Next entry: Uruguay 1-1 (4-2 PEN) Ghana: The most heartbreaking loss ever? Previous entry: Why We Watch

Netherlands 2-1 Brazil: Fluke upon fluke upon giant fail

Felipe Melo: Looking happy for possibly the last time in his life.
Having picked the Netherlands to win this game in our predictions thread, it'd be nice to be able to gloat on this one. But those of us who picked the Dutch were lucky, not right; Brazil lost this game thanks to a mental meltdown no one could've predicted. Brazil dominated the first half. Robinho's opening goal was simplistic excellence -- he split the central defenders, took a pass right on his feet and stroked it home. Holland was on its heels the rest of the first 45, unable to build any attack or keep hold of the ball. Brazil could've easily had a 2 or 3 goal lead by halftime, particularly if Kaka's impression of the Luis Suarez winner for Uruguay last round hadn't been tipped away by the sparkling van Stekelenburg in net. Then the gods took a dump in the brigadeiros. Most days, Felipe Melo doesn't knock in an own-goal past the helpless Julio Cesar. In fact, Brazil had never given up an own-goal in the entire history of the World Cup. So that was unusual. Most days, Wesley Sneijder doesn't head in a corner for a goal. In fact, after the game, the diminutive Sneijder said it was the first time in his life he'd scored a header, that "it just went off his bald head" and in. So that was unusual. Most days, Felipe Melo doesn't stomp the leg of one of the game's great dramatic actors, Arjen Robben. I can't say Melo never gets hit with red, but had he not been saddled with the guilt of an own-goal, this wouldn't have occurred, either. That, friends, is a one-in-one-thousand recipe for an upset. There are other ways the Dutch could've come out ahead, but this particular brew was especially rare. Brazilian coach Dunga has been a target of scorn since being handed the reins, and now that one of his choices, Felipe Melo, was the goat of the entire tournament thus far, expect him to be handed his walking papers. Brazil's next coach will probably be someone with a cartoonish love of the attacking game to wash the defensive mentality from the mouths of the squad. I still think they had the right idea with this team, tightening up the back and letting explosive players like Robinho and Kaka loose on the break. But I suppose when your team gives up one mistake goal and then suddenly can't find anyone but Dutch players with their passes, starts fouling obviously and petulantly, and ultimately winds up at 10 men with over 20 minutes left in the game, the coach bears plenty of responsibility for that collapse. How could Brazil lose themselves so completely? And poor Felipe Melo. Will he ever be able to set foot in Brazil again? If anyone's grateful that Dunga will be the fall guy, maybe it's Melo; how else could he escape the full wrath of a Brazil fan base that still obsesses over a loss from 60 years ago? We haven't talked much about the Netherlands, but that reflects the nature of this game -- the first half was all about Brazil dictating terms, the second was all about them falling to pieces. Around them, the Dutch played up and down. They were lost, then buoyed by the fluke, then playing up a storm on all the obnoxious fouls by Brazil. Sneijder and Kuyt were good, Robben failed to impress, and van Stekelenburg kept his team in the game early on. But when Brazil had its head on straight, they were dominant, and I think they win this game 7 of 10 times or more. But not this game, not this day. And now the Netherlands finds themselves favorites to advance to the finals.

------

Registration is required! Don't forget to Login or Register using the links in the upper right menu before starting to write your comment.

Posted by Marc on 01:39 PM • Permalink

That goal should have been awarded to Sneijder, not Felipe Melo. It was going in anyway.

/on my fantasy team

Comment #1: Jeff  on  07/02  at  03:24 PM

From a scorekeeping perspective I can’t say I agree, but it’s certainly worth pointing out that Melo did need to get a touch on it.  He just didn’t get enough of the ball.

Comment #2: Ape Man  on  07/02  at  03:26 PM

I thought Melo barely touched it, and it’s not clear to me that the keeper would have stopped the goal without Melo’s interference. Own goal or not, the subsequent meltdown was amazing to watch.

Comment #3: John B.  on  07/02  at  03:54 PM

Do they even have any standard for what counts as an own goal?  I’ve seen it pinball off two players and they talk about how the striker makes God his bitch for his manly, manly power - conversely, barely being grazed by the ball gets own goal.  A certain English goal-jockey had about a thousand percent more to do with the trajectory of a certain American shot, and yet he’s not credited with an own goal.  It almost seemed like “how dare a non-Brazilian be credited with scoring - own goal” - I’m surprised they even let the Dutch claim credit for the other goal and didn’t give it to the last Brazilian to touch the ball

Comment #4: phalamir  on  07/02  at  09:38 PM

I’m shocked it is an own goal.  As I understand it, it should only be considered an own goal the ball would not have entered the net without the deliberate action of the defender.  So, an accidental deflection is not an own goal, but a botched attempt to play the ball is. 

Goalkeepers usually get the benefit of the doubt, a misplay by a keeper isn’t an own goal. 

This is an own goal (and a very costly one):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMHif1Nfbyw

This is not an own goal, even if they scored it as such:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYuthyVuIqs

Comment #5: James  on  07/02  at  10:18 PM

http://www.fifa.com/worldcup/news/newsid=1266860/index.html?cid=twitter_voiceofthesite#sneijder+credited+with+first+goal+dutch+quarter+final+victory

FIFA has now credited Sneijder with the first goal. I agree with the decision, Melo got only a slight touch on the ball and it would have gone in anyway if he’d missed it.

Comment #6: AndrewED  on  07/03  at  10:11 AM

Yes, it was a Sneijder goal. And as for the Dutch being lucky? They came into the game with one of only two 100% records in the finals (they’re now the only team) against a Brazilian team who’d only really impressed against an understrength Chilean team which gave them all the space in the world. I presonally predicted an extra time Brazilian win but in retrospect, I guess the pressure from the media back home and the squad’s apparent lack of faith in Dunga’s system obviously weakened them more than any of us thought, perhaps as much as those factors did the English.

Comment #7: Stubborn Kind of Fellow  on  07/03  at  01:39 PM

I’m glad to see that FIFA credited Sneijder with the first goal. He deserves it since the Brazilians didn’t alter the trajectory of the ball very much.

Comment #8: John B.  on  07/03  at  03:03 PM

Excellent news for Sneijder (and for Melo.)

Comment #9: James  on  07/03  at  10:35 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.