Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Post-Racial My Black Ass Previous entry: Why don’t men read more romance novels?

Teabagging racist-email-sending Dr.: ‘I’m not a bigot, I did a counseling day for black Boy Scouts’

TPM has caught the conservative movement with its racist pants down again. Actually, we saw so much racist garbage during the campaign from the low-information Base that it was no surprise to find out the Teabagger movement and is apesh*t not just about taxes, but the fact that we have a black president.

On Sunday night, Dr. David McKalip forwarded to fellow members of a Google listserv affiliated with the Tea Party movement the image below. Above it, he wrote: "Funny stuff."

Asked about the email in a brief phone interview with TPMmuckraker, McKalip said he believes that by depicting the president as an African witch doctor, the "artist" who created the image "was expressing concerns that the health-care proposals [made by President Obama] would make the quality of medical care worse in our country." McKalip said he didn't know who created it.

After being busted for this bottom-of-the-barrel trash behavior, the Florida Medical Association condemned McKalip's bigoted email and called for an apology. McKalip had his nuts in a vise, so I'm sure it pained him to type this one out:

"I genuinely regret the decision I made in passing this e-mail message along.  Directly to President Obama, I sincerely apologize for offending him. This was,  in no way whatsoever, my intention. The image has nothing to do with my feelings or thoughts on any race or culture. I recognize that this image is offensive and hope that the nation refocuses on assuring all Americans have access to high-quality, affordable health care with no party interfering in the patient-physician relationship. My intention is to focus directly on the issue at hand, which is putting financial and decision-making power into the hands of patients and taking it from government and insurance companies," said McKalip.

Yes, we are to believe that the first image that comes to mind when you think of the current president is that he runs around a bone through his nose dressed as a a loincloth-clad witch doctor as he discusses health care reform.

I'd like to say that this was the end of it, but we're talking about conservatives, right? Specifically the kind of conservatives who talk a big game about personal responsibility except when it comes to themselves. Case in point —McKalip's not sorry for what he did, he's mad at the humorless Left for finding out about his jocularity and ruining a perfectly good joke. Besides, he can't be racist, because, well, he helped out them pickaninnies once:

In an interview yesterday with the St. Petersburg Times, which picked up the story, he declared: "I am not a racist. I am simply a person speaking up to make sure patients don't get hurt by the government and by insurance companies.''

As a defense against the racism charge, he noted, in the paper's words, that he had "helped organize a career counseling day several years ago for African-American Boy Scouts." And he blamed liberal activists for touting the email, which he called a "satire."

Perhaps someone should buy him a membership to The Valley Club.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Pam Spaulding on 03:51 AM • (25) Comments

This sounds like what Cambridge cop Crowley said.  Is this the new “get out of disgrace” card? “I can’t be a racist because I once [gave CPR to Reggie Lewis] [spoke to black children]”?

Comment #1: NobleExperiments  on  07/26  at  04:16 AM

forwarded to fellow members of a Google listserv affiliated with the Tea Party movement

I suspect the Tea Party people have turned into a Little Green Echo-chamber.  They’re all in a little rosboat talking to each other, with no-one at teh oars, and the boat is drifting further and further away from the coastline of sanity…

Even if you are a big friggin’ racist, how the hell can you forward something like this as “funny” unless you assume teh groups you’re sending it to regards it as legitimate comment?

Comment #2: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  07/26  at  04:28 AM

Oh hell, my spelling has gone all to shit this evening.  Sorry, people.

Comment #3: Phoenician in a time of Romans  on  07/26  at  04:29 AM

As sick to death of these constant bone-headed racist jokes I am, in a way I hope they keep it up. Of course, it’s easy to say as a white, heterosexual, male, but let’s lance the boils and let them drain. Let’s let all of the children who have friends of every race see this, and see with whom they are dealing. Disgraceful.

Comment #4: Seebach  on  07/26  at  05:58 AM

Oy, when will people learn that the word “satire” is not fucking magical? Squirting it out like a startled squid squirts out ink doesn’t mysteriously make your racism not racist. Satire is the style, not the content. Saying that the picture isn’t racist because it’s satire makes about as much sense as saying that “The White Man’s Burden” isn’t racist because it’s a poem. Which is none.

