Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: NYT Mag interviews Charlie Crist: he hasn’t found ‘the right one’ for him Previous entry: I Will Give Credence To Anything, Because I’m A Real ‘Murkin

Sanka-Sipping Liberal Elitists

Economy

The fact that everything is more expensive is forcing people to forgo their lattes.  How will we identify our sneering elite?  (Well, besides the sneers.)

Whenever there’s a sharp rise in living costs like this, you can bet there will be a flood of rich little poor kids harangues to follow (example here).  There’s an element of economic understanding that declares a hierarchy of goods - food and shelter before all else, with the odd preference on declaring that you have suitably crappy food and shelter (and no other luxuries) if you declare yourself “poor”.
When rising prices hit the middle class, one of the surest ways to staunch the bleeding is to cut out luxuries, but often without the realization that a luxury for thee is not necessarily a luxury for me.  One of the most popular cost-cutting measures I see referenced is to cut out cable and internet in order to save money.  However if you’re poor (and have your real live color TV or one of them fancy computing boxes!), cable and internet - if you even have internet - are one of few ways you have to access entertainment and information.  One of the reasons that someone with means can cut internet, say, to save money is because they have the mode of transportation available to get them somewhere with free wi-fi (and the requisite equipment to use it), or a job that allows them the freedom to access the internet during work hours. 

There’s also what the author of the piece calls the “latte effect”, which uses some seriously deceptive figures:

A $1.50 bottle of soda for each weekday of the year, for example, would add up to about $390. Now at $2 in some parts of the country, the habit comes with an annual price tag of $520. Over five years, that’s $2,600.

[...]

For New York City resident Natasha Patel, the penny pinching means no more cab rides home on weekends. Instead, she relies on her monthly subway pass, saving about $20 in taxi fares a week ($1,040 over a year, $10,400 over a decade).

Yes, if you cut out certain daily things, you will save an aggregate load of money at some point in the future.  But where people tend to get in trouble isn’t in the little luxuries, such as they are, but the big bills that simply pile up.  We build housing that’s almost entirely unsuitable to living on a marginal income both by size and energy use, construct metro areas that are virtually impossible to navigate in any affordable fashion, place necessary retail in areas only reachable by car. 

The media in particular tends to discuss economic hardship only when it actually affects people who can’t spend quite as freely as they once did.  But for those of us who are already on a cheap phone plan, who’ve cut down our driving, who are aggressively tackling our debt rather than buy unnecessary frivolities, we don’t have lattes to cut out, and it’s not a particularly big shocker that unnecessarily expensive shit is, in fact, unnecessarily expensive.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Jesse Taylor on 10:59 AM • (26) Comments

I thought that being poor was eliminated about the same time we ended racism - it was in the ‘60’s, wasn’t it?

After all, hardly anybody uses the N-word, unless you’re a rapper, and similarly, doesn’t everybody have a TV and an iPod?

Q.E.D…

Comment #1: MikeEss  on  06/23  at  12:15 PM

I guess I could stop wasting my money on that extra-soft toilet paper and start using the cheaper, scratchier kind.

*sigh*

Comment #2: Vitameatabaramin  on  06/23  at  12:15 PM

Vitameatabaramin - if you keep insisting on having air conditioning and not purposefully seeking out accommodations that were built prior to 1960, your asshole is just going to have to take the hit.

Comment #3: Jesse Taylor  on  06/23  at  12:26 PM

A $1.50 bottle of soda for each weekday of the year, for example, would add up to about $390. Now at $2 in some parts of the country

Where is a bottle of soda $2, pray tell?  I try not to buy it too much, but when I do it’s like $1.25, even in the fancy parts of Manhattan.  I’ve seen $1.50 sodas in the tourist trap parts of town where they know people are too stupid to realize they’re being ripped off or know how to go somewhere else for a damn soda (or just get water, or whatever).  But $2?  Sorry? 

And, yeah, sure, I guess if you cut out spending that $1.25 a day on whatever little splurge makes you happpy, yeah, wow, you’ll save like $35 a month.  Which wouldn’t even be enough to get cable, let alone make a big difference in your financial life.

