Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: The “non-violent” anti-abortion activists Previous entry: Anti-choice violence and why it puts “common ground” into question

So how does O’Reilly feel about the assassination of George Tiller?

Faux News bully Bill O’Reilly has spent multiple segments of his show—29 segments to be exact—portraying Dr. George TIller as a bloodthirsty savage. The doctor, who was murdered in his church on Sunday, has been vilified by O’Reilly. Do you think he feels any level of accountability for stirring up the fringe anti-choice womb controllers out there? Clips of his demonization are seen in the following DKos video, along with this excerpt of an article on this from Salon

Tiller’s name first appeared on “The Factor” on Feb. 25, 2005. Since then, O’Reilly and his guest hosts have brought up the doctor on 28 more episodes, including as recently as April 27 of this year. Almost invariably, Tiller is described as “Tiller the Baby Killer.”

Tiller, O’Reilly likes to say, “destroys fetuses for just about any reason right up until the birth date for $5,000.” He’s guilty of “Nazi stuff,” said O’Reilly on June 8, 2005; a moral equivalent to NAMBLA and al-Qaida, he suggested on March 15, 2006. “This is the kind of stuff happened in Mao’s China, Hitler’s Germany, Stalin’s Soviet Union,” said O’Reilly on Nov. 9, 2006.

O’Reilly has also frequently linked Tiller to his longtime obsession, child molestation and rape. Because a young teenager who received an abortion from Tiller could, by definition, have been a victim of statutory rape, O’Reilly frequently suggested that the clinic was covering up for child rapists (rather than teenage boyfriends) by refusing to release records on the abortions performed.

This characterization of Tiller fits exactly into ancient conservative, paranoid stories: a decadent, permissive and callous elite tolerates moral monstrosities that every common-sense citizen just knows to be awful. Conspiring against our folk wisdom, O’Reilly says, the sophisticates have shielded Tiller from the appropriate, legal consequences for his deeds. It’s left to “judgment day” to give him what’s coming.

O’Reilly didn’t tell anyone to do anything violent, but he did put Tiller in the public eye, and help make him the focus of a movement with a history of violence against exactly these kinds of targets (including Tiller himself, who had already been shot). In those circumstances, flinging around words like “blood on their hands,” “pardon,” “country club” and “judgment day” was sensationally irresponsible.

All the wingers are trying to run from this incident of eliminationist behavior because they know they own this, just like they own the McCain/Palin mobs that gleefully unleashed their hate before the cameras. No, this assassination of George Tiller is on your hands.

More below the fold.

Feministing has more information on what people can do about this event - which is domestic terrorism.
 
Dr. Tiller's murder: What you can do

In comments to my previous post on the killing of Dr. George Tiller, AnatomyFightSong asked,

I would love to hear people's thoughts on how we can mobilize to (non-violently) fight back. How can we turn this terrible tragedy into an opportunity to strengthen the pro-choice movement?

It's hard to know how to respond to something like this with more than just sadness and anger. A few suggestions on what to do with that energy:

Attend a memorial vigil for Dr. Tiller.

  • Wichita, KS: Meet on Sunday at 8pm in Old Town Square.
  • Lawrence, KS: Meet on Sunday night at 8pm, South Park Gazeb
  • Washington, D.C.: Meet at the fountain at Dupont Circle at 9pm Sunday. Also at 6:30pm on Monday at the White House.
  • Boston, MA: Meet at 6pm on Monday, June 1 at St. Paul's Episcopal Cathedral.
  • Seattle: Candlelight vigil in Seattle on Monday, 6pm.  Details TBA. (Follow @ProChoiceWA on Twitter for details.)
  • Portland, OR: Meet at Pioneer Courthouse Square on Monday at 8:00pm
  • Ottawa, ON: Meet at 8:00pm on Tuesday, June 2 at the Human Rights Monument @ Elgin & Lisgar
  • Kansas City, MO:Meet on Monday, June 1 at 8pm at the JC Nichols Fountain (near the Plaza).

If your city/town isn't listed, plan a vigil yourself!

Donate to a pro-choice organization.

Discuss how this is connected to the daily intimidation of abortion providers all over the country.

  • Write letters to your local media when you see this framed as an isolated incident, or as the act of just one extremist. Explain how this is connected to the broader issue of threats and intimidation against women's health care providers.
  • Encourage your friends and family members who aren't pro-choice to reject groups that endorse or support extremist behavior.

Thank an abortion provider!

People who work and volunteer in reproductive health clinics (both those that provide abortions and those that don't) risk their lives every day to ensure women's health and freedoms are protected. They also deal with a lot of harassment and crap that might not be physically dangerous, but is a huge mental burden and daily stress. Let's use this as an opportunity to recognize their commitment, and say THANK YOU!

