Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Non-overt, overt, and assumed feminism in pop culture Previous entry: Elmo’s friend

Friday Genius Ten: “A Rare Circumstance” Edition

Wednesday night we went to see the double-header of Sleigh Bells and Cansei De Ser Sexy, and I'm sorry to report that Sleigh Bells is the first band in a long time where I've liked the record but hated the live show.  Serioulsy, I lasted three songs and had to leave.  It's hard to put my finger on it, but my feeling is that they were trying too hard.  They're a two-piece---and often it's just the singer with a bunch of electronic music behind her---and so they tried to compensate for the lack of visual interest by drowning the stage in strobe lights to the point where you couldn't actually be sure that they were the musicians, even if you had a good idea what they looked like. They also opened with "Iron Man", which is the sort of thing I think you get to do if you have two good albums in a row.  Just sayin'.  The lead singer Alexis Krauss had a lot of energy and a great voice---like I said, I love the album---but with the overcompensation at her back, it fell flat. 

But this was just me, of course.  Most of the audience was going nuts.  Of course, as Marc pointed out as we left, they went nuts when the pre-music shuffle had Van Halen's "Panama" in it, so they were up for anything. 

My problem is that there's no reason for a two-piece to have to compensate for anything.  I've heard their stripped-down early shows were amazing and I believe it.  I've seen many variations on the two-piece for at least a decade, everything White Stripes-style drum-and-guitar rock music to stuff that's more like Sleigh Bells, where the sound is filled out with electronic music.  It all works just fine; the stage show is about bringing a human element to it along with the dance party.  I didn't get anything out of this show that I couldn't have gotten with Christmas lights and playing the record on my stereo, except maybe the splashes on my shoes from the generous amount of beverages that people were dropping on the ground for some reason. 

It was all still worth it, because Cansei De Ser Sexy really is just one of the most fun bands you can see live.  So I'm kicking off the Friday Genius Ten with a song of theirs.  Leave yours in comments, thoughts on shows you've seen that just didn't work for you, or thoughts on anything at all.  Open thread.

Original song: "Music Is My Hot Sex" by CSS.

1) "Back in Your Head" by Tegan and Sara

2) "Great DJ" by the Ting Tings

3) "Gold Lion" by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs

4) "Boyz" by MIA

5) "Lights & Music" by Cut Copy

6) "Ready For the Floor" by Hot Chip

7) "I'm Good. I'm Gone" by Lykke Li

8) "The Reeling" by Passion Pit

9) "We Used To Be Friends" by the Dandy Warhols

10) "Wolf Like Me" by TV on the Radio

Videos:

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Amanda Marcotte on 08:40 AM • (23) Comments

Crystal Castles was a show that didn’t work for me. Loved their EP and record, and then I saw them at SXSW 2010 when I realized that they were basically a Velvet Underground cover band singing through a vocoder.

Comment #1: JonE  on  05/13  at  10:28 AM

My genius mix from your song:

1. Boyz -MIA,
2. Walking with a Ghost- Tegan & Sara,
3. Ready for the Floor (Jesse Rose Remix) - Hot Chip,
4. Heads will Roll (A Trak Remix) - Yeah Yeah Yeahs,
5. Ice Cream - NYPC,
6. I Turn My Camera On - Fork,
7. Golden Skans - Klaxons,
8. Rebellion (Lies) - Arcade Fire,
9. Caring is Creepy - The Shins,
10. Where is My Mind - Pixies

Comment #2: JonE  on  05/13  at  10:32 AM

I’ve had bands that burned me out over their live shows. We were huge TMBG fans back in the day and saw tons of their concerts throughout the 90’s and were always well rewarded. Then a long string of shows in the aughts, during which they clearly could not give a shit, totally soured me on them (that, and their insistence on making children’s albums). Ruined all their albums for me.

1. Neutron Lover - The Homosexuals
2. I’ll Stick With You - The Primitives
3. Head Over Heels - The Go-Betweens
4. Colour Television - Eddy Current Suppression Ring
5. Ignorant Father - Eleven Pond
6. Operation - Deerhunter
7. It’s All I Can Do - The Cars
8. The Suspect - Animals and Men
9. Murder By Rock - Guitar Wolf
10. Weber - Butthole Surfers

Comment #3: Egnu Cledge  on  05/13  at  10:37 AM

Heh, Egnu, now that I think of it, I got bored at a Butthole Surfers show not so long ago.  Granted, Peaches opened for them, and that’s a hard act to follow.

Comment #4: Amanda Marcotte  on  05/13  at  10:55 AM

If they could only put Cansei Sur Sexy with the B52s!

As for “hated live show”, I think the worst I have ever seen from a supposedly “headline” band was Social Distortion. Frankly, I don’t even see why they bother to tour - they suck!  Stand there and stare at your feet suck.

Comment #5: Ms Kate  on  05/13  at  11:08 AM

When a band that was once renowned for setting itself on fire in front of autopsy videos and sex changes (and had whoever that was on the cover of Double Live dancing for them) becomes boring, we are in sad times.

Comment #6: Egnu Cledge  on  05/13  at  11:17 AM

I usually have the opposite problem, as my usual ‘music consumption’ strategy is to go to a lot of shows then buy the records for the bands I liked. So while I have no cases of ‘liked the record, hate the live performance’, I have a bunch of impulse record purchases of bands I loved live but can’t listen to at home. Or rather I used to go to a lot of shows… now that I don’t, I barely ever buy new records.

