly racist parts of the book, like one part where Scarlett et al. were complaining that former slaves had suddenly become “lazy” since they won their freedom, with the implication that black people are naturally that way.  And there was the standard Southern boilerplate of evil Northerners treating white Southerners so very, very badly, both during and after the war.  I mean, there has to be a reason why the book and movie were such a phenomenon among white Americans, especially among white Southerners pre-World War II.  The movie is still the biggest blockbuster in U.S. history.

Comment #97: keshmeshi  on  12/07  at  08:19 PM

This was such an epic misrepresentation of the book. I made an entire post where I looked at my book shelf and made up conservative spins for everyone along one row. It was perversely fun. I’m ready for my job now, Fox News.

Greatest hits:

Invisible Man: A black man benefits from affirmative action and squanders the money of good white people by becoming a communist who is in debt and free loading in a basement.

Jane Eyre: An uppity women teases a Nice Guy, leaves him, and then comes back to marry him for his money.

Harry Potter: A poor boy is a scholarship student at a prestigious school. He refuses to do work, and he wants to make the noble Purebloods pay for all these poor students to go to their school. The liberal media mightily supports him.

Let the Right One In: A depraved transexual temps a young boy away from his caring mom and into a heinous life style.

The Phantom of the Opera: Don’t trust Europeans.

http://wp.me/p1IEbT-1H

Comment #98: hlynn117  on  12/07  at  08:35 PM

A Song of Ice and Fire: Sex is just meant to be a tool to manipulate people; if you actually care for the people you screw, you end up losing out. Oh yeah, and whatever you do, only marry for political reasons and not for love. Oh yeah,and dragon eggs are proof of intelligent design.

Comment #99: Ben F.  on  12/07  at  09:31 PM

@87
“Fight Club: We should respond violently to the feminization of society!”

Sadly, it doesn’t take being a wingnut to think this. It seems to be the dominant perception of what Fight Club was about.

Comment #100: Treefinger  on  12/07  at  10:25 PM

The Jungle Meatpacking plants ran much more efficiently before onerous government regulations were foisted on them.

Comment #101: jonas  on  12/08  at  12:24 AM

The Crucible=If a group of girls accuse a man of something heinous, it’s because they made it all up out of spite and sluttiness.

Clarissa=If you run off with the handsome, sexy guy instead of marrying the repulsive rich slob your family picked out for you, then you should expect to starve in the gutter, no matter how clever and virtuous you are.

I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings=Little girls need to be under constant, strict supervision, or they’ll ruin a man’s life by accusing him of rape.

The Diary Of Ann Frank=If your religion differs from the majority’s, then you need to be locked up for your own protection.

Comment #102: Blue Jean  on  12/08  at  01:09 AM

Frankenstein - Scientists with will to power and the ability to ignore potential moral/ethical violations of their work and its consequences are the greatest innovators….especially in the name of “true love.”  Also, there’s nothing wrong with abandoning newly created life to the dangerous prejudicial outside world if he proves to be too “freaky”.

No, no, no exholt. Frankenstein is - Whatever it costs you in health, sanity, or soul, you Will bend every law of god and man to bring that precious life into existence afterwords it’s totally your responsibility to take care of that thing, and when you’re inevitably crushed by all responsibility with no support, we’ll kill it because it’s not like it’s “people.” I can’t believe you created such a little monster…

 

Comment #103: scrumby  on  12/08  at  01:30 AM

“Whatever it costs you in health, sanity, or soul, you Will bend every law of god and man to bring that precious life into existence afterwords it’s totally your responsibility to take care of that thing, and when you’re inevitably crushed by all responsibility with no support, we’ll kill it because it’s not like it’s “people.””

...in other words, Victor Frankenstein is the perfect “pro-lifer”: Life begins with an orgasmic bolt of lightning (conceptually or literally) and ends at birth re-animation, after which you may merrily kill your own, or somebody else’s, offspring at will, no harm, no foul…

Comment #104: MikeEss  on  12/08  at  03:07 AM

Naked Lunch: How come there weren’t any naked hot chicks smearing food on themselves in it? I want my money back!

The Idiot: Whew, for a minute there, I was worried that it was a biography of GWB.

Fahrenheit 451: More global warming propaganda.

