Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: Stupid on purpose Previous entry: Dusting off anti-artist sentiments for today’s faux outrage

UPDATE: PA state investigation finds Valley Club did discriminate against minority kids at its pool

L-O-S-E-R-SRace

(By the way, brace yourself if you venture into the comments of the linked news article. It’s another reality check about post-racial America…)

After all the protestation that the club wasn’t run by bigots, the state found the Valley Club in Huntingdon Valley, Pennsylvania was run by bigots. The report is damning and I have some screenshots in the post.

You’ll recall that the Creative Steps Day Camp paid $1900 to swim in the camp’s pool during the summer and when they showed up, this was the reaction.

“When the minority children got in the pool all of the Caucasian children immediately exited the pool,” Horace Gibson, parent of a day camp child, wrote in an email. “The pool attendants came and told the black children that they did not allow minorities in the club and needed the children to leave immediately.”

...“There was concern that a lot of kids would change the complexion … and the atmosphere of the club,” John Duesler, President of The Valley Swim Club said in a statement.

That didn’t go over well, and it only got worse when the next defense is that there weren’t enough lifeguards assigned to watch that large a group of kids. Unfortunately that was a big whopper of a lie, because in the report findings, there is example after example of parties that size or larger with few restrictions, certainly none of them turned away. Also, the Human Relations Commission report stated the Valley Club had 155 paid membership in 2009 and 179 in 2008, none held by an African-American. A few screenshots to peruse of the reactions of some Valley Clubbers:



Nice. And this:

Valley Club tried in 2009 to expand its membership by recruiting in areas outside its township - Lower Moreland, which has a 0.8 percent black population - mailouts were “mainly directed at areas with overwhelmingly Caucasian populations” including Rhawnhurst, Fox Chase and Churchville.

The more-diverse townships of Cheltenham and Abington, like other nearby areas with “significant African-American populations,” the report says, were passed over.

What a surprise! So this was the fine levied…

The commission ordered the club to pay a $50,000 civil penalty for the club’s discrimation again one child, whose parents filed the complaint with the commission.

The report also orders Valley Club to pay other damages, including reimbursing the parent who filed the complaint for all related expenses. If there is no settlement made between the parent, the club and the commission, either party can request a public hearing before the commission and can after that be challenged in court.

The $50,000 civil penalty is to be paid to state government, under terms of the finding.

Related:

* Black kids booted from Philly club’s ‘whites-only’ pool
* ‘Complexion’ of black camp kids not a problem at new pool
* Too little, too late for the Valley Club

 

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Pam Spaulding on 07:34 AM • (24) Comments

So they didn’t do some kind of class-action?  Only the one kid’s parents are getting any kind of compensation?

If the discrimination occurred, it happened to all the children.  There should be a $50,000 per child, in my opinion.

Comment #1: speedbudget  on  09/23  at  08:41 AM

I bet this kid feels great about going back to school and seeing his racist asshat teacher again.  I’m sure there’s no reason to worry that she’ll be discriminatory in the classroom, especially after he traumatized her so by going for a swim in her presence.

Comment #2: libdevil  on  09/23  at  09:24 AM

I bet this kid feels great about going back to school and seeing his racist asshat teacher again.  I’m sure there’s no reason to worry that she’ll be discriminatory in the classroom, especially after he traumatized her so by going for a swim in her presence.

Jesus, no shit. Somebody needs to be keeping a VERY close eye (and a dossier) on that teacher. What a classic example of somebody who shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a classroom.

Comment #3: Steve LaBonne  on  09/23  at  10:05 AM

I’d be willing to bet that Michelle Flynn has either already resigned or will soon. She will, of course, claim that she was the real victim here.

Comment #4: Scott  on  09/23  at  10:22 AM

Speedbudget, it is my understanding that the commission’s finding does not impact pending litigation on the basis of state and federal civil rights violations.  The lawyer for the kids’ camp was on TV today saying they would be seeking civil damages which seems about right.  I hope all these kids get enough money to pay for college.  And I hope Michelle Flynn gets run out of the school system.  Jesus.

Comment #5: pennylane  on  09/23  at  10:24 AM

Jesus, no shit. Somebody needs to be keeping a VERY close eye (and a dossier) on that teacher. What a classic example of somebody who shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a classroom.

I was just happy to see her name and position publicized. There’s a good piece of information for all the parents in that school district to have.