In the cases where I did end up listening to the album(s) first, it is likely the band does not tour in my area or is defunct (His Hero is Gone, Nux Vomica, World Burns to Death) and I listened to them because they were influencial on other bands I liked. I almost got to finally see Tragedy live but they were sold out.

Comment #7: BlackBloc  on  05/13  at  11:25 AM

Anybody ever seen Jucifer? L’Autrichienne was actually pretty complex and nuanced, but live they stand in front of a literal wall of speaker and repeatedly hammer a single chord over, and over, and over again. Interspresed with indecipherable wails. In fact, here’s a show from the same venue several years ago. That one’s slightly better, but the lights didn’t even come on until about four minutes in. It was kind of like listening to a heavy metal band practice their scales. It was, at least ear splittingly loud.

Comment #8: Egnu Cledge  on  05/13  at  11:29 AM

Ms Kate,

It’s not quite CSS + B-52’s, but have you encountered Golden Triangle? Also, live.

Comment #9: Egnu Cledge  on  05/13  at  12:03 PM

Oooh, convergence!  I tried to sell the fiancee on ‘Music Is My Hot Hot Sex’ for our wedding tomorrow, but they didn’t go for it.

Comment #10: NBarnes  on  05/13  at  12:13 PM

“Wolf Like Me” is so good. I have nothing to but that.

Comment #11: witless chum  on  05/13  at  12:17 PM

Weezer.  It was like putting on an album, only with terrible reverb.  (Granted, some of that was the venue.)  And I LIKE Weezer; I just didn’t pay $30 to watch Rivers Cuomo stare at his guitar for an hour.

Comment #12: Fellmama  on  05/13  at  12:27 PM

Weird, the Sleigh Bells set was one of my stand-outs from Coachella this year. They, well, slayed it. But my husband had a similar reaction to yours, Amanda. “Eh, trying to hard, I’ll be at the back of the tent waiting it out.” And he likes their record a lot. But I like how heavy they come across live - they are essentially an electronic band, which could sometimes make for a boring show, so taking their music in a very “metal” direction live is a good choice for them.

I’m pretty selective with shows these days, so it’s rare for me to have a really bad experience. But I was really burned by Morrissey a few years back. It just never worked out for me to see him during Your Arsenal days, when there was still a point; in retrospect we should’ve known better and not even bothered. It was probably a good year before we could play The Smiths in this house without cringing. And it’s not like he was incompetent or anything, it just was all wrong. Also, Sonic Youth at Coachella a few years back. I read later that people loved their set, but we left a few songs in. Maybe it was because they were late and it was one of the last night sets after a long, hot day. Or maybe it was because their free Central Park gig with Sun Ra Arkestra in 1992 was such an epic experience for me as a teenager, so nothing they do now could possibly measure up.

Genius:
1. Heart - Boredoms
2. Vacuum - Gang Gang Dance
3. Okay, Let’s Talk About Magic - Fuck Buttons
4. What You Want - My Bloody Valentine
5. Tunic (Song for Karen) - Sonic Youth
6. Bros - Panda Bear
7. Taste the Floor - The Jesus and Mary Chain
8. Winter Wonder Land - Animal Collective
9. Central and Remote - Grizzly Bear
10. Remade Horizon - Dirty Projectors

Comment #13: elena  on  05/13  at  12:43 PM

I’ve never seen Morrisssey, but my wife loved him in the UT Bass concert hall a year or two ago.

Comment #14: JonE  on  05/13  at  03:36 PM

I always found it a shame that “Music is My Hot Sex” was CSS’s biggest mainstream hit. I always thought “Let’s Make Love and Listen to Death From Above” was a far superior song.

Comment #15: Sherm  on  05/13  at  04:41 PM

Aww, that sucks!  I love love love the Sleigh Bells album.  And I love that Lykke Li song and the CSS song.  I haven’t been to a gig in ages, eep.

Comment #16: alicefairy  on  05/13  at  05:01 PM

Right now my concert-going is limited to following my brothers’ band to every gig they do. I’m their number 1 fan.

Comment #17: BlackBloc  on  05/13  at  05:03 PM

I’ve never heard of a single one of those bands. Does that mean I’m old?? SOB!

Comment #18: PhysioProf  on  05/13  at  07:52 PM

Sound Opinions is covering the Riot Grrrrl movement this week (on now in Chicago; Saturday morning as well)

Comment #19: NY Expat  on  05/13  at  09:11 PM

@sherm, totally agree

Comment #20: JonE  on  05/13  at  09:45 PM

@Sherm, WORD. But Music Is My Hot Sex was featured in the iPod ad. Unfortunately, without that CSS probably wouldn’t even be on the mainstream radar at all.

Comment #21: elena  on  05/13  at  11:08 PM

Since this is an open thread, can anyone suggest sites with a similar set up to 4chan (user generated content, discussion of personal issues, anonymous to other users) but with Pandagon-type users (feminist, left-leaning, smart, mature etc)? Or do these types of people not need anonymous online forums like 4chan?

Comment #22: predeceased  on  05/14  at  12:50 AM

Predeceased, maybe metafilter? I don’t think it’s anon, though. It seems anon is now for people who are looking to do some trolling, unfortunately.

Comment #23: elena  on  05/15  at  12:33 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.