Login

Register

Member List

RSS Feed

Amanda | Contact

Auguste | Contact

Jesse | Contact

Pam | Contact

Next entry: GLAAD/Harris post-election survey: Americans favor adoption and partner rights for same-sex couples Previous entry: So who’s “fat” now?

Utah: State Sen. Buttars proposes resolution mandating retailers use ‘Merry Christmas’

Ultra wingnut and homobigot Chris Buttars clearly thinks that the state of Utah has no business to attend to in the state Senate. The lawmaker jumps into the 2008 War on Christmas fray (a little late, I might add), with this lunacy:

Utah state Sen. Chris Buttars told Salt Lake City’s Deseret News that he’s drafting the non-binding resolution because several employees at a retailer told him they were instructed not to say “Merry Christmas” to customers.

I’m sick of the Christmas wars,” Buttars told the Salt Lake Tribune. “We’re a Christian nation and ought to use the word.”

...Utah Senate President-elect Michael Waddoups said a resolution lacking the impact of law is really just a message being sent, but, he added, “Sometimes you have to send a message.”

Salt Lake City civil rights attorney Brian Barnard, however, warned Buttars that asking for “Merry Christmas” is fine, but basing the resolution on America being a Christian nation was taking it too far.

“If [Buttars] wants people to say ‘Merry Christmas’ because it’s the Christian thing to do,” Barnard told the Tribune, “then it becomes a violation of First Amendment rights.”

Buttars responded with this brain-dead statement (why is this mental giant in office?)—

the majority of Americans celebrate Christmas as a Christian holiday because the United States is a Christian nation.

“We started that way and we still are,” the senator said.

BTW, besides being a racist (x2), homophobe and defender of intelligent design, Chris Buttars also proposed a bill earlier this year that would allow police to withhold misconduct reports from the public, including those infamous Tasing incidents. Nice.

------

Registration is now required! We're still in the process of getting it all squared away, so for the moment don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper left menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Pam Spaulding on 10:10 AM • (42) Comments

Buttars responded with this brain-dead statement (why is this mental giant in office?)

Because somebody has to make US Rep Uppity Ten Commandments (R-Georgia) look stellar.

Comment #1: Ms Kate  on  12/03  at  10:20 AM

Interesting that the guy can’t tell the difference between making it so that people can wish other people Merry Christmas as they wish, which would make sense, and making everybody say Merry Christmas when they might not observe Christmas or observe it in a Merry fashion.

Comment #2: Ms Kate  on  12/03  at  10:22 AM

Chris Buttars is part of my theory that there’s more concentrated kookery in every inhabited square mile of Utah than anywhere else in the nation. You just have to live there for a few years to really understand it. (Having a polygamist wife trying to get me to join her Amway downline was just the tip of the iceberg when I lived there.)

That said, can you please not sent us to WorldNutDaily? This article was in the Salt Lake Tribune as well, and I don’t feel dirty when I click on those links.

Comment #3: mirele  on  12/03  at  10:30 AM

Imagine being Buttars’ wife or kid. That’s gotta be one effed-up household dynamic with him in the house.

Comment #4: Orange  on  12/03  at  10:42 AM

There’s always the free market angle to convince Republicans.  The market has decided to say Happy Holidays.  It turns out that unfettered free markets are not very Christian.

Comment #5: D2  on  12/03  at  10:42 AM

Why not shoot the works and pass a law declaring Christianity the official, mandatory, state religion of Utah, and outlawing all others?  (And atheists?  You better church up or else…) After all, that’s what he and his kind really want, isn’t it?

Of course, the irony of being a state senator of a state whose majority religion isn’t considered to be Christianity by wingnuts in other states is pretty amusing.  Or would be if the level of stupidity and arrogance wasn’t so frightening…

Comment #6: MikeEss  on  12/03  at  10:53 AM

”“I’m sick of the Christmas wars,” Buttars told the Salt Lake Tribune.”

So is everyone else with an IQ above room temperature.  Put down your holy book, shaman, and walk away…

Comment #7: MikeEss  on  12/03  at  10:56 AM

This is incredibly stupid, even ignoring the fact that not everyone celebrates Christmas.  Everyone knows “Christmas” season in the retail world starts in mid-November.  Who wants to feel like an idiot saying Merry Christmas before we’ve even had Thanksgiving?

Comment #8: acallidryas  on  12/03  at  11:04 AM

Useful idiots they’re called.  And they are, indeed, both.

Comment #9: ice weasel  on  12/03  at  11:37 AM

These guys never disappoint… retardedly awesome.

Comment #10: atheist  on  12/03  at  11:42 AM

Everyone knows “Christmas” season in the retail world starts in mid-November

Mid-November?

