Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Voting Wins! Previous entry: Close Enough To Honest

Joe The Plumber’s Fake Small Business

imageSarah Palin is on my TV advocating policies for people like Joe the Plumber “who are struggling to maintain a small business”.

Joe the Plumber isn’t struggling to maintain a small business.  He doesn’t have one.  And he’s not actually struggling - he just wants to be sure that when he has a business and it’s making a quarter million dollars in Holland, Ohio, he won’t have to pay 3% extra in taxes.  You see, it helps if you remember your talking points about your crappy everyman stand-in.  Either that, or if you’re going to start making things up about him, I’d like it if he was a hard-nosed private eye with a keen-eyed secretary who actually solves all of his cases for him.  That, I could buy.

Palin’s also demanding records of all communications between ACORN and Obama, like that time where he wrote to the elusive Mr. Peanut (shadowy head of the nut-based organization) and talked about how amazing it would be if the entire starting lineup of whatever football team McCain told his captors about actually voted for him instead.  And it will happen.

It’s amazing how marginalized Palin became after her debate, like that great funny character on a sitcom who gets overexposed and then gets relegated to bit parts every couple of weeks - except that she keeps insisting that her harebrained scheme to become vice president will pan out.  It’s not that entertaining any more.

UPDATE: I think the secret to what Ezra discusses is that McCain and Palin don’t actually care or know anything about Joe.  Some words came out of his mouth.  Good words.  Useful words.  And those words will be used to make other points.  With words.  That’s the important thing here.  So long as those words aren’t eloquent, obviously.  That’s for elitists.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Jesse Taylor on 12:37 PM • (29) Comments

And Sarah would have succeeded, too, if it hadn’t been for you meddling kids.

Comment #1: GDad  on  10/17  at  12:56 PM

Actually they are doing a fantastic job with Palin. She is in highly controlled venues saying whatever comes out of her mouth and no one hears it except for the dunderheads and genetically deformed that show up and are worked up by the lies and spewed illogic of Ms. Disaster…

If she actually did more talkies, she would have to defend herself from angry journalists like Couric. In the protected venues filled with invitation only rednecks and idiots, she’s home free and out marketing the party to the people who could very well grease her way into the office. They might, ok WILL live to regret it, but for now, they get their mad on and love her for ‘speaking what needs to be spoken’ and it’s all happening out of the glare of the spotlight of the jaundiced and decidedly not liberal media…

Comment #2: PinkyLeftBrain  on  10/17  at  12:56 PM

...and it wouldn’t even be 3% extra in taxes.  it would be 3% extra in taxes ONLY on the portion of his net income above $250,000.  Because we have marginal tax rates in this country.

Comment #3: sam  on  10/17  at  01:21 PM

I find it interesting that it is Obama that was accused of being a charismatic cryptofascist figure, when Palin fits the role much better… well, except for the ‘crypto’ part. wink

Comment #4: BlackBloc  on  10/17  at  02:02 PM

A millionaire business owner once told me that the reason poor people don’t work hard to become millionaires was because the prospect of an oppressive tax burden demotivated them.

Comment #5: pragmatic idealist  on  10/17  at  02:19 PM

If Sarah Palin had not existed, the Coen brothers would have had to create her.

Comment #6: the golux  on  10/17  at  03:24 PM

...and it wouldn’t even be 3% extra in taxes.  it would be 3% extra in taxes ONLY on the portion of his net income above $250,000.  Because we have marginal tax rates in this country.

Not only that, but the business gets to deduct its expenses against its income, including its payroll, and pays taxes on its profits after that’s done. This is a business with two full-time employees. If it’s paying their wages and making a quarter mill in profits, then “plumber” must be as much of a euphemism as it was in Watergate.

Comment #7: Warren Terra  on  10/17  at  03:30 PM

It’s amazing how marginalized Palin became after her debate, like that great funny character on a sitcom who gets overexposed and then gets relegated to bit parts every couple of weeks - except that she keeps insisting that her harebrained scheme to become vice president will pan out.  It’s not that entertaining any more.

The ‘Poochie the Dog’ of right-wing politics.

Comment #8: Juan Stoppable  on  10/17  at  03:42 PM

Well, I for one am totally grateful to McCain/Palin for defending the fantasy alternate existences of working-class people everywhere.

Comment #9: Kathleen  on  10/17  at  04:18 PM

Sarah Palin = Steve Urkel.

Comment #10: FlipYrWhig  on  10/17  at  04:21 PM

As lifelong Democrat, I have to say that Obama’s response to Joe the Plumber is an unmitigated disaster. The only thing worse has been the unseemly and over-the-top response of Obama’s supporters.