***

There’s also some good reading here by Andrew Belonsky—Pro-Life Feminism Births a Great – and Inexhaustible – Debate: The rise of ‘pro-life feminism’ raises endless questions on the real meaning of the F word. I wonder how that crowd is taking this news about Dr. Tiller? Also, check out Greg Sargent’s: “Time To Revisit Criticism Of DHS Report On “Right Wing Extremists.”

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Pam Spaulding on 12:24 PM • (30) Comments

Fire, crowded theater, all that ...

Blame the victim, too.  How ... predicable.

Comment #1: Ms Kate  on  06/01  at  12:27 PM

If I were Dr. Tiller’s next of kin I would be preparing a civil suit against O’Lielly.

Comment #2: Steve LaBonne  on  06/01  at  12:38 PM

O’Reilly frequently suggested that the clinic was covering up for child rapists (rather than teenage boyfriends) by refusing to release records on the abortions performed.

Or, more likely they were following HIPAA laws which explicitly outlaw releasing patient information?

God, I hope O’Loofah gets hit by a bus.  Fucking piece of shit.

Comment #3: DTG in STL  on  06/01  at  01:01 PM

One against Randall Terry, too, since the murderer posted his idea of joining Tiller’s church on that site and Terry has come out tap dancing in his glee that a “mass murderer” has been killed.

Terry is an imam of hate, no different from Bin Laden.  If you don’t think he’d be happy to see this happen across the country, read his statements.  He won’t even refer to Tiller as “Dr.”, but as “Mr.”

It’s terrorism, and it’s buried inside the paper b/c terrorism against women doesn’t matter.

Comment #4: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  06/01  at  01:03 PM

I don’t think the fact that he was murdered in a church is getting enough attention.  Seriously, how good of a Christian can these jack asses be if they’re gunning down people that are in church?

Comment #5: Spooky Skeptic  on  06/01  at  01:05 PM

Stupid mouse.  I wasn’t ready to blaspheme yet.  To finish, I think we can use this incident as a very quick and effective to dismantle the ovarian subjugation movement’s claims to moral superiority and this idea that they’re doing God’s work.  I’m pretty sure that Jesus would say killing a guy in a church and plotting serious unrest in and around a church is way worse than an abortion.

Comment #6: Spooky Skeptic  on  06/01  at  01:08 PM

And the Most Idiotic and Monstrous Response of the Day award goes to:

This weekend an abortion performer was terminated. Because this was illegal it was not carried out in a safe manner, but instead by gunfire in a crowded church. Terminating abortion performers should be rare, safe, and legal.

Since the Constitution erects a High Wall of Separation between Church and State we must not let our religious opposition to vigilante killings get in the way of our public policy decisions on terminating abortion performers. We must also realize that every termination of an abortion performer is a tragedy for everyone especially the terminator. It is never a decision taken lightly.

Furthermore social justice cries out that we should no longer allow the wealthy to fly to some Moslem kingdom where they can stone an abortion performer to death quite legally, while the poor are relegated to shooting them by ambush and being imprisoned for it.

To think that Justice Anthony Kennedy is all that stands between reality and this guy’s sick fantasy.  It makes me want to thank Arlen Specter all over again for borking Bork.  But this is what we’re up against, people.  Some of our opponents just have no idea of the difference between a theocracy and a civil society.

Comment #7: BABH  on  06/01  at  01:12 PM

I’m pretty sure that Jesus would say killing a guy in a church and plotting serious unrest in and around a church is way worse than an abortion.

Clearly you’re not familiar with the blonde-haired, blue-eyed, Rambo-muscled, kicker of Jew-moneylender-in-the-Temple arse brand of Jeebus that these hateful nutbars believe in. That macho Jeebus is right on board with what you describe.

Comment #8: Gracchus.  on  06/01  at  01:17 PM

If I keep thinking about this, I get so pissed off. Almost enough to go enroll in med school myself—never mind that I didn’t major in the sciences…

I mean, if it’s true that only two doctors performed the late-term abortions Tiller specialized in, this really fucking hurts—not just emotionally, but practically as well. For all the women with life-threatening eclampsia, birth defects, or other medical reasons for late-term abortions, we’re down to one provider. If “pro-life” terrorism doesn’t stop, it can, realistically, achieve its sick, warped aims.

Who in med school now has the courage (and financial wherewithal) to replace Tiller?

Comment #9: mllerustad  on  06/01  at  01:26 PM

“So how does O’Reilly feel about the assassination of George Tiller?”

...no doubt with a glee he can barely restrain while on camera.  After all, he and Limbaugh and Hannity and all the others are our very own Lewis Protheros...