Mid-November?

The “Christmas” season around here started November 1st.  Halloween ended and pop - Christmas stuff was out right next to the paltry selection of Thanksgiving decorations.  Fliers started coming in the newspapers about “early Christmas shopping” and the TV news reporters started doing their yearly stories on retailers preparing for the holidays.

Like Rep. Buttars, I too am so very tired of this “Christmas war”.  I wish that Christmas would retreat back to the month of December and let Thanksgiving have its month back.  At this rate, Halloween is going to get drawn into the Christmas war as well and soon elves and goblins will be having gun battles in the streets as the defenders of Halloween fall before the might of the powerful Kringle juggernaut.

Comment #11: NonyNony  on  12/03  at  11:42 AM

The “Christmas” season around here started November 1st. 

‘Round here, we tend to see Halloween stuff boxed up and moved off the aisles before Halloween, so they can move the Christmas junk in.

Comment #12: Scott  on  12/03  at  11:49 AM

Fuck it, I’m just going to quote IOZ:

The gradual erosion of “Merry Christmas” in favor of “Happy Holidays” doesn’t mark a moral retreat in the face of religious multiculturalism or anti-Christian laïcité. It marks the commerce-driven extension of a shopping season, one that now extends from before Halloween to the post-New Year sales. “Happy Holidays” isn’t culturally inclusive; it’s commercially inclusive.

Comment #13: Dunc  on  12/03  at  11:51 AM

At this rate, Halloween is going to get drawn into the Christmas war as well and soon elves and goblins will be having gun battles in the streets as the defenders of Halloween fall before the might of the powerful Kringle juggernaut.

Mmph, I’m already annoyed at the local churches in my area fear-mongering every Halloween / Samhain about “poisoned candy” (show me ONE case where it didn’t turn out to be the parent, seriously) to try to depress neighborhood turnout and redirect to the “safe” church where they can try to proseletize to the kids when Mommy and Daddy aren’t watching.

Comment #14: Ellen  on  12/03  at  12:15 PM

Where’s zombie Thomas Jefferson when you NEED him?

Comment #15: MsAnon  on  12/03  at  12:51 PM

Everyone knows “Christmas” season in the retail world starts in mid-November.

Man, I wish they’d wait until mid-November.  We had Christmas crap in Los Angeles by about October 1.

Maybe Buttars should make everyone say “Merry Christmas” year-round since retailers keep pushing it earlier and earlier anyway.

(I don’t know if they still do it, but Nordstrom used to refuse to put up any Christmas decorations until the day after Thanksgiving.  At some point, they had to start putting signs up to explain themselves since every other goddamn retailer from Rite-Aid to Macys was putting their stuff up by mid-October.)

Comment #16: Mnemosyne  on  12/03  at  12:56 PM

Ah.  Utah.  Whatever would we do without Utah? 

Is there any way we could simply excise the entire land area of that state from the planet and sent it off into the Sun? 

Jeebus

Comment #17: LL  on  12/03  at  01:03 PM

The courts would slap this down before you could say “establishment clause”.

Comment #18: Entomologista  on  12/03  at  01:04 PM

I wish that Christmas would retreat back to the month of December and let Thanksgiving have its month back. 

Not me. I consider the extension of Xmas into November to be an admission of surrender that they can’t successfully turn Thanksgiving into a stupid fucking marketing vehicle like they have with every other holiday. Instead it manages to mostly be about a bunch of people getting together and having a nice dinner together, only intermittently marred by the occasional idiot who insists on going shopping at 3am the next day.

Comment #19: dan  on  12/03  at  01:31 PM

So let me get this straight:

It is equally okay for non-Christian workers to be forced to wish someone a merry Christmas, and for health care workers to deny health care to patients based on their own beliefs.

Comment #20: BetsyD  on  12/03  at  02:00 PM

Wield your Merry Christmas like a sword!  It’s not a sometimes inappropriate pleasantry; it’s the core of your self-expression as a Christian!

Really, will conservative Xtians *ever* get over their martyr complex?

Comment #21: deep6  on  12/03  at  02:32 PM

Seeing that guy’s name makes me think of the character Butters from South Park.

How about we have a mass calling to Buttar’s office wishing them all a “Happy Holidays!”

Comment #22: Tommykey  on  12/03  at  02:37 PM

Utah Senate President-elect Michael Waddoups said a resolution lacking the impact of law is really just a message being sent, but, he added, “Sometimes you have to send a message.”

And what exactly is that message? “Nice store you’ve got there. Wouldn’t want any new zoning or fire-safety laws to come around and ruin it” is the only message I can discern. I haven’t been to church in decades, but I don’t remember the bit about the Shaking-Down of the Temple.