Comment #5: Sophist FCD  on  07/26  at  06:11 AM

NobleExperiments:

Is this the new “get out of disgrace” card?

It’s not new. It’s just a slight variation on the “I’m not racist because I have a black friend” excuse, which is as old as racism itself.

And yes, “satire” is one of those words, like “irony” and “socialism,” that I wish we could somehow exempt from freedom of speech, in that the misuse thereof ought to be a crime. Like an actual criminal crime, not just a civil matter.

Comment #6: Dan, Grand High Emperor of Bananas Foster  on  07/26  at  06:43 AM

I think that conservatives believe “satire” is the word for “something mean and political that I think is funny.” which is not, strictly speaking, the literary definition.

Comment #7: bethany  on  07/26  at  09:09 AM

TPM had a follow-up yesterday of another email Dr.McKalip sent to his tea-bag friends in which he made it quite clear how unrepentant he is. I called one hospital he’s affiliated with and spoke with an administrator and let her know his behavior and lack of remorse was appalling. I sent an email to the other hospital he’s affiliated with to express similar disgust.

I found the contact info via dailykos (search Dr. McKalip) and the links took me to blogger drivingvolvo.

Comment #8: revrick  on  07/26  at  09:11 AM

And people wonder why feminists don’t like the “humorless” label.

“It’s just a JOKE.”

Why do all those mean lefties have to make the poor doctor feel dirty by pointing out it’s racist, and that only racists find that kind of racial “humor” amusing?

Comment #9: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  07/26  at  09:24 AM

*applauds latest conservithug move roundly*

So if a conservithug has a gun in real life, are they actually able to shoot anything other than their own foot?

Comment #10: speedbudget  on  07/26  at  09:38 AM

“So if a conservithug has a gun in real life, are they actually able to shoot anything other than their own foot?”

Of course, but only abortion doctors, black “suspects”, and liberals who are dragging down ‘Merica…

Comment #11: MikeEss  on  07/26  at  09:59 AM

I’m fairly certain that keeping a running tally of every not-asshole thing you’ve done for a non-white person is a pretty good sign that you’re a racist.

Comment #12: pennylane  on  07/26  at  10:15 AM

“I’m fairly certain that keeping a running tally of every not-asshole thing you’ve done for a non-white person is a pretty good sign that you’re a racist.”

Well, the good news is that with so few examples it’s pretty easy to remember them all…

Comment #13: MikeEss  on  07/26  at  10:31 AM

I once helped an older black woman cross the street, and even carried her grocery bag!

I’m not a racist.

Comment #14: Ranylt  on  07/26  at  11:19 AM

You know what?

It is possible to be a white person and not racist.  It is possible to be a not-racist white person, and still do racist things.  White privilege and ignorance and following institutional practices can have people who really aren’t racist behaving in a racist manner.

Most white people who are not racist are appalled to discover that something that they did or said was unknowingly racist.  Plus, we feel stupid for not realizing we were being assholes.

But when you dress the President of the United States up in witch doctor apparel with a bone in his nose—obviously racist imagery—you don’t get to say, “It was just a joke!  I’m not really racist b/c I helped out some black kids once upon a time so shut up and leave me alone!”

It’s not just a joke.  Most people do not find it funny.  Finding it funny means approving of racist imagery.

You notice how no one is giving him shit over the “Obamacare” with the sickle in the logo?  Calling him a socialist and using the old Soviet logo is a jerk move, but it’s not a racist joke, and you can actually make (bad) arguments that unfettered capitalism is better for the country than anything that remotely resembles our former rivals.

Criticizing Obama is not a problem.  Comparing him to Soviets, while intellectually weak, is not the problem.  Dressing him up in a racist trope is.

If you find racist jokes amusing, you’re a racist.  Being a racist is not a good thing, and you should be shunned over it.  That’s actually the only positive about this ordeal—Poor racist doctor doesn’t like being called a racist b/c he knows it’s not a good thing.