Quick anecdote, my mother, a grade-school teacher who has never, ever, not in her life voted for a Republican is utterly outraged. She’s so angry about the anti-Joe smears that she’s changed her vote.

I’m really worried that we’re blowing it.

Comment #11: Dave  on  10/17  at  04:23 PM

Sarah Palin = Steve Urkel

HERESY.

You take that back.

Comment #12: Damian  on  10/17  at  04:27 PM

As lifelong Democrat, I have to say that Obama’s response to Joe the Plumber is an unmitigated disaster.

Telling him that having lower taxes when Joe is first starting out in business will help him grow his business faster was an “unmitigated disaster”?  Or was it the part where Obama pointed out that having more customers who can afford his services would be better for Joe than lower taxes?

I’m really worried that we’re blowing it.

Yes, you do sound very ... concerned.

Comment #13: Mnemosyne  on  10/17  at  04:27 PM

Dave: cool story bro

Seriously, you expect anyone to buy that faux outrage at face value?

Comment #14: Damian  on  10/17  at  04:28 PM

Dave, as a former “lifelong” Republican, I have to ask you what the hell you’re talking about.

You sound extraordinarily concerned.

Comment #15: Joshua  on  10/17  at  04:43 PM

A millionaire business owner once told me that the reason poor people don’t work hard to become millionaires was because the prospect of an oppressive tax burden demotivated them.

To be fair, it’s the reason I choose not to be a millionaire.

Comment #16: Dweeze  on  10/17  at  05:01 PM

You actually think that McCain didn’t know anything about the GOP-planted guy who’s the brother of the son-in-law of the guy who McCain took bribes from?  It was all just an amazing coincidence that this particular guy showed up?

Comment #17: QrazyQat  on  10/17  at  06:39 PM

I wonder if we can throw McCain off the R ticket and replace him with Joe the plumber, that guy is great.

Comment #18: KLH  on  10/17  at  07:32 PM

Why aren’t everyone millionaires? Look at those who are! They are generally vain, self-aggrandizing, vainglorious, self-centered, egotistical, callous, inept, lazy, cheep, greedy, users who wouldn’t fuck anything that put up a fight unless it wanted to take a pittance of their money for taxes that might go for something other than lining their cages with more money or killing people with really negative sounding label words describing them like ‘spooks’, ‘gooks’, ‘sand ni***rs’, etc…

Let’s face it, if all of the rich people left because their tax rates went up 2% than the country would be far better off. Yeah, it would be a while to get things sorted out but since by and large the ‘utra-rich’ aren’t the great ‘American brain trust’, we’ll manage…

‘Joe the plumber’ is a straw man to be used to flail the democratic party with the very people they are supposed to represent - working poor. How dare the ‘democrat’ party tell that man that wants to buy a business (he legally can’t run) that he will pay higher taxes and that a black man is going to ‘spread around his money’ so that others might be able to eat and get healthcare and try to live a small part of the American dream rather than the freaking nightmare they have been living. I mean, what fucking country is this? This is BUSH LAND! Help yourself to taxcuts and don’t look at the ‘little guy’ who wants to screw you out of your money. The uppity lower class wants healthcare and good roads and good schools and safe food and safe water and safe jobs and cheap gas and equality of pay. They don’t realize that they all cost MONEY and their business owners are sick and tired of supporting them. Why can’t they provide for themselves?

“I’m alright Jack, keep your hands off a my stack. I’m in the high-fidelity first-class traveling set and I think I need a Lear Jet” Cut wages!!!

You see, there is something fundamentally wrong in this country.

McCain is talking to a ‘business owner’ and says that he wants to save him some money with tax cuts.

Why?

So far the ‘rich’ haven’t been doing a very good job of propping up the economy, have they. Why give the ‘big guy’ more money? For a Mercedes Benz? A BMW? Another house in the Hamptons?

Why?

I got a great idea. It’s a little ‘Maverick ™’ sounding but it could work: Let’s not put more money into the ‘big guys’ pocket and try putting more money into the ‘little guys’ pocket. There are a lot of them which might cost more but they get around too. And they really do buy stuff. A WHOLE LOT of stuff!

It sounds kinda wacky, but it might actually work… Make Joe the plumber actually support the people that can’t work for him because he doesn’t have a plumbers license because he’s not a journeyman plumber, but details, details… If you look metaphorically at the whole ‘Joe the plumber’ thang, you see that giving their employees more money could make for happier and healthier employees who would buy cars and boats and tools and provisions and wave runners and eat out more (at restaurants wink and would buy more computers and houses and well, just buy more and more stuff!

Wacky sounding, huh… It would probably never work…

Comment #19: PinkyLeftBrain  on  10/17  at  07:48 PM

Now let me get this straight.