Comment #10: MikeEss  on  06/01  at  01:27 PM

After all, he and Limbaugh and Hannity and all the others are our very own Lewis Protheros…

I love how they cast a Chris Hitchens look-alike for that role in the movie. These crapweasels don’t give a damn about the particular brand of extremism and controversy they’re pushing—as long as it works to get them attention and money, they’ll roll with whatever works.

Comment #11: Gracchus.  on  06/01  at  01:31 PM

How does O’Reilly feel about the assassination of George Tiller?

On June 12, 2007, he said, “Yes, I think we all know what this is. And if the state of Kansas doesn’t stop this man, then anybody who prevents that from happening has blood on their hands as the governor does right now, Governor Sebelius.”

Right there.  He says anyone who doesn’t stop Tiller has blood on his/her hands.  He’s said that the legal system, which Governor Sebelius represented, has blood on its hands for not prosecuting Tiller.  He said that anyone who doesn’t stop Tiller is guilty of baby killing.

He’s going to “address the issue” tonight on his show, and try to claim that he didn’t cheerlead for this to happen, b/c he’s really a nice guy, just a bit abrupt on camera.  But make no mistake.  He considered Tiller a ‘baby killer’ and advocated violence against him.

Fucking terrorists all.

Comment #12: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  06/01  at  01:56 PM

BABH, who’s the souce of that quote?

Comment #13: kaninchen  on  06/01  at  02:46 PM

They aren’t all running from it, though! They are collecting reax at DailyKos now that are less than full-throated denial:

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2009/5/31/737300/-Homegrown-jihadists

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2009/6/1/737552/-Hal-Turner:-let-the-terrorists-win

Interestingly, I also caught Malkin this morning pointing out that all “mainstream” anti-choice groups have condemned the violence. Not to say that any of this undermines her point, but it kinda undermines her point. She wants to align herself with right-wing terrorists when she’s complaining about DHS persecuting her for her politics, and then this happens.

The Eliminationists really have departed for another planet.

Comment #14: humanadverb  on  06/01  at  02:52 PM

kaninchen:  A well-respected lawyer in the conservative movement with a storied appellate practice, including arguing before the Supreme Court.  I am not at liberty to give his name.

Comment #15: BABH  on  06/01  at  03:04 PM

Kaninchen, BABH: Just throw the quote into Google and you come up with a transcript at Fox News: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,281861,00.html

Use ctrl-f to find it, down towards the bottom. Your welcome.

Comment #16: humanadverb  on  06/01  at  03:17 PM

Clearly you’re not familiar with the blonde-haired, blue-eyed, Rambo-muscled, kicker of Jew-moneylender-in-the-Temple arse brand of Jeebus that these hateful nutbars believe in. That macho Jeebus is right on board with what you describe.

http://www.theonion.com/content/news/christ_kills_two_injures_seven_in?utm_source=onion_rss_daily

Comment #17: Steve LaBonne  on  06/01  at  03:21 PM

Randall Terry held a presser at the National Press Club to try to make the case that the eliminationist, womb-controlling, domestic terrorism movement that spawned an act of domestic terrorism is not to blame. I don’t think this press release will actually help him on that front—he sounds like a madman. Here’s his version of “It’s not my fault”:

Mr. Terry states: “We must not fear, we must not flinch, we must not retreat a single inch. George Tiller was a mass murderer, and we must continue to say so in his death just as we did in his life.

“The pro-life movement must not be browbeaten by Obama or the child-killers into surrendering our best rhetoric, actions, and images. We hold absolutely NO responsibility for his death.

“We must continue to call abortionists ‘murderers’ according to the teachings of the Church; we must continue to peacefully expose and protest them; and we must continue to show the bloody remains of children that died at the hands of Tiller and his kind.”

Comment #18: Pam Spaulding  on  06/01  at  03:38 PM

Randall Terry, not Terry Randall. Had to look it up.

I keep thinking about RICO. Damnit, I need to understand the law better.

Terry also makes a point that the only problem he has here is that Tiller didn’t receive a jury trial. My mind goes to that common law grand jury the tinfoil crew has been trying to pull together, to start a prosecution around Obama’s birth certificate. You look at Terry’s statement here, and he clearly believes in and endorses a parallel legal regime outside of our constitutional ones.

I need to stop thinking about this for a while. Idle speculation is taking me to dark, frustrating places. This is bigger than the lone-nut thing. (Are we calling them lone-wolves, now?) It always has been.

Comment #19: humanadverb  on  06/01  at  03:51 PM

Clearly you’re not familiar with the blonde-haired, blue-eyed, Rambo-muscled, kicker of Jew-moneylender-in-the-Temple arse brand of Jeebus that these hateful nutbars believe in. That macho Jeebus is right on board with what you describe.

Uh-huh.

