Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Parallels and Priorities Previous entry: So how does O’Reilly feel about the assassination of George Tiller?

The “non-violent” anti-abortion activists

I want to elevate this comment by Sarah in Chicago to illustrate what I mean when I say that just because your average anti-choice activist doesn’t shoot doctors doesn’t mean we should laud them for non-violence.

I’ve stood outside women’s clinics and done clinic escorting, I’ve seen the looks of fear on the faces of women as they duck down to avoid the harassment of the anti-choice ‘protesters’.

I’ve seen these ‘protesters’ repeatedly and flagrantly break federal and state laws to confuse, lie to, and mislead women driving into women’s clinics.

I’ve seen these ‘protesters’ purposefully wear outfits similar to ours in order to appear to be working for a clinic, I’ve seen them use props to seem official, I’ve seen and heard them scream harassment across parking lots, over hundreds of feet from them.

I’ve seen these ‘protesters’ set up video recording equipment, not to record because that is illegal and has been banned, but without recording materials in them, so that it’s obvious their only intent is to intimidate.

I’ve heard my name used by these people after I had been doing clinic escorting for a short while, as well as them knowing details of where I was from, what and where I was doing my doctorate, etc ... and they said it amongst themselves loud enough so that they made sure we could hear.

Even the ones that don’t go after those providing reproductive services wielding guns, bombs, etc aren’t like protesters that protest other things they are trying to get changed. If they were, they would be outside political entities, outside congress-people, outside the White House. No, these ‘protesters’ stand outside hospitals and health centres, clinics and providers. They actively try to harass, intimidate, guilt-trip, etc both the women accessing necessary services, and the health-provision providing them.

They aren’t protesters, they are specifically here to generate fear and scare people away. They may not kill directly, but they are most emphatically are using fear to cower people into achieving their political ends, to impose their worldview on everyone around them.

And that’s terrorism ... it doesn’t always require a bomb or gun to achieve such, but that’s only a small step from the fundamentally similar ways they act.

Oh, and I only stopped clinic escorting when where I had been doing such didn’t need us anymore, as the protesters had given up ... I’m wondering if they may be needing us back again soon.

To be clear, this doesn’t mean the armchair supporter of abortion bans is violent, but if they go out to clinics to intimidate women, obviously their intention is to get their jollies by scaring women they believe are jezebels.  But I have to ask the armchair anti-choicers this: How come the violence inherent to the movement doesn’t make you ask the hard questions?  It should be clear that if you support state-mandated childbirth, you’re pushing for violence to control women’s fertility.  At some point, you need to own this reality.

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Amanda Marcotte on 02:46 PM • (15) Comments

I am so glad we have the most stupid protesters in the country.  They came out stood on the corners near the Planned Parenthood (it’s set back off the street behind another building in a small complex) and only held up signs.  Granted the signs were disgusting and way over the top but they didn’t say a word just hold up their posters for the passing cars to see. Oh and did I mention all this was on a Sunday mid-morning across the street from a shopping mall when it wasn’t even opened?  It was like a church field trip.  While I was waiting for the left turn light all I heard was a few cars roll down their window and tell these protesters that they were disgusting.

Comment #1: Amalink  on  06/01  at  02:58 PM

“State-mandated childbirth” and “government-forced childbearing” are brilliant locutions.  They’re by far the most accurate representation of the reality over which we’re fighting, and demonstrate the hypocrisy of the stance of the anti-abortion crowd, who claim to be for “freedom” and “small government” in everything…  except matters of sex, gender, and religion.  (They also imply the essential misogyny of the movement.) 
I wish more of the lefty blogosphere would adopt your terminology.

Comment #2: smartalek  on  06/01  at  03:05 PM

But I have to ask the armchair anti-choicers this: How come the violence inherent to the movement doesn’t make you ask the hard questions?

Your usual armchair anti-choicers (as distinct from the feces-flinging trolls) are not going to show up in these threads, because (and this is the answer to your question) they’re intellectual cowards. Guys like Dana and EricJG understand that Pandagon isn’t the MSM: here we actually call people on their reality-challenged BS.

Comment #3: Gracchus.  on  06/01  at  03:07 PM

Sarah in Chicago’s comment is 100% truth.  Those forced birthers are there to terrorize patients and employees and for no other reason.  Anybody who has been there can confirm this as fact.

At some point, you need to own this reality.

But they don’t need to own it.  It serves no purpose for their goals for them to own it.  In fact, it works at cross purposes to them.

If you were to say, “At some point, in order to be a decent person, you need to own this reality,” that would be different.

That OR hasn’t been shut down for being a terrorist organization is an embarrassment to the US.