Comment #4: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  12:27 PM

But if you cut out a $2 breakfast every morning, you could save over $7,000 in a decade!  That’s real money!  Eventually!

Comment #5: Jesse Taylor  on  06/23  at  12:31 PM

“And, yeah, sure, I guess if you cut out spending that $1.25 a day on whatever little splurge makes you happpy, yeah, wow, you’ll save like $35 a month”

But you’re POOR. You don’t GET to be happy. Happy is for rich people.

Comment #6: The One True Vegan  on  06/23  at  12:33 PM

“But you’re POOR. You don’t GET to be happy. Happy is for rich people.”

If you want to be happy, choose your parents more wisely…

Comment #7: MikeEss  on  06/23  at  12:36 PM

Wow, Jesse, I think you’re on to something.

I pointlessly waste at least $100 a month on groceries (yeah, I know—call me a chardonnay swilling elitist!)).

If I cut that out and started scavenging food from the garbage or hitting up my local soup kitchen and food bank once a week or so, I could save more than $1000 a year!  Maybe even $2000!  I’ll be out of debt in no time!  I might even lose some weight!

Comment #8: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  12:37 PM

Now you’ve got it!  And a lifetime of cloistered abstinence will save you tens of thousands of dollars by avoiding meals, entertainment, contraceptives/condoms/other tools of sexual safety (and/or toys), new and clean clothes, and even showers!

Comment #9: Jesse Taylor  on  06/23  at  12:43 PM

Also, things happen that cannot be anticipated. Example, this last weekend my water heater exploded, flooding my basement (yay!)
When we were snooping around down there trying to figure it out, we discovered all the hot water in the house had been plumbed with regular pvc pipe, which releases carcinogens when hot water runs through. Totally not up to code.
So that needs to be replaced now. Along with the hot water heater.. Setting me back about 2000.00 dollars, and because I took a trip in April my savings was basically cleaned out.
So it’s like, what do you do? Cash on hand is always helpful and sometimes hard to get, even when you have a steady job that pays well.

Comment #10: yazikus  on  06/23  at  12:46 PM

“If I cut that out and started scavenging food from the garbage or hitting up my local soup kitchen and food bank once a week or so, I could save more than $1000 a year!  Maybe even $2000!  I’ll be out of debt in no time!  I might even lose some weight!”

Hey!  I could stand to lose some weight!  Is there a name for this new and innovative diet of yours?...

Comment #11: MikeEss  on  06/23  at  12:47 PM

“I pointlessly waste at least $100 a month on groceries…If I cut that out and started scavenging food from the garbage or hitting up my local soup kitchen and food bank once a week or so, I could save more than $1000 a year!  Maybe even $2000!  I’ll be out of debt in no time!”

Ha, that would actually work for some of us—if you live in a college town, you can go to every lecture, reception, art opening, et cetera that offers refreshments, and not have to eat your own food for days.

Comment #12: rowmyboat  on  06/23  at  12:48 PM

Yeah, I remember those days… 

And the days of ramen noodles and the occasional $1 slice of pizza. 

And in the interest of full disclosure, I work in an office that provides a breakfast spread and comps our lunch.  Which enables me to eat much better than my means.  Every company should feed it employees for all time they spend on the job, in my opinion.

It’s joke.

On the other hand, wow, imagine if I got all my dinners and weekend food from charity and scavenging!  I’d be saving money hand over fist!

Comment #13: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  12:54 PM

Bleh.  That should be It’s a joke..

I’m turning into squashed.

Comment #14: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  12:57 PM

And a lifetime of cloistered abstinence will save you tens of thousands of dollars by avoiding meals, entertainment, contraceptives/condoms/other tools of sexual safety (and/or toys), new and clean clothes, and even showers!

Re: the post I wrote about the hit your credit rating takes if you show evidence of a social life.  I get the impression that the upper classes really do think it would be best if members of the working class cut out non-work-related activities.  That was their opinion when they didn’t see why factory workers can’t work 80 hours a week and sleep by their machines.  And that’s their opinion now when they don’t see why it’s crazy to require your car loan rate be contingent on the fact that you swear up and down you only use it to drive to work and back.