Comment #20: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  06/01  at  04:21 PM

Because a young teenager who received an abortion from Tiller could, by definition, have been a victim of statutory rape, O’Reilly frequently suggested that the clinic was covering up for child rapists (rather than teenage boyfriends) by refusing to release records on the abortions performed.

Or maybe Tiller is protecting rape victims from further harm.  We all know what rape prosecution is dismal in this country, and if this particular girl was raped by someone she knows (which is the most likely case), then her life could be in danger if the rapist found out that she was pregnant, or that she had an abortion, or that she told someone (the doctor) about the pregnancy.  The point is clear: O’Reilly wants many, many women to die.  He also wants men to die if those men don’t also want women to die.

Comment #21: bananacat  on  06/01  at  04:54 PM

Nice one, PiaToR. Kreider, as usual, is spot-on about this stuff. Here’s a working link:

http://www.thepaincomics.com/weekly050504.htm

Another version of Macho ‘Murkin Jeebus in this article about Mars Hill Church.

Comment #22: Gracchus.  on  06/01  at  05:15 PM

Will the Southern Poverty Law Center take a case from Tiller’s family? I know they usually go after folks who’ve committed hate crimes based upon race, but I think this is a hate crime and someone like them should take the Tiller family’s case pro-bono. Or once the cops catch this despicable murderer, a sweep of his computer should yield tons of info about who to bring a civil suit against.

Comment #23: DC Fem  on  06/01  at  05:17 PM

Here’s a working link

Are you telling me I messed up AGAIN!?!?

Lo, for Caren’s HTML Gods have visited their wrath upon me!  Surely, I am but a pawn to ther evil schmes!  Slowly bat surely, mi ability to commumincate shal bi takin from mi, an I shel bee raduced to nottin but bable!  SUX R TI WIGES UF UNBELIF!!

FKC!! Hrof wren gurh, thum tru hromon! Crat ma tref, per joad, per hery, per dago?

Trey hork li, grd flock flock flonk.

Matherthakrs!

Comment #24: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  06/01  at  06:51 PM

Are you telling me I messed up AGAIN!?!?

Nah, it’s one of those wonky artist/photographer’s sites: if they’re not gumming things up with Flash, they’re Framing things left and right.

Comment #25: Gracchus.  on  06/01  at  07:05 PM

I would love to see Tiller’s family and/or the Colorado dr. sue O’Reilly, Terry, et al for defamation. How can they get away with calling people murderers and criminals on TV? Are libel laws no longer in effect at all?

Comment #26: Dorothy  on  06/01  at  09:59 PM

or all the women with life-threatening eclampsia, birth defects, or other medical reasons for late-term abortions, we’re down to one provider.

I wonder: if a woman dies because a needed abortion is not available due to lack of providers, could her next of kin sue these pro-life groups for contributing to her death?  I’d hate to see anyone die like this, but if they keep it up, it will: women will die from easily-preventable complications, and given the nature of such things, I rather doubt we’d see that many live babies resulting.  This is not an absolute-value math question—-sending the mother to her death along with a fetus that won’t survive either way is not a net positive.

We need to get this truth out, because the antis have the field here—-the general public hears “late-term abortion” and they think “baby that can live,” never mind the reality of severe birth defects or legitimate likelihood of survival if the mother dies out from under them at five months along, never mind grieving parents facing the reality of a wanted baby that won’t survive no matter what they do, never mind that husbands and children and family and friends and the women themselves don’t want expectant mothers to be dragged into death along with their babies like a funeral sacrifice when a pregnancy goes disastrously wrong—-these are the hidden realities, and normal empathetic people are suckered by lies and pretty pictures (and ugly ones) into supporting policies that would trade a woman’s life for a minor shift in timing and method of her fetus’s death.

That’s all it is here.  They want women to die so that they can take whatever comfort they take in dead babies being killed by natural causes instead of abortion.  It’s like Mrs. Lincon knowing all about the assassination plot at Ford’s Theatre and didn’t warn Abe away from seeing the play with her because she wanted company.

Comment #27: Kyra  on  06/01  at  10:22 PM


Who in med school now has the courage (and financial wherewithal) to replace Tiller?

This is why I am calling for an immediate replacement of conventional everyday patriarchy with masculinity, for a change.

Comment #28: scratchy888  on  06/02  at  04:51 AM

Yall keep sayin these folks want women, and sometimes men, to die like that’s shocking. These people love death. It gets the good people to heaven faster, and the bad people to hell faster.

Comment #29: Bacopa  on  06/02  at  08:36 AM

“Pro-Life” should never be used as their moniker.  They are “Anti-Choice”.  In the event the mother’s life is in danger, they would prefer letting the mother die.  This is not “Pro-Life”....it is “Anti-Choice”.

Comment #30: redford  on  06/02  at  01:22 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.