He doesn’t mind actually being racist, but he knows it’s not good to wear that label in public.  It’s progress.

Comment #15: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  07/26  at  11:47 AM

And whoever made that crap couldn’t even find a picture of an African for the photoshop - that gear looks Papuan to me.

Comment #16: Wareq  on  07/26  at  01:32 PM

One career day in “several years”?
And what exactly does “helped organize” mean? Could mean anything from “was the primary mover that really made it happen” to “helped by declining to actively oppose it.” 
If this is what he can come up with, well, I guess he really loves African-Americans.

Comment #17: Jebediah  on  07/26  at  04:42 PM

Directly to President Obama, I sincerely apologize for offending him.

Gaaaaaahh!!  Because the problem with this is that some random jerk off offended Barack Obama, right?

Comment #18: jTuba  on  07/26  at  04:44 PM

Why did he choose the picture of Obama that has the best “Are you really this stupid? Really?” expression I’ve ever seen.

I’m not even sure what the point of the witch doctor image is, other than making a really racist joke. Obama will bring unscientific “medicine” into the public option? Obama knows nothing about medicine? Obama has poor choice in Halloween costumes?

Comment #19: limes  on  07/26  at  04:56 PM

When I read bloggers reflexively assume that the police report is reliable in any way, I just get more upset because it’s just more evidence that a whole lot of people out there are more naive about power and authority than you’d think.  Is it really possible that so many of my fellow Americans have never been on the receiving end of unfair treatment from a bunch of asshole cops?

I think this is a real problem: most conservatives and moderates and large number of nice white liberals are just that naïve, or possibly willfully blind. So let me point to a nice academic paper by a nice tenured academic - Christopher Slobogin.  http://www.constitution.org/lrev/slobogin_testilying.htm

The first clue to how common police lying and deceit are is the term “Testilying”. That term was invented by police to describe their commonplace habit of committing perjury while testifying. How commonplace: Let me quote from the article:

In one survey, defense attorneys, prosecutors, and judges estimated that police perjury at Fourth Amendment suppression hearings occurs in twenty to fifty percent of the cases. Jerome Skolnick, a veteran observer of the police, has stated that police perjury of this type is “systematic.”  Even prosecutors — or at least former prosecutors — use terms like “routine, “commonplace,”  and “prevalent”  to describe the phenomenon. Few knowledgeable persons are willing to say that police perjury about investigative matters is sporadic or rare, except perhaps the police, and, as noted above, even many of them believe it is common enough to merit a label all its own.

Follow the link to the article to see Slobogin’s sources for this.

Christopher Slobogin; ” Testilying: Police Perjury and What to do About It” ; University of Colorado Law Review Rev 1037;67; Fall 1996; http://www.constitution.org/lrev/slobogin_testilying.htm

While the article deals with a number of issues, and comes to conclusions I disagree with, there are two critical points I think it makes. One is that lying in police testimony and police reports is commonplace and routine. The other is that police officers routinely back one another up when lying.  So the triumphalism we sometimes see about other officers backing up Crowley is meaningless. It is even more common for officers to back up each other’s lies than to originate lies in the first place. It would be extremely rare indeed for a second officer to fail to support what the first says in an official report.

And it is rare indeed for a police officer for lying to get them in trouble, even when caught. Once case I’m personally familiar with was a local activist who was always the peacemaker at demonstrations. She spent a great deal of time trying to persuade protestors not to act like assholes. And in one case there was some civil disobedience where people were blocking traffic for not very good reasons. And she tried to persuade them to come back to the sidewalk. The police, who were excellently position to see what was going on arrested her for blocking traffic and (I think this was a while back) incitement. And the prosecutor went to trial with five officers testifying against her. Fortunately for Anna, the demonstration was videotaped from beginning to end. (Very fortunate -no cell phone cameras, cheap digital cameras at the time.)  So she was acquitted, and the prosecutor publicly admitted she was not guilty. (Olympia is a very unusual town.)  No one even considered for a moment charging any of the officers who testified against her with perjury. As far as I know they were never even reprimanded.  Police officers lie routinely. Those lies are usually believed, and even when they are not it is very rare for an officer who has provably committed perjury to suffer any consequences for doing so.