1. Obama goes to Joe the Plumbers door.
2. Obama says ‘we need to spread the wealth’
3. Joe the Plumber disagrees
4. Media seek’s out Joe the Plumber, disappointed with his answers, Media attack Joe the Plumber
5. Left-wing blogs attack and set put to destroy Joe the Plumber.


all Joe the plumber did was disagree with Obama.

Comment #20: KLH  on  10/17  at  08:20 PM

“Joe the Plumber” went from unknown to irritant faster than, well, Sarah Palin.

Comment #21: FlipYrWhig  on  10/17  at  08:32 PM

1. Obama goes to Joe the Plumbers door.

Nope—Joe approached Obama while Obama was campaigning in his neighborhood.

2. Obama says ‘we need to spread the wealth’

Nope—Obama says it’s better to give businesses a tax break when they’re first starting out than it is to give high-revenue businesses one.  He also pointed out that if the economy tanks and Joe’s customers can’t afford his services, Joe will go out of business, so it’s good business to “spread the wealth” and make sure his customers have enough money to hire him.

3. Joe the Plumber disagrees

That one you got right, at least.

4. Media seek’s out Joe the Plumber, disappointed with his answers, Media attack Joe the Plumber

Nope—McCain campaign finds Joe and works him into the debate, even inviting him to a McCain rally in Toledo.  Media start investigating to see if Joe is what McCain claims he is.  Turns out, he’s not even a plumber, much less a guy getting ready to buy a business with net profits of $250,000 a year.

5. Left-wing blogs attack and set put to destroy Joe the Plumber.

If by “destroy” you mean “show that the McCain campaign lied about Joe and his circumstances,” I suppose you could say that.  But, then, you’re from the side that thinks it’s perfectly fine to pick on a 12-year-old kid, but a grown man is too delicate to defend himself.

There’s a name for people who only pick on people smaller and weaker than they are, you know.

Comment #22: Mnemosyne  on  10/17  at  10:41 PM

Left-wing blogs attack and set put to destroy Joe the Plumber.

Funny thing is, the person who dropped a dime on Sam the Unlicensed Plumber’s Assistant was probably a customer outraged that (s)he paid a fortune to a guy without a license.

Dave, your concern is noted.

Comment #23: Big Bad Bald Bastard  on  10/18  at  12:56 AM

Off-topic, but how many private eyes are there really that have their secretaries solve the cases for them? I’m most intimately familiar with Gabriel Knight and Grace.

Comment #24: AndersH  on  10/18  at  06:22 AM

One wonders if Pinky Leftbrain ever heard of Boolean logic?Naw.Sorry.But,let me parse over his statements.
Millionaires…......If they’re so lazy,how did they amass such wealth?
secondly,I’d like to have veryone’s rates increase 2%.I find it unstable that 40 % of the taxpayers pay no Fed income taxes.I find it fundamentally wrong that so many people want others to pay and feel ,well,entitled.
And PL,I understand you’re probably a once and future humanities student,but
1)Where do you feel being’rich’ begins,in terms of annual income?
2)What % of income taxes should the top 5%  of wage earners pay?
Just interested in a little thought .
  Now,a little about my hopes and aspirations.I think it very likely Sen Obama will win.And,since he seems to be overmatched at accomplishing anything,I expect the results to be bad.We’ll wait and see..
  “When I was a lad,I served a term as Novice at an organizing firm
I held long meetings,and I polled the poor
And I polished upm the handle on the big brass door.
I polished up the door so carefully
That now I am my parties chosen nominee

Chorus
“He polished,etc”
  My organizing had such small yields,I was sent to the Senate(Downstate Springfield)
I voted ‘Present” in a voice so bland
And I always helped my patron-if he’d grease my hand
Chorus"And he’d always help Big Tony,if he’d grease his hand
I voted present so incessantly,
that now I am my parties chosen nominee
Chorus"he voted ‘Present’ so consistently,that now he is his parties chosen nominee


tum -te tum -te tum -te tiddle tum tumm

Comment #25: corwin  on  10/18  at  10:24 AM

“Palin’s also demanding records of all communications between ACORN and Obama-”

Obama has an easy response to this - he legally cannot divulge those communications, since they were privileged. It’d be unlawful.

Comment #26: Will H.  on  10/18  at  03:03 PM

Please tell me why/how it’s priveleged?

Comment #27: corwin  on  10/18  at  04:05 PM

Millionaires…......If they’re so lazy,how did they amass such wealth?

By having rich grandfathers.  What, you’re trying to pretend that every millionaire in the country made that money all by him or herself?

Comment #28: Mnemosyne  on  10/18  at  05:13 PM

Perhaps Palin should divulge all the communications about official business that she has had with her husband, Treasonous Traitor Palin?

Comment #29: Ms Kate  on  10/18  at  07:17 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.