Comment #4: Jake Squid  on  06/01  at  03:20 PM

Every movement has fringes.  Ours, theirs, all of ‘em.  However, the more radical the mainstream of the movement is the more radical the fringes will be.  If the so-called middle is batshit crazy and stops just short of calling for violence it almost assures somebody on their fringe will take that last step.  As sure as night follows day.  If the center is mildly lawless, the fringe will be more so.

So yes, you Operation Rescure freaks, the blood is on your hands too.  There is precious little moral difference in wishing someone dead and pulling a trigger.

Comment #5: Magis  on  06/01  at  03:31 PM

I’m a clinic escort and the protestors we get aren’t physically violent, and obey the local laws about protesting 99% of the time.  They are mostly older white men and members of the Knights of Columbus. The protesters shout things at the patients, like “Keep your baby alive! We can help you!” and “Don’t do it! You will regret it for the rest of your life!”

The most sickening thing part when the doctor shows up. They see his car coming and their eyes light up as if they were kids who just saw Santa Claus. They start to scream, “MURDERER!” “THERE’S BLOOD ON YOUR HANDS DOCTOR!” It’s like the two minutes hate, and they are really enjoying it. They remind me of a crowd at an arena when the home town team scores a big win. It’s terrifying.

Comment #6: MissCherryPi  on  06/01  at  03:32 PM

“There is precious little moral difference in wishing someone dead and pulling a trigger.”

True, but when you see everything as a part of “God’s Plan”, it’s pretty easy to make yourself believe it was an “Act of God” that killed Dr. Tiller and not some insane fundnut who overdosed on wingnut Koolaid…

Comment #7: MikeEss  on  06/01  at  03:51 PM

Agree 10 million percent with SiC’s comment.

Comment #8: Colin  on  06/01  at  04:22 PM

Years ago I volunteered at as a patient escort at a small women’s clinic.  It was, in fact, so small that, unfortunately the patients’ waiting area sat in the front of the building separated from the sidewalk by two large plate glass windows (blinds always drawn, of course).  One of our regular protesters was a guy who showed up every Saturday in camouflage from head to toe and would stand on the sidewalk in front of the patient area screaming at the top of his lungs “Mommy, don’t kill me” “Mommy, please let me live” and other assorted shit and we would have to escort patients around this asshole.  At least until the cops, as they always did, came in and hauled his ass back across the property line. 

These are scary, scary people.

Comment #9: MissyAnne Thrope  on  06/01  at  04:26 PM

So much for disavowing it: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/06/01/AR2009060102058.html?hpid=topnews

Comment #10: pseudointellectual  on  06/01  at  04:35 PM

Reading all this has made me become interested in volunteering as an escort.  Are there any specific organizations I can get involved with, or should I just find a local clinic and arrange it with them?  If I knew of any protests, I would be very tempted to hand out Bibles to the protesters, with the passages highlighted that clearly show that abortion is not murder.

Comment #11: bananacat  on  06/01  at  05:15 PM

catgirl—in DC and surrounding areas there’s an org that does it separate from the clinics and helps out any clinic that wants it. I think in NYC they do it clinic-to-clinic. If you’re in either of those places I can put you in touch with people, otherwise try just going to a clinic any given Saturday morning and talking to the escorts about it. (We’re a friendly bunch.)

Comment #12: Colin  on  06/01  at  05:25 PM

Emotional violence is still violence.

Comment #13: Karmakin  on  06/01  at  05:45 PM

catgirl -

Here in Chicago I’ve done it through the NOW chapters, who are the ones the clinics contact and ask for trained escorts ... the NOW chapters then solicit for volunteers and train them up. Get hold of the NOW chapter in your area perhaps? I mean, even if they don’t do it themselves, they will probably know who does.

I really enjoyed it, and it was fantastically fulfilling ... I will admit though there were some times it was hard ... like middle of winter and the temperatures were in the negative degrees fahrenheit and you have to stuff those chemical hand-&-foot warmers into your shoes and gloves, or in the middle of summer and it’s over 100 degrees with high humidity.

The nice thing in those often was realising that we would turn up and they often wouldn’t; showing how we were more committed to preserving the rights of women, than they were in tearing those rights away.

I mean, sure, there were moments that were downright scary, tho nothing physical (I’m 5’10” and athletic, so I can intimidate well ... though I had a friend who was 5’1”, and she could do that too). But some of the looks of gratitude I got from women accessing the services were so worth anything.

Comment #14: Sarah from Chicago  on  06/01  at  06:25 PM

Reading all this has made me become interested in volunteering as an escort.

Me too. I just applied with Planned Parenthood a little while ago.

Comment #15: junk science  on  06/01  at  06:58 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.