Comment #15: Amanda Marcotte  on  06/23  at  01:04 PM

“I get the impression that the upper classes really do think it would be best if members of the working class cut out non-work-related activities”

In my (limited, admittedly) experience, the attitude is more that the shame of having no money is SO GREAT, that your every waking moment must be dedicated to Erasing the Shame, and your every action geared to that end. Anything you do that delays your Erasing of the Shame is unacceptable. And also you must never call attention to yourself, lest someone notice your shameful state.

I see this attitude a lot in people slightly older than my parents (so, early boomers maybe?) as well as Depression babies. And it does hinge entirely on the idea that any financial misfortune is your own fault, and maybe a sign that you’re just maybe a bad person.

Comment #16: The One True Vegan  on  06/23  at  01:12 PM

And also you must never call attention to yourself, lest someone notice your shameful state.

And you must avoid all positive sensations and experiences, lest they distract you from your shame.  Even if it’s a $1.50 iced coffee once a week.

Comment #17: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  01:16 PM

“And you must avoid all positive sensations and experiences, lest they distract you from your shame.  Even if it’s a $1.50 iced coffee once a week. “

gawd, i’m in serious trouble then…my $1.50 iced coffee comes with a flirty barista, too. THE SHAME.

Comment #18: The One True Vegan  on  06/23  at  01:24 PM

For SHAME, young man/lady!

And to think that whole time you could have been buttering up some investment banker who might marry you and pay off all that debt!

Comment #19: The Opoponax  on  06/23  at  01:34 PM

Bleh.  That should be It’s a joke..

I just assumed that by omitting a key stroke, you were conserving personal energy, meaning you could type more on the same amount of food.

Comment #20: Dweeze  on  06/23  at  01:58 PM

“I get the impression that the upper classes really do think it would be best if members of the working class cut out non-work-related activities.  That was their opinion when they didn’t see why factory workers can’t work 80 hours a week and sleep by their machines.”

Well, why not?  Business is not a charity.  And if those lazy workers fall asleep and are mangled by the machine, there’s always more <strike>Irishmen</strike> <strike>Chinese</strike> <strike>Jews</strike> <strike>Italians</strike> <strike>Puerto Ricans</strike> <strike>Mexicans</strike> <strike>Jamaicans</strike> people we can exploit coming in to replace them every day.  Besides, if they get hurt or worn out, it’s their own damn fault.  Slackers…

Comment #21: MikeEss  on  06/23  at  02:02 PM

Can I give my kids? Cause they’re costing me a fortune.

Comment #22: Col Bat Guano  on  06/23  at  04:05 PM

However if you’re poor (and have your real live color TV or one of them fancy computing boxes!), cable and internet - if you even have internet - are one of few ways you have to access entertainment and information

I have friends who call me a tv addict (and maybe I am) and they boggle at how much I pay for satellite tv, but we don’t spend $ on ANY other entertainment.  Hmm…maybe I should start sleeping at work so I don’t have all that elitest “free time” to do fun things.

Comment #23: Olivia  on  06/23  at  04:16 PM

“Hmm…maybe I should start sleeping at work so I don’t have all that elitest “free time” to do fun things.”

ehhh, you can sleep when you’re dead.  Now get back to work!...

Comment #24: MikeEss  on  06/23  at  04:50 PM

And… if you are self-employed or looking for a job, your Internet and cell phone are something you prioritize above food, kind of. I mean, I’m making meals out of some pretty odd things in the pantry sometimes, because I can’t afford NOT to get a call that will bring me income, nor can I afford to lose the ability to keep tabs on my Internet store and add new inventory there.

I’m confused about someone above saying Depression babies consider poverty shameful? My experience has largely been that older people are more likely to be *surprised* people who seem well-enough off are poor, but consider it less shameful.

Comment #25: Samantha Vimes  on  06/23  at  05:45 PM

I know things are bad, but Sanka?
Really?
Sanka?

Isn’t there a caffiene gum I can get my insurance to pay for? It’s a legitmate addiction, right?

Comment #26: hbsweet, empress of ice cream  on  06/24  at  12:55 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.