I skimmed the report, and noticed the Valley Swim Club is a non-profit organization, and not merely a “private club” as Walt Slowinski believed. Nonetheless, the Creative Steps Day Camp paid a membership fee of nearly $2000 to have the kids swim there once a week for a couple of months. Slowinski’s interpretation of this was that kids were being ‘bussed’ - niiiiice - to the pool as part of a social program run by the Valley Club.

He paid his dues, damn it; and one of the unwritten benefits of being part of a “private club” is no darkies!

If only the report had listed his place of employment as well.

Comment #6: Nil  on  09/23  at  10:37 AM

I predict the ironic result of the plaintiffs (the kids and their parents) ending up with ownership of the pool.  If the club is a non-profit organization, incorporated, it likely has no substantial assets other than the pool and insurance won’t cover the judgments.

Comment #7: MiddleageLiberal  on  09/23  at  11:13 AM

This can’t be true.  It just CAN’T.  Just the other day I heard some guy on Fox say we’re living in a post-racial America, and Obama is the proof.

Why are these little black children (or pickaninnies, as I call them) lying about the way they were treated?  WHY DO THEY HATE AMERICA?

/remove tongue from cheek/

Comment #8: ummeli  on  09/23  at  11:25 AM

I can sympathize a bit with the members who were surprised to see a whole bunch of non-members show up to use the pool—not with their racism or the idiot assumptions that led to. Even if they all were bussed from Bryn Mawr, you’d expect your fellow pool users to be as carefully vetted as you were.

But the fault lies with the club president—a PR man by profession who should have known he had to prepare the members to expect a bunch of black kids coming over once a week. The justification was simple: the pool needs money to keep going; letting non-members swim is part of that.

If you want only members to use the facility, be prepared to pay more for your membership.

Comment #9: Hector B.  on  09/23  at  11:25 AM

Racism?  In America?  Never!
Somehow I doubt this story will ever make it onto Faux Spews or Limpballs show.

Comment #10: DrDick  on  09/23  at  11:27 AM

MiddleAgeLiberal, that’s what I’m hoping - I’m hoping the Creative Steps Day Camp winds up with its own pool.

Comment #11: purpleshoes  on  09/23  at  11:48 AM

Whenever the right-wing talk about Obama ushering in a post-racial society, what I hear is “Ok we’ve given you what you wanted, we bribed you blacks with a black president, in exchange you guys don’t get to ever call racism on anything, EVER!”

Comment #12: BlackBloc  on  09/23  at  12:07 PM

“Somehow I doubt this story will ever make it onto Faux Spews or Limpballs show.”

It might make it, but only as an example of Political Correctness Gone Wild!, and how Sneaky Trial lawyers use those Negroes and Mexicans to ruin everything good about American Society one lawsuit at a time…

Comment #13: MikeEss  on  09/23  at  12:12 PM

I hope all these kids get enough money to pay for college.

That is an ideal outcome, but I doubt that will happen.

Even if a civil suit produces a settlement on that scale (many millions of dollars), the kids will probably never see a dime… the club will simply go out of business and file for bankruptcy.

This isn’t the Augusta National Golf Club, it’s a little non-profit racist swim club in suburban Philly.  I doubt they have the kind of scratch to pay out a massive 8 figure settlement.

That said… I’m completely OK with seeing this club getting sued into non-existence and then handing the club’s property over to the parties that were harmed.  But the kids aren’t gonna be getting millions out of a civil suit, because I really don’t think the club has millions of dollars to pay out.

Comment #14: DTG in STL  on  09/23  at  12:18 PM

I’m hoping the Creative Steps Day Camp winds up with its own pool.

I see four problems with this:

1. I don’t think the Creative Steps Day Camp can afford to operate its own pool.
2. The pool is not convenient to the Day Damp, being located eight miles away.
3. The primary market for the pool is white racists, who likely would quit or be repelled by a pool owned by and for black people.
4. The pool is losing money, so the resale value is dubious.

Comment #15: Hector B.  on  09/23  at  12:21 PM

On the other hand, I was very happy that the new principal of my sons’ middle school came down hard on some little turd who was harassing an Asian friend of my older son.  The kid’s idiot parents had to come in to learn what their idiot darling had been up to, and why it wasn’t acceptable.

Racism isn’t something that will go away overnight, but if some of the next generation know it is bullshit and the rest are repeatedly taught to restrain themselves, we are getting somewhere.