Comment #105: CountAgion  on  12/08  at  06:37 AM

A real one: Brave New World is a warning against reproductive technologies.

Comment #106: matt_heath  on  12/08  at  07:37 AM

House of Sand and Fog: too bad, the banks are always right.  Also, immigrants will destroy the country by taking your stuff.

Comment #107: Ms Kate  on  12/08  at  12:26 PM

To be fair, Phoe, Claudius was quite bright; his family just treated him as a fool because he twitched, stammered and dribbled sometimes.

Most of that was probably an act to make himself seem enough of a “fool” to avoid being killed off as he didn’t want to end up like many of his royal relatives. 

I mean, there has to be a reason why the book and movie were such a phenomenon among white Americans, especially among white Southerners pre-World War II.  The movie is still the biggest blockbuster in U.S. history.

GWTW has also been very popular worldwide….probably because it provided a seeming escape from the Great Depression and the ongoing Wars/impending coming of WWII.  Everyone in my grandmother’s and mother’s generation loved the movie.  Heard that after WWII…one European theater played it for 15 years straight….until the theater workers threatened to strike as a result of getting tired of hearing the theme to the movie for that long. 

 

Comment #108: exholt  on  12/08  at  12:38 PM

/i/Middlemarch/i/ - Smart women have more trouble getting married.

/i/Ender’s Game/i/ - playing videogames makes kids violent.

/i/House of Mirth/i/ - don’t get stock tips from your friends’ husbands.

/i/Dune/i/ - Arabs are terrorists.

Comment #109: karounie  on  12/08  at  02:57 PM

Oops - sorry about sleepwalking thru the italics.

Comment #110: karounie  on  12/08  at  02:58 PM

@Thalestris

It could be equally argued from Ender’s Game that if humanity doesn’t control population through universal provision of nutrition, health and education - especially for females - arbitrary population control will eventually be imposed, with eugenic exceptions for those whose genetic propensity for strategic violence makes them ‘essential breeders.

There’s an inverse correlation of nutrition+health+education and family size - it’s no co-incidence which nations are spontaneously approaching or exceeding zero population growth.

Comment #111: Tafkao  on  12/09  at  09:09 PM

Oscar Wilde The Ballad of Reading Gaol choosing to be a homosexual will end in heartbreak and physical pain, and leave you with a myopic liberal mistrust of the benefits of a strenuous corrections system.

SPOILER ALERT Paul Theroux Mosquito Coast  Non-conformists will die ironic and ignominious deaths because being a liberal is a form of mental defect.

Sophocles King Oedipus See where listening to you conscience gets you?

Euripides The Bacchae Women are strange.  Women acting in unison are dangerous.  Drunk women acting in unison are gonna tear you limb from limb, buddy.

Shakespeare Hamlet Do or do not.  There is no “let me think this through rationally and then do the morally courageous thing.”  That leads to nothing but insanity and/or death for everyone concerned.

C. S. Lewis The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe With God backing you and weapons in your hands, you can defeat anyone you designate as evil.

University Press Group trans/pub Arab Historians of the Crusades With God backing you and weapons in your hands, you can defeat anyone you designate as evil.

Various anonymous Tales of One Thousand and One Nights If you don’t put your foot down from day one, your woman ain’t never going to shut up.

Comment #112: Tafkao  on  12/09  at  10:32 PM

Yeah, sadly, I’ve seen people make the “conservative interpretation” of a bunch of these. Often in college: couple of student papers last year argued that Sciascia’s To Each His Own is admirable ‘cause it teaches you should mind your own business rather than risking your life in pursuit of justice.

Remember how last year, PA’s Governor Corbett used Wordsworth’s “The world is too much with us” to justify slashing state services? And in 2004, on CSPAN, I saw a preacher at a Howard Phillips campaign rally invoke Bleak House to oppose child labor laws.

Comment #113: Josh  on  12/10  at  05:35 PM

Tafkao - C. S Lewis was pretty much presenting alegories of Biblical stories, so that one for LWaW was probably not that far off from what he intended.

Comment #114: helen w. h.  on  12/12  at  01:02 PM

2 Kings 2:23-25:  See what happens when you don’t get off my lawn?

Comment #115: Dark Avenger Guardian Chow Mein  on  12/13  at  01:27 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.