It is one thing to point out for the sake of discussion that even if every allegation made about Gates is true that he should have not been arrested. It is quite another, and seems to be commonplace among commentators, to assume the police reports are more reliable than Gate’s own testimony, and to assume they are true until proven false.

Comment #20: Gar Lipow  on  07/26  at  07:20 PM

The above comment was posted by me in this thread instead of where I intended. I have since posted in the right thread. Because it is long, I think it may be a pain in the ass to scroll past, so you might want to delete it. Thanks and sorry

Gar

Comment #21: Gar Lipow  on  07/26  at  07:26 PM

Wasn’t it Palin who brought some witch doctor to town to preach about how he and others bullied elder women?

Comment #22: Ms Kate  on  07/26  at  11:26 PM

RE: accidental racism.

as everyone knows (because i talk about him a lot) my boyfriend/fiance/live-in-lover/Nigel/Whatever is black.
which should prove that *I* am not racist, right? especially a’cuz i’m Cherokee, and was raised that way, right?

does anyone remember a thread, maybe 13 or 14 months ago, where i was beating myself up. because i now have to walk with a cane, and i was going to a building on campus, and a guy (a big guy. i mean *really big*) jumped up to open the door for me, and i spent about 2 seconds panicked, because “oh what do i do BIG black guy is getting up and coming towards me to…..... oh, he’s trying to help the disabled chick. dear *gods*, Elizabeth, WTF was *that* all about?”


yeah. it happens - most of the media message we get about non-white people is overwhelming negative - Mexicans are all lazy, drifting, dirty bums who are going to steal your jobs (and the cognitive dissonance to believe that sentence is exhausting); blacks are all lazy, violent hyper-sexualized criminals who are going to steal you stuff, including your wife/girlfriend/daughter; asians are all super-genius perverts who are going to steal your *jobs* and your wife/girlfriend/daughter AND hack your systems (and the bank and everything else) and clean you out -

there are so few non-evil portrayals of non-whites in the media that i actually think it’s a wonder that there aren’t racial lynchings going on *EVERYDAY*.

i don’t even know how to fix it. i mean, almost nothing on TV (including the fucking *news*, most of the time) has any resemblence to reality at *all*.
generally, if its some sort of “cast” there’ll be *A* non-white person, the “token”, which is now nothing more than a joke, used by everyone…
if it’s a cop-type show - not *all* the bad guys are non-white - but all of the VIOLENT bad-guys tend to be non-white - the only crimes that white people appear to commit (on TV) are either white-collar crimes or domestic violence (which everyone knows isn’t a crime if the woman is *yours* ::GAG::)

how are we supposed to move past racial stereotyping and racist bullshit if the majority of the populace has no experience with anyone different from themselves *EXCEPT* for what they see on the TV?
i mean, sure, even white-collar managerial types must have POC working for them - but they always think that the POC working for them are the *exceptions*, that those specific POC have “turned their backs” on their culture and upbringing and are trying to become “white” (no, really - i was one of the assistants on a huge study started this year at OSU about this - most white people think that the POC they meet in college or offices or similiar areas are POC who are trying to assimilate into white culture, that they are not at all representational of POC, and that *most* POC ARE like are shown on TV, and that the POC they meet in these “non-traditional for POC spaces” are to be respected for trying to “become better” and ARGH!)

how do we fix it?


(MS Kate - that, btw, is HILARIOUS! i did actually laugh out loud. pissed Pete off, because i woke him up. but VERY worth it!)

Comment #23: denelian  on  07/27  at  03:55 AM

I don’t know, denelian. Of course, everyone who writes or casts actors can directly impact the media problem. Anyone who works with children can try to counter the racial narrative of our culture. Better critical thinking skills in general, so that people will cast aside falsities, would be good.

Comment #24: Samantha Vimes  on  07/27  at  08:29 AM

Maybe the Real President secretly declared this to be Unrepentant White Guys Month.

Oh, wait. That’s every month.

Comment #25: paul  on  07/27  at  11:51 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.