Comment #16: Ms Kate  on  09/23  at  12:22 PM

I’m hoping the Creative Steps Day Camp winds up with its own pool.

I see four problems with this:

1. I don’t think the Creative Steps Day Camp can afford to operate its own pool.
2. The pool is not convenient to the Day Damp, being located eight miles away.
3. The primary market for the pool is white racists, who likely would quit or be repelled by a pool owned by and for black people.
4. The pool is losing money, so the resale value is dubious.

Good points.

I think the most likely outcome is that the parents and children are going to be awarded a huge settlement, the Valley Club will file for bankruptcy and forfeit all of its assets, and the property will wind up being sold off to a third party, with whatever money comes from the sale being divided among the children’s families… and it’s not gonna be a whole lot of money when all is said and done.

But this club will have been shut down, and that will still be pretty significant in and of itself.

Comment #17: DTG in STL  on  09/23  at  12:39 PM

Back to add that I find it absolutely nuts that this teacher said what she said in front of those kids.  I used to teach, and all the teachers I knew—whether liberal, conservative, racist, or no—were very circumspect about the things that came out of their mouths in public.  You never knew who was around.  Things get back to the wrong (or right) person, and you’re either out of a job or wish you were.

I can’t get over the audacity of this teacher saying these things in front of her own student.  I find it hard to believe she didn’t know what she was saying was utterly and completely racist, and I find it even harder to believe that even if that were true she didn’t know what she was saying would, at the very least, hurt the feelings of the kids around her.  To be that heartless and still be a teacher. . .I am flabbergasted. 

She didn’t have to be such a douche, you know?  She could have pasted on the polite smile we all do when we’re really pissed, packed her kids up with some words about “being late for an appointment” and written a nasty letter to the management to let them know how she feels about “those people” being in her pool.  I mean, come on.  Has she no class?

Comment #18: speedbudget  on  09/23  at  01:39 PM

Here’s betting they sent a mailer to those in the borough of Jenkintown, which is completely surrounded by Abington (mine) and Cheltenham (Reggie Jackson’s) townships and is 4% African-American, compared to 11 and 25%, respectively.

Comment #19: Dr. Squid  on  09/23  at  02:31 PM

To be that heartless and still be a teacher

I had some teachers who were that shitty, although they never said anything racist as far as I know.

Comment #20: keshmeshi  on  09/23  at  03:53 PM

I mean, come on.  Has she no class?

No.  She’s a racist piece of shit.

I know, it’s hard to believe in 2009 people can still be such ignorant fucks, but there you have it.

Comment #21: Caren-Sun-blocking Creator of Animorphic Pancakes  on  09/23  at  06:50 PM

I had some teachers who were that shitty, although they never said anything racist as far as I know.

Unfortunately, there are plenty of rank assholes who enter the teaching profession at all levels…especially K-12.  One high school teacher I had who took pleasure in belittling and torturing his students did so to such an extent that I did my utmost to insult and drive him up the wall to encourage him to retire sooner. 

And what’s with snotty Profs at some Ivy schools who feel entitled to insist that all questions pertaining to lectures/classes are to be directed to their TAs/TFs or worse, literally running out of the class as if the undergrads s(he)‘s forced to teach are dangerously infected vermin?!!

Comment #22: exholt  on  09/24  at  01:23 AM

Yeah, exholt, I had a bully teacher who picked out a couple of kids every year to belittle in front of his class. My brother had him to and let me know it was the guy’s standard operating procedure.
Only my year, with him, it didn’t work. At least 5 of us heckled him every time he tried to single out one of the struggling students for his contempt. I don’t know why things worked out that way—I guess we did have older siblings or friends who knew a bit about his weaknesses so we could get under his skin—but a couple months in, he learned that he wasn’t going to *enjoy* opening the class up to taunts and focused on actually teaching.

Comment #23: Samantha Vimes  on  09/24  at  07:27 AM

I mean, come on.  Has she no class?

Only if she gets fired. ::rimshot::

I can understand people getting cranky that a bunch of kids comes to the swim club without any warning or newsletter or what have you. Paying to use a pool means you’re entitled to a heads’ up, “Hey, a bunch of day camp kids will be here on these days.”

But the racial component is ugly and unconscionable.

Comment #24: Red Stapler  on  09/24  at  01:07 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.