Comment #23: Rick Massimo  on  12/03  at  02:59 PM

I love that it’s a MORMON who came up with this. A religion widely believed to be a phony cult.

No irony there.

Comment #24: Southern Beale  on  12/03  at  03:25 PM

Happy Holidays has been the standard for as long as I remember, so at least 25 years.  What is the matter with these people?  Get. A. Life.

Comment #25: keshmeshi  on  12/03  at  03:30 PM

“The courts would slap this down before you could say “establishment clause”.”

...and the Fundnuts, the wingnuts, and other assorted Republicans would be crying about “Activist Judges!” about a second later…

Comment #26: MikeEss  on  12/03  at  03:47 PM

Man, that cute little kid from South Park sure grew up to be a choad.

Comment #27: Captain Bathrobe  on  12/03  at  04:02 PM

His delusions of what a state senator from a lightly-populated salt flat can do nationally reminds me of this jailhouse conversation:

Hans Moleman: Are you really allowed to execute people in a local jail?
Rev. Lovejoy: From this point on, no talking.

Comment #28: norbizness  on  12/03  at  04:20 PM

Tommy/Bathrobe: Eccomi!

Comment #29: norbizness  on  12/03  at  04:23 PM

There’s a pattern here: The same people who think that their marriages are threatened if some other people are allowed to get married also think that their holiday is threatened if some other people’s holidays are acknowledged.

“Season’s Greetings” and “Happy Holidays” have been expressions for this time of year since literally as long as I can remember. In fact, I’ll bet that’s been the case as long as Buttars can remember.

It’s as good a demonstration of the utter, slack-jawed mental vacuity of the religious Right as you’re likely to see: O’Reilly or Limbaugh or some asshole from their church/ward/what-have-you tells them that innocuous, obviously friendly expressions they’ve been hearing their whole lives are now fighting words—and they buy it.

(And here is a musical depiction of this mindset.) (mp3, NSFW)

Comment #30: Molly, NYC  on  12/03  at  04:24 PM

And this, friends, is yet another reason why stupid people shouldn’t be allowed to have jobs.

Comment #31: Dan, Grand High Emperor of Bananas Foster  on  12/03  at  04:28 PM

This atheist celebrates Christmas because it’s a pagan holiday as well as a damned good time. 

If those uptight christians hadn’t usurped it we’d still be putting up lights on evergreen trees, eating special foods, staying up late, giving each - oh, we are still doing those things.  Go figure.

These guys are pretty insecure, eh?

Comment #32: Caveat  on  12/03  at  05:07 PM

It is my sincerest Christmastime wish that Mr. Butter’s law is enacted and enforced nationwide and that Navy Seals are put behind every cashier in the country, ready to slice their throats from ear to ear if they don’t wish the Baby J*sus Happy Birthday with every sale.  It may take a few examples to get the point across, but stringent enforcement may be required to bring law and order back to this Christian nation of ours, to keep it from becoming a Muslin Caliphate.

Comment #33: Rugged in Montana  on  12/03  at  05:09 PM

Everyone knows it’s Buttars—it’s STUPID!

Comment #34: Samantha Vimes  on  12/03  at  05:57 PM

Looks like folks have already taken the South Park jokes, so I’ll have to take the even lower road and rename the venerable senator Butt-arse.

Comment #36: Lauren O  on  12/03  at  06:11 PM

Heil Christmas!

Comment #37: M. Peachbush  on  12/03  at  06:30 PM

Seeing that guy’s name makes me think of the character Butters from South Park.

I tend to read it as “Butt-arse”, myself, which is both appropriate and makes me snicker like a twelve year old.

Comment #38: Lisa  on  12/03  at  06:33 PM

Senator . . . Nutter Butters?

Comment #39: deep6  on  12/03  at  07:06 PM

As a Utah resident and practicing Wiccan (guess that makes me unamerican), I just want to say what many, many residents of Utah say when we hear this sort of crap over and over.

Shut up, Butters.

(BTW, he won the ‘boner of the day’ award on one of our local morning shows for this particular bit of innanity. He, um, wins that award a -lot- around here.)

Comment #40: Phoebe  on  12/03  at  07:29 PM

I did a little checking, and as I thought, this fine, upstanding citizen-legislator is a proud member of the LDS Church, a returned missionary in fact.  As such, I wonder why he’s making such a fuss about American being a “Christian nation” when his own church is considered heretical by the very members of the Religious Right who came up with the War on Christmas in the first place?

Comment #41: Ellid  on  12/03  at  08:57 PM

There’s a sucker born every minute, Ellid….

Comment #42: annejumps  on  12/03  at  11:08 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.