Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: About the media “exclusives” Previous entry: Glockapella

To Play Through Pain And Love The Game

This Joe Klein piece on Obama’s passion (or lack thereof) has been getting some play in light of his choice of Scranton’s finest.  The gist of it is that Obama isn’t showing his emotions, is too nuanced and cerebral (please browse 2000 and 2004 for the rest of the complaint). 

But when you start talking about Obama needing to act more passionate, angrier and more outspoken, isn’t the single most obvious guarantee from such a move that he’ll be called out for acting like a preacher, and channeling Jesse and Al?  The model of prominent black politicians is so narrow and so artificially dominated by those two men that it invariably draws comparisons - and has for much of Obama’s candidacy.  That’s the problem with the “passion” argument in a nutshell.  The more outspoken and outraged Obama acts, the closer he gets to a preexisting model into which he can be shoehorned.

 

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Jesse Taylor on 12:10 PM • (14) Comments

You know, Obama was my fourth choice for president, and I still have some real policy disagreements with the man, but from a politics/campaigning standpoint? The third time I was positive I knew what he should do or say and he did or said something else and it was way smarter and better than what I thought he should do or say, I decided I would stop bloviating about what he needs to do and say.

Comment #1: Rick Massimo  on  08/23  at  12:32 PM

Why would Obama need to become more passionate? His running mate is Raiden for crying out loud.

Comment #2: Incertus, Nacho Daddy  on  08/23  at  12:40 PM

I didn’t realize that being President was the same as being Bela Karolyi, sorry?

This is one of those double binds that Dems always face.  If you’re animated and play to people’s emotions, you’re Mussolini.  If you’re sober and logical, you’re a dead fish.

Only Republicans have the right combination of charisma and gravitas to lead, I guess.

Comment #3: The Opoponax  on  08/23  at  12:42 PM

Incertus, I think you’re on to something there…but really, if the god of lightning was going to disguise himself as a human, couldn’t he have at least picked a name that didn’t rhyme with his real one?

Comment #4: smadin  on  08/23  at  12:55 PM

Shoehorned…and marginalized.

Thanks for the concise, on-target observation.

Comment #5: blip_blap  on  08/23  at  01:00 PM

he’ll be called out for acting like a preacher, and channeling Jesse and Al

I could swear I’ve seen more than a few people already accusing him of that this election season.  Because any black man who’s at a podium’s trying to act like a preacher, don’t you know.

Comment #6: Jennifer  on  08/23  at  01:04 PM

Joe is a total fuckwad. He puts all his indignant angry pieces online but when it comes to print, he falls back to questioning Dems on everything. He wont put the indignant pieces calling the sky blue because doing so might mark him as a dirty fucking hippe and he just cant have that now, can he?

Total fuckwad.

Comment #7: M.O.  on  08/23  at  01:30 PM

Sexism and racism aren’t ideologies, they’re contradictory grab-bags of stereotypes. For every bigoted stereotype, there’s an equal and opposite stereotype. As long as a culture shares a stereotype library, it’s possible to switch back and forth between mutually contradictory stereotypes without anyone noticing the logical absurdity: Hillary’s tough, and Hillary’s a cry baby. Hillary rode her husband’s coattails, and she cynically engineered the Clinton dynasty. Obama’s a rock star, Obama’s tepid, Obama’s a celebrity…

Comment #8: Lindsay Beyerstein  on  08/23  at  02:02 PM

Lindsay’s right. And the power to name is the power to define.

Comment #9: Roxanne  on  08/23  at  02:39 PM

Jokeline does what, as you point out, he has always done, damned if you damned if you don’t.  No one is good enough.  And, like Howard Dean, if the man ever showed any authentic passion, in the manner of that millions of us, it would be recorded, edited down, enhanced and played back millions of times in demonstration that he just wasn’t presidential enough.

Jokeline, and the rest of the village, if karma means anything, will suffer some cruel days at some point.  And that doesn’t even begin to address their negligence, just their hubris and hypocrisy.

Comment #10: ice weasel  on  08/23  at  03:09 PM

The more outspoken and outraged Obama acts, the closer he gets to a preexisting model into which he can be shoehorned.

 

I thought that was the idea.

If he can be squeezed into a mockable pre-existing stereotype, the info-refractors of the media get to play that up instead of the actual Obama.  They’ve been trying to—part of the ‘elitism’ accusation is “We can’t get him to play Stepin Fetchit.”

Comment #11: D. Potter  on  08/23  at  03:19 PM

I always figured Obama was angry in the way Jon Stewart was angry: furious about what’s being done to his country, but staying in control nevertheless. Stewart and Obama don’t rant and rave (well, Stewart does, but comically), but they stay on point, they stay focused, and there’s no doubt anger helps keep them that way.

Comment #12: Erl  on  08/23  at  03:52 PM

This is one of the biggest upsides of the Biden pick - he can be a vicious attack dog for Obama, so Obama doesn’t have to play the “angry black man”.

Comment #13: DTG in STL  on  08/23  at  08:37 PM

I could swear I’ve seen more than a few people already accusing him of that this election season.  Because any black man who’s at a podium’s trying to act like a preacher, don’t you know.

And the irony of that is that for roughly 30 years, the Republicans have incorporated “national motivational preacher” into the job description of president. Now that the Democrat is better at it than the Republican, suddenly not so much.

Funny how that works.

Comment #14: Rick Massimo  on  08/23  at